Oosterhoff's group ignored COVID-19 rules despite reminders, restaurant says

The restaurant where Ontario MPP Sam Oosterhoff posed for a photo with a large group of people who weren't wearing masks says the diners didn't follow its COVID-19 rules despite reminders from staff.

Restaurant owner says he keeps things in perspective after loss of his daughter

Betty's Restaurant in Niagara Falls, Ont., says staff told MPP Sam Oosterhoff and his group to wear masks during their recent gathering. (Betty's Restaurant/Facebook)

The restaurant where Ontario MPP Sam Oosterhoff posed for a photo with a large group of people who weren't wearing masks says the diners didn't follow its COVID-19 rules despite reminders from staff.

Betty's Restaurant in Niagara Falls, Ont., wrote on Facebook this week that staff had to tell the group "several times" to wear masks when not seated at their tables.

"Unfortunately they chose not to follow posted rules about wearing masks and distancing," the restaurant said in the statement. 

"We can remind guests but we cannot strong-arm them into following rules."

The Niagara West MPP — who posted a series of photos on social media showing a group of around 40 people squeezed together — has apologized for not wearing a mask. He didn't respond to a request for comment Tuesday about the restaurant's statement.

Owner Joe Miszk said he also received a private apology from the group, which he appreciates. 

Despite the attention — media outlets have been calling Miszk, and the restaurant is fielding negative comments —  Miszk said he's satisfied with an apology because he keeps the situation in perspective.

Miszk lost his daughter, Julianne, to cancer about three months ago.

He described her as a passionate para-athlete who excelled at running and competed at the Special Olympics. She was a seven-time provincial champion and was inducted into the Niagara Sports Wall of Fame. 

"These are challenging times for everybody, and we want to all do our best to do the right thing. And it's health first, safety first … and sometimes we have to recognize that sometimes we don't always get it all right," he said.

"People do make mistakes sometimes and it's important to be able to recognize that."

Miszk said he saw how supportive a community can be with his daughter. But sometimes, he said, you go through things and see the other side.

He says he understands that the group made a mistake. When it comes to the business, you address the situation, he said, and "we move on." 

Oosterhoff briefly posted these pictures to his Facebook page, drawing critcism for the lack of physical distancing and masks. (@BBarker77/Twitter)

In its statement, the family restaurant said Oosterhoff's group was in a private room — with a separate entrance and restrooms — and didn't interact with other customers.

The restaurant has sanitized and disinfected the "entire area since the party," and says it is doing its best to follow all the guidelines in place for people's safety. It also thanked members of the community who continue to support them since.

Miszk said he was proud of the way his staff handled the situation.

While Oosterhoff's photos were quickly deleted, backlash followed.

Ontario Hospital Association president Anthony Dale called for Oosterhoff's resignation from his parliamentary assistant role to Education Minister Stephen Lecce. NDP Leader Andrea Horwath also called on Premier Doug Ford to "set an example." 

Ford said on Monday Oosterhoff would keep his position and that "everyone makes mistakes." 

Ford has described people not wearing masks at parties as "jokers" and said "you'd think the cheese slipped off the cracker with these people."

WATCH | Premier Doug Ford says he accepts Oosterhoff's apology:

'We all make mistakes,' Ford says after MPP Sam Oosterhoff pictured at gathering without masks

1 year ago
Duration 1:07
Premier Doug Ford has dubbed those who don't wear masks everything from "yahoos" to "jokers" to "a few fries short of a Happy Meal." But he says he accepts the apology of an MPP Sam Oosterhoff, who was photographed in a group without masks. 1:07

In his apology, Oosterhoff said there were fewer than 50 people at the indoor gathering, in keeping with Ontario's COVID-19 regulations for staffed events.

People are required to wear masks inside restaurants when they aren't eating or drinking, and must stay two metres away from those outside their household. 


Christine Rankin is a reporter/editor with CBC News, and an associate producer at CBC Sports. You can find her on twitter at @ChrisRankinNews, or send her a message at christine.rankin@cbc.ca.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?