'I couldn't stay silent,' says Cree singer who performed powerful message for Pope Francis

Si Pih Ko sang a message in Cree to the tune of the national anthem following the Pope's apology to Indigenous people in Maskwacis, Alta., Monday. It resonated powerfully, and she told CBC News she'll do whatever it takes to share the pain of survivors.

Si Pih Ko was not reacting emotionally to the Pope’s apology, she says: she was rebuking him

Cree singer reveals message behind powerful Pope performance

1 year ago
Duration 2:55
Featured VideoSi Pih Ko captured the world's attention when she sang in Cree to the tune of Canada's national anthem after Monday's papal apology, then spoke directly to the Pope. Now, she is explaining what she said, and why.

WARNING: This story contains distressing details.

It was a raw, powerful moment that seemed to stop time — a song performed emotionally in Cree to the tune of Canada's national anthem by an Indigenous woman wearing traditional regalia.

In an interview Thursday with CBC News, Si Pih Ko, also known as Trina Francois, said the song lyrics were an ancient ballad to the land and the village. Other local language speakers have translated it as: "Our creator, keep our sacred land, Canada. Our land here, Canada. Our Sacred Land."

After she sang, over applause and cheering from the crowd in Maskwacis, Alta., Si Pih Ko spoke directly to Pope Francis in Cree, her voice strong in its anguish.

"You are hereby served spoken law. We, the daughters of the Great Spirit and our tribal sovereign members cannot be coerced into any law, any treaty that is not the Great Law," she translated later for CBC News.

WATCH | Si Pih Ko's message to the Pope:

Si Pih Ko sings in Cree after Pope's address in Maskwacis, Alta.

1 year ago
Duration 1:21
Featured VideoSi Pih Ko, also known as Trina Francois, sang a message in Cree to the tune of the national anthem in an unscripted moment during Pope Francis's visit to Canada.

"We have appointed chiefs on our territories. Govern yourselves accordingly. 'Hiy Hiy' does not mean 'Thank you.' It means that I have nothing more to say," she said to the Pope in Cree.

Si Pih Ko hadn't planned to speak during the ceremony to mark the first day of Pope Francis's "penitential pilgrimage" to Canada, but said she had to when the Pope was given a headdress and he put it over his skull cap, or zucchetto.

To her, that was a sign of disrespect.

"Silence is power, but I couldn't remain silent," she said later to CBC News.

'She took a stand'

In Edmonton, Métis Sixties Scoop survivor Brenda Hatt watched it all, tears running down her face. She said she felt — for the first time — like someone was speaking for her.

"She put her fist up in the air. That is a very strong symbolism across the world. She took a stand," said Hatt, 54.

A Cree woman raises her fist as she sings a message to Pope Francis.
Si Pih Ko, also known as Trina Francois, sang a message in Cree to the tune of the national anthem in an unscripted moment during Pope Francis's visit to Maskwacis, Alta., on Monday, July 25, 2022. (Adam Scotti/Prime Minister's Office/Reuters)

Growing up in English households, Hatt didn't learn her traditional language, so she didn't understand exactly what was being said.

But she said it resonated deeply. 

"You could feel the passion and pain in her voice," she said. "She spoke for a lot of people across Canada and the fact it's a woman is even that much more powerful."

The moment has been shared around the world on social media, with people saying they were shaken to the core, her pain like a knife to the heart.

Sixties Scoop survivor Brenda Hatt was one of many people who were deeply touched by Si Pih Ko's message to the Pope. She said she feels like it was a turning-point in her own journey to connect with her Métis roots. (Ty Ferguson/CBC)
A tweet is show where a person writes that she sobbed seeing the emotion in the song.
A Twitter reaction to Si Pih Ko's song performed in Cree during Pope Francis's visit to Maskwacis. (BSwirlsi/Twitter)

'She spoke from her perspective as a woman'

William Elvis Thomas was watching with pride from Si Pih Ko's home community of Nisichawayasihk Cree Nation, 800 kilometres north of Winnipeg.

"I love the fact that she had the courage to say what she said and to take a stand for what she believes in," said Thomas, who heads the community's Nihitho Language and Culture Unit.

Thomas knows Si Pih Ko personally and is also fluent in the specific Cree dialect she was speaking, "the language of the four winds or the four spirits," which has been passed down by elders living in northern Manitoba and Saskatchewan.

A tweet where a person writes "if my heart had a face" above an image of a woman singing emotionally.
A person writes 'if my heart had a face' on Twitter in reaction to Si Pih Ko's emotional song. (quoth_the_rave/Twitter)

Thomas said it's hard to translate the words precisely into English, but she used the term for the land of Canada, Kakanatahk, which means "that which is sacred." 

"She spoke from her perspective as a woman. She includes herself in the language when she speaks and she's saying that we are like a part of a sovereign group and we are the women of the group," Thomas said.

The message itself was a rebuke to the Pope, the Catholic Church and the colonizing countries of Britain and France, he said.

"They had no right to come in and do what they did to displace our traditional ancestral, sacred laws that we had in place," he explained.

"She's asserting that we still have that and that we wish that to be respected and that the Pope should acknowledge that."

'She spoke for many of us'

Back in Edmonton, Brenda Hatt says the message is even more powerful now that she understands it.

"She got our point across, not just her point, but our point across … That we're still here, that, even through all of this, all the hundreds of years of trying to wipe us out in Canada — and I don't say that lightly. There was a plan to genocide the Indigenous people of Canada. But you know what? We're still here."

Hatt said it feels like a turning-point in her own life.

William Elvis Thomas is an elder from Nisichawayasihk Cree Nation, Man., Si Pih Ko's home community. He knows her personally and said he was proud to see her stand up so powerfully for what she believes in. (Karen Pauls/CBC)

Taken from her mother by Alberta Social Services when she was just four weeks old, sent to what she describes as "horrendous" foster homes and later adopted at age 13 by a white family, she's trying to connect with her lost Métis heritage. Hatt recently learned her late grandfather was a residential school survivor.

"I lived in a foster home where she told me outright she was going to beat the Indian out of me and I didn't even know at that point that I was Indian or what Indian was. But I had that instilled in me at such a young age that it was something to be ashamed of, that I didn't look into anything to do with my familial lineage until I was in my 40s," Hatt said.

Hatt isn't religious and said the Pope's apology doesn't mean much to her, although she's glad he asked for forgiveness of all the survivors of residential schools.

Still, she'll take one thing forward from his visit this week.

"We can't change what's happened and we need to move forward, and we need to move forward together," she said. 

"And to belong to a group of people that have survived hundreds of years where they weren't supposed to survive is a powerful message. And her standing, stepping forward, putting your fist in the air and stating, 'We are still here.' How can anybody not be proud of her?"

An ongoing mission

Si Pih Ko says she's honoured by that response.

"I hope that it brings the people back to the land. Our way of life," she said.

An activist most of her life, Si Pih Ko is living in a teepee as part of a protest camp on the grounds of the Manitoba Legislature. She said this experience has given her more confidence to give voice to her ongoing battle against the child welfare system.

"I fought two years to get my little ones back, and it shouldn't have been like that," she said.

"Residential schools continue in the child welfare system, and if I had to ask the survivors today, 'What would you like me to do? To speak for the little ones today, that are in care?' Because I'll do whatever it takes. Your pain, your words, through me. I'll get it done."

Support is available for anyone affected by their experience at residential schools or by the latest reports.

A national Indian Residential School Crisis Line has been set up to provide support for former students and those affected. People can access emotional and crisis referral services by calling the 24-hour national crisis line: 1-866-925-4419.

Mental health counselling and crisis support is also available 24 hours a day, seven days a week through the Hope for Wellness hotline at 1-855-242-3310 or by online chat at


Karen Pauls

National reporter

Karen Pauls covers Manitoba stories for CBC national news. She has worked across Canada, U.S. and Europe, and in CBC bureaus in Washington, London and Berlin. Some of her awards include the New York Festivals for coverage of the Greyhound bus beheading and a Quirks & Quarks question show, and from the Radio Television Digital News Association for stories about asylum seekers, the Michif language, the Humboldt Broncos bus tragedy, live elections and royal wedding shows. In 2007, Karen received the Canadian Association of Journalist’s Dateline Hong Kong Fellowship and did a radio documentary on the 10th anniversary of the deadly avian flu outbreak. Story tips at

With files from Michelle Song, CBC