Vaccine allergy? Experts say most past reactions not valid reason for exemptions
Some patients concerned about receiving 2nd mRNA dose if they had adverse reaction to the 1st
Dr. Mariam Hanna noticed an uptick in requests for allergy assessments in her Burlington, Ont., clinic after the province began implementing COVID-19 vaccine certificates last month.
Whether people have held off on getting vaccinated because of a past reaction or are seeking an exemption to inoculation mandates, Hanna said a previous allergic response doesn't mean you can't get your shots.
Allergists across the country have safely inoculated most patients who come into their clinics, regardless of allergy history, she said.
"Be it as an excuse or a misunderstanding or some miscommunication there, we are certainly getting a lot of referrals because of [vaccine rules]," said Hanna, an assistant clinical professor at McMaster University in Hamilton.
"Most of the time, it isn't reason for exemption."
Hanna said many of the patients she assesses are concerned about previous reactions to non-COVID-19 vaccines. But because the mRNA jabs from Pfizer-BioNTech and Moderna are different from typical inoculations, those past reactions usually don't come up again.
Other patients are concerned about receiving a second mRNA dose if they had an adverse reaction to the first. But she said many patients mistake common non-life-threatening reactions — including rash or swelling at the injection site — for an allergy.
"It's only the very, very few patients that have had a systemic reaction — typically within 15 to 20 minutes of receiving the first dose — that we want to be careful about," Hanna said. "Most of the side-effects that we expect with a vaccine, those are not contraindications for exemption.
"And sometimes you need an allergist to help clarify it."
Allergists look at patient's full history
Allergists assess patients in their specialized clinics, taking a full history to determine the severity of the previous allergy experience — and whether it was an allergic reaction at all.
The assessment can sometime include skin tests, where an ingredient of the vaccine is smeared on a small patch of skin, but Hanna said every patient's appointment will be different.
Dr. Samira Jeimy, a clinical immunology and allergy expert with Western University in London, Ont., said even those who experienced what they perceived to be strong allergic reactions could be mistaken.
Some non-allergic reactions can include anxiety-related events that mimic allergic responses, she said, including hyperventilation, fainting and even symptoms that look and feel like anaphylaxis — a severe, potentially life-threatening reaction where blood pressure drops and airways narrow, making it hard to breathe.
"Things that mimic anaphylaxis are far more common than actual anaphylaxis," Jeimy said. "One example is vocal cord dysfunction, where somebody could actually have their vocal cords slammed shut [when] nervous."
The Canadian Society of Allergy and Clinical Immunology says the risk of systemic allergic reactions, including anaphylaxis, is extremely rare. Studies suggest the estimated annual rate of anaphylaxis in Canada is about 0.4 to 1.8 cases per one million doses of vaccine administered.
According to Health Canada's review on adverse vaccine reactions, 307 cases of anaphylaxis have been reported in the country — out of more than 56 million COVID-19 doses administered.
Jeimy said her clinic has been able to vaccinate "about 99 per cent" of people coming in with allergy concerns.
That includes those who have had real, severe reactions to a first COVID-19 vaccine dose.
Allergists work around this by giving someone with a confirmed allergy small amounts of the dose, separated by 15- to 30-minute observation periods, until dosing is done.
Jeimy said it can take hours to complete a graded administration for extreme cases.
"If I think the patient is at a moderate risk of reaction, I'll divide the vaccine up into three or four doses," she said. "If the patient is at a higher risk, I'll make the dosing even longer."
Benefits of vaccine vs. allergy risks
Canada's National Advisory Committee on Immunization says COVID-19 vaccines shouldn't be offered "routinely" to those who had severe allergic reaction following the first dose.
If a risk assessment deems the benefit of vaccination outweighs allergy risks, NACI says a different vaccine than the one that caused the initial reaction — either AstraZeneca's viral vector jab or the mRNA products — may be used to complete the two-dose series.
Jeimy said that her clinic carries doses of AstraZeneca for emergency situations, but she hasn't had to use them. Instead, most people can safely complete a two-dose mRNA series.
Allergists aren't certain which component of the mRNA vaccines cause severe allergic reactions in a small number of people, she said. But PEG, or polyethylene glycol, is "currently thought to be the culprit." She said PEG allergies on skin tests don't necessarily "correlate to vaccine tolerance," however.
PEG is a common ingredient in cosmetics, skin-care products and some medications, including Tylenol and cough syrup, Jeimy said. So people with PEG allergies likely know they have it long before getting an mRNA vaccine.
NACI says a COVID-19 vaccine "should not be routinely offered to individuals who are allergic to any component" of the jab.
Jeimy urges people to ask a doctor for clarification before swearing off COVID-19 shots.
"I don't think it's helpful to pre-emptively avoid things because of a fear of a reaction," she said. "You have a far greater risk of COVID-19 infection."
To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.
By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.
Become a CBC Account Holder
Join the conversation Create account
Already have an account?