'A last goodbye to Brandon': Message in a bottle unites families years after it was set adrift

A message in a bottle has connected two families more than four years after it was thrown into Lake Huron as an act of faith and a final goodbye.

Brandon Walli, 23, died in 2016 after being hit by a vehicle near Flamborough, Ont.

Brandon Walli's family talks about the bottle and their 'final goodbye':

2 years ago
Duration 1:06
Shandelle Carrigan and Jason Poulton share what it was like to find the bottle, while Brandon Walli's sister Robyn and his dad, Tom, talk about what it means to them.

Shandelle Carrigan knew she'd found something special when the bottle on Ontario's Barrie Island beach caught her eye, but she had no idea what it would lead to.

Black electrical tape was tightly wrapped around the neck, making the vessel watertight and protecting a slip of paper inside.

When she flipped it over, Carrigan saw a picture of a young man, his arms raised in the air, a look of confidence and joy splashed across his face.

"The only part I could make out was 'Son in Heaven,' so I knew I'd found something … I just didn't know what the significance was at that point."

More than four years earlier, Brandon Walli's family had thrown the bottle into Lake Huron. It was an act of faith, and a final goodbye.

The 23-year-old was hit and killed by a car in October 2016, while walking along Highway 6 in Flamborough, Ont.

Raising awareness in Brandon's name

Tom Walli, his father, said he's convinced Brandon was looking down at his phone when it happened.

The tragedy led the Geotab, Tom's employer, and the family to launch the campaign Phones Down, Eyes Up, hosting benefit concerts and setting up a scholarship in Brandon's memory. They family said they're determined to save others from the pain they carry each day.

That same year, they placed a message in a bottle and his three-year-old niece threw it into the water near their camp on north-central Ontario's Manitoulin Island, which includes Barrie Island.

The page was covered in the signatures of loved ones, that picture of Brandon standing on the edge of the escarpment, and a poem.

Shandelle Carrigan holds up the bottle she found on Barrie Island in mid-April. The message inside eventually led to finding the Walli family, who threw it into Lake Huron more than four years ago. (Shandelle Carrigan/Facebook)

"Dear Son in Heaven," it began.

Eileen Doyle, Brandon's mother, said he was always the centre of family events like birthday parties or Christmas dinners.

"He made his presence known by just his laugh," she said.

His sister, Robyn Tollar, describes him as the life of the party, adding "when you were around him, you couldn't stop laughing."

This family cast this out as a kind of a last goodbye to Brandon. So to find something of that significance really touched me deeply.- Shandelle Carrigan

The bottle and its message floated away.

Years went by. Brandon's family tried to heal. Some even forgot about the bottle.

Then, on April 13, Carrigan came running up from the beach.

"I found a message in a bottle, I found a message in a bottle," her husband Jason Poulton recalled her shouting.

Poulton said he watched his wife run through a range of emotions — from the excitement of the find, to being struck by the tragedy, pain and love bottled up inside it.

Freeing the message proved a bit of a struggle — it was secured so well that the family had to use a hacksaw to cut the bottle open.

Out fell some rocks, the paper and a $10 bill.

"Please have a drink on us in memory of our son!" read the bottom of the page. On the back were a few lines from Brandon's obituary.

"I shed some tears over this. I felt really emotional over it," said Carrigan. "This family cast this out as a kind of a last goodbye to Brandon. So to find something of that significance really touched me deeply."

Listen: The story behind the bottle

Searching through clues

The family gathered what clues they could from the bottle and started searching online. They also posted pictures and videos about it on social media asking for help finding Brandon's family.

"Within 24 hours, we'd located them," said Poulton.

"Unreal, right?" added Carrigan.

A Facetime call was quickly arranged, including a toast in Brandon's honour.

"They were in tears. They were so happy it was found," said Poulton.

Brandon Walli's family believes he was walking and using his phone when he was struck by a car on the highway in October in 2016. (Submitted by Robyn Tollar)

Doyle said hearing someone had finally found the bottle was "heart-warming" and brought up a lot of emotions.

"It's very emotional," Tom said. "It's a big springboard to get this message out there and keep his name alive."

The message "Phones Down, Eyes Up" registers with Carrigan and Poulton. They have four teenage sons of their own.

"We could only imagine that tragedy happening to us or anybody we know. It would just be devastating," said Poulton. "We kind of feel an obligation to assist them with getting this message out."

Plans to relaunch bottle

In a strange twist, it turns out the bottle didn't go far.

The Walli family camp where it began its voyage is nearby.

"This is how we met our neighbours," said Poulton, with a laugh. "Who does that?"

Tom Walli, Brandon's father, performs during a Phones Down, Eyes Up benefit concert in honour of his son. (Submitted by Geotab)

Carrigan said she now speaks with the Walli family nearly every day.

The couple intends to keep the cut-open bottle and is "never going to spend" the $10, instead keeping it as a memento.

The families plan to meet up in person once the pandemic allows them to.

Together, they'll put Brandon's poem in a fresh bottle with a new $10 bill, said Poulton. Then they'll add a chart with their names and phone number before sealing it up tight and casting it back out into the lake.

"We're going to take it out in a boat this time so it goes further," said Carrigan.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Account Holder

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?