When should kids 5-11 get their second shot – after 8 weeks or 21 days? Your questions answered
Pediatrician Dr. Matthew Purser says, ultimately, it’s up to families
Almost 50 per cent of children aged five to 11 in Waterloo region have had at least one dose the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine. Almost five per cent are double-vaccinated.
Waterloo Region Public Health has now allowed walk-in appointments for this age group to make it easier for parents and legal guardians to get their children vaccinated before in-person learning returns on Monday, a spokesperson said.
The current recommendation from the National Advisory Committee on Immunization (NACI) is to wait eight weeks between first and second doses for kids. But Health Canada has authorized children to get their second shot after at least 21 days after the first.
Ultimately, the decision is up to parents, legal guardians and kids.
To better understand the different intervals, CBC Kitchener-Waterloo spoke to Dr. Matthew Purser, a pediatrician at Grand River Hospital and Cambridge Memorial Hospital. He's also an assistant clinical professor in the department of pediatrics at McMaster University.
This interview has been edited for length and clarity.
What is the difference between waiting eight weeks versus at least 21 days?
Dr. Matthew Purser: If the shortest interval time of 21 days is chosen, what that would essentially result in is having better coverage in the short term. We know that having two COVID vaccines into the arm of someone provides them with better protection against the Omicron variant. It's better to have two than it is to have one.
But if you look ahead down the road, four or five months, getting the two doses close together is going to mean that your protection will wane or decrease over that time period. So, if you've got your second dose 21 days after the first, five months from now, you're not going to have as good protection as if you had spaced them apart by the minimum eight-week interval that NACI is recommending for most children.
Right now, where we are in the pandemic with the current wave, a lot of people are deciding to not wait the eight weeks for the second dose. I think understandably and justifiably, they feel like it's better to have the short-term protection than it is to have the longer-term protection because the hope is that in five months from now, we're not going to be seeing the same numbers of Omicron cases. We're not going to have the same kind of viral level and transmission in the community that we do now. So why not have better upfront protection?
What is your recommendation to parents and legal guardians?
Dr. Matthew Purser: I think that really is a personal decision for a lot of people, and it has to do with what their anticipated exposure is with other members of the community.
So for example, if I think about the child who has underlying health conditions or is immunocompromised, and it's anticipated that the child is going to be staying in a home, minimal close contacts, I would say a lot of families in that scenario probably would opt to wait until at least the eight week interval to get the second dose because that will provide overall better protection and the hope being that in the short term, they're going to have minimal exposure.
Whereas for the average family with a five to 11 year-old-child — especially if they're going to be going back to in-person learning next week — I think a lot of people in that scenario may, in fact, choose to get the shorter interval just to provide that better protection in the short term because we know that with going back to school, there will inevitably be increased exposure.
It's case dependent.
Are there health risks associated with not waiting the recommended eight weeks?
Dr. Matthew Purser: No, it's essentially just a matter of coverage.
What is your reaction to the local vaccination numbers for children between five and 11?
Dr. Matthew Purser: It's disheartening to say the least.
As a pediatrician who works almost exclusively in our regional hospitals, looking after the sickest children and the sickest patients in our region, I have seen over the last few weeks countless numbers of children coming in with suspected or confirmed COVID cases, many requiring hospital admissions, oxygen therapy, IV fluids. A lot of the patients that are being admitted to hospital are not the ones who are eligible to be vaccinated. It's the younger age group. It's infants, young toddlers who are coming in.
It's only through vaccinating close caregivers and other household members that we can offer that indirect protection. The point of vaccination from a public health perspective is not necessarily to protect patient zero or to protect yourself, it's to offer that wider protection to our most vulnerable populations. And so, in this case, a great example is young infants who at this point are not eligible to receive the vaccine themselves.
Why are pediatric vaccination numbers the lowest compared to other age categories?
Dr. Matthew Purser: It's more than likely multi-factorial.
I'm sure there are families who would love to be able to go and vaccinate their children, but maybe don't have the luxury of taking time off work to be able to go. Absolutely some of that might be and limited accessibility. I think the number one reason for those numbers being low is in fact vaccine hesitancy on the part of parents.
To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.
By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.
Become a CBC Account Holder
Join the conversation Create account
Already have an account?