Hamilton neighbourhood covered after plant malfunction sends 'beans raining down'

Bits of soybean coated parts of the city's North End neighbourhood near the end of December after a processing issue at the nearby Bunge plant.

Company 'implementing corrective action' after area showered in bean hulls

Hamilton resident Adrienne Van Halem, 35, stands on Burlington Street East near the Bunge plant, where a malfunction at the facility caused pieces of soybean to fall on her neighbourhood sometime between Dec. 28 and 29. (Dan Taekema/CBC)

Adrienne Van Halem woke up one recent morning to find it had rained soybeans overnight.

The 35-year-old left her home on Burlington Street East in Hamilton on Dec. 29 to walk her dog and found something off-white sprinkled over cars, houses, porches — everything in her North End neighbourhood.

It wasn't snowfall or the salt that Van Halem mistook it for at first. It was bean husks.

"It struck me as unusual, of course," she said with a laugh. "It's just gross and messy and surprising to have beans raining down."

Van Halem shared the odd occurrence on the website Reddit, asking whether there was anyone she should contact.

"My whole block is covered in the soybean skins," she wrote, sharing a picture of the top of a car dotted with shells.

Van Halem shared this photo showing soybean skins covering the roof of a car in her Reddit post about what she discovered when she went out to walk her dog on Dec. 29. (Submitted by Adrienne Van Halem)

The homeowner also called nearby Bunge, a U.S.-based food company that operates an oilseed processing plant in Hamilton, to ask if it had any explanation for what happened.

She said she received a voicemail confirming the facility was involved, and the next day a letter arrived acknowledging what happened, along with a gift card for a car wash.

Company acknowledges 'annoyance'

Sometime overnight between Dec. 28 and 29, pieces of soybeans were "discharged inadvertently," Bunge spokesperson Deb Seidel wrote in an email to CBC News, calling it a rare occurrence.

"While the hulls discharge posed no health or safety risk to either neighbours or employees, we understand that the residue was an annoyance for our neighbours," she said.

Seidel confirmed that gift certificates were handed out to those who were affected and said the company contacted Ontario's Ministry of the Environment and is "working on identifying and implementing corrective action from the incident."

Van Halem shows the car wash gift certificate she received in the mail from Bunge. (Dan Taekema/CBC)

The ministry confirmed in an email to CBC News that it followed up with Bunge and determined that the spray of shells that landed on the area was the result of a plugged dust collector caused by excess moisture in the process.

"The facility was unaware until the City of Hamilton relayed a public complaint," the email read.

'A whole lot of soyabeans'

That statement left Lynda Lukasik shocked.

As executive director of Environment Hamilton, Lukasik said she's familiar with a variety of different fallouts from industry in the city, particularly steel mills and scrapyards, which can cause dust and iron oxide to rain on houses nearby.

But she had never heard of an area being coated in bean bits before.

"If a whole lot of soyabeans blew out of the facility and landed on the surrounding neighbourhood ... and they weren't aware, that really concerns me," she said.

Soybean pieces are sprinkled on the ground near the Bunge plant on Jan. 4, 2022. (Dan Taekema/CBC)

Seidel said Bunge was aware of the release, but its staff were focused on fixing the operational issue and "did not recognize the full extent of the drift until the next afternoon." Soybean residue could still be found in the area when CBC News visited a week later.

The company has had a location in Hamilton for about 80 years.

Its stack towers over a section of the city near one end of Burlington Street, where oil is extracted from the beans and used in food products such as margarine or salad oil. The remnants are turned into a soybean meal that's used as animal feed.

At Bunge's plant in Hamilton, which has been operating for about 80 years, oil is extracted from the beans and used in food products such as margarine or salad oil. (Dan Taekema/CBC)

While dust and other forms of release-related residue are historically associated with heavy industry, Lukasik said Hamilton's growing agri-industrial centre means incidents like this could become more common.

Provincial rules dictate that no industry is supposed to be doing anything that leads to an impact offsite, she added, including soybean skins falling from the sky.

The ministry noted that similar incidents have been reported in the past, such as a release of sugar from a company in the neighbourhood in 2020.

That case actually came up when Van Halem was researching the area before she and her husband bought their home about two years ago.

A sprinkling of soybeans can be seen on the train tracks leading into Bunge's Hamilton location. (Dan Taekema/CBC)

In response to her post on Reddit, some people said that's what you get for living so close to a plant.

But Van Halem said she and her husband enjoy the industrial nature of the neighbourhood and knew full well what they were getting into when they bought their home. She also said she recognizes that bean hulls falling on your house isn't the biggest deal.

Still, she wishes the company had reached out first to explain what happened, rather than her having to make the first move.

"I think there's a responsibility that lies in the industrial area that operates in a downtown core to be good neighbours."


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?