Winnipeg's finance chair says city budget can weather economic storm

City finance chair Scott Gillingham says the budget predictions set last week can be reached despite upheavals in the economy due to coronavirus.

Stock markets and oil prices plunge as coronavirus wreaks financial havoc

A potential recession could affect revenues for the city, but finance chair Scott Gillingham says there are enough reserves to stay on target. (Sean Kavanagh CBC )

The city's budget predictions released last Friday can weather the turbulence blowing through the economy, says finance chair Scott Gillingham.

Gillingham spoke after a budget presentation to the Winnipeg Chamber of Commerce on Monday, while coronavirus fears and falling oil prices had led to "panic selling" on North American stock markets and worsening fears of a global recession.

He was there to discuss the city's four-year budget, with a mix of cuts to grants to community groups, more spending for road improvements and the continuation of a promise by mayor Brian Bowman to keep property tax increases to 2.33 per cent per year.

Finance chair Scott Gillingham says no one can predict events such as coronavirus, but believes the city's budget will survive economic turbulence. (Sean Kavanagh/CBC )

Gillingham said the effects of the coronavirus outbreak on the economy were impossible to anticipate in the months leading up to tabling the budget last week.

"How can you predict that? There are things that just come out of seemingly left field you could never contemplate," Gillingham said.

But the finance chair says the city has cash reserves of over $100 million to help it through rough financial times.

"We do have some room to manoeuvre. Right now our financial stabilization reserve has a healthy balance in it. I think this is one of the advantages though of longer term budgeting, is there is a level of certainty and predictability," Gillingham said.

The president of the chamber of commerce sees some turbulent times coming for everyone.

"You know, when you take a look at threats, obviously this is a new threat to not just organizations, companies, people's portfolios, but governments right across the board," Loren Remillard said.

Loren Remillard with the Winnipeg Chamber of Commerce acknowledges there are serious economic threats but believes the city's recent budget can withstand the pressure. (John Einarson/CBC)

However, Remillard agreed with Gillingham; the city has put itself in a decent position.

"The one area — and credit to city hall — the cost control measures that have been implemented via collective agreements, via successive budgets,  has put them in a good position to better respond to those threats," Remillard said.

There are other factors beyond control of civic politicians that could also significantly impact the city's revenues.

The recently-released budget depends on money from what the city calls impact fees, which it charges developers for growth in the city's far-flung suburbs.

Yet the money from those fees, more than $30 million collected so far, is subject to the city winning a court case launched by the developers.

The city is also banking and spending millions in savings from re-negotiating the pension benefits for police officers — a decision hotly contested by the Winnipeg Police Association and the subject of an arbitration case.

"We'll let those cases work their way through the courts and respond accordingly when needed," Gillingham said.



To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.