Police board wants answers after 'eye-opening' street check report

Hamilton Police Chief Glenn De Caire agreed Thursday to provide answers about the service's on-the-street policing tactics in response to concerns raised about privacy and racial bias.

Board will look into keeping race data for tracking bias

Hamilton Police Chief Glenn De Caire agreed Thursday to give answers next month about the service's on-the-street policing tactics in response to concerns raised about privacy and racial bias. 

The police service's oversight board asked for the answers after hearing from a Hamilton activist who painted a picture of "innocent and law-abiding people being stopped, questioned and asked for identification." 

That practice, which activist Gary Fondevilla referred to as "street checks," is no different than controversial "carding" in Toronto that has been shown to disproportionately impact low-income people and visible minorities, he said. 

"Carding allows too much room for personal bias," Fondevilla said. "It goes against our Charter rights."

Members of the board called the presentation "eye-opening" and "compelling." 

De Caire acknowledged the existence of racial profiling in policing. He said the service does "not train our members to participate in the random, indiscriminate stopping of persons based on race or any other prohibited ground for the purpose of identifying individuals." 

'Moved a couple of things forward today'

The activists said the meeting outcome was progress in a back-and-forth they've had with the service for months, but said they remain skeptical the chief's presentation a month from now will address their concerns.

"We've moved a couple of things forward today," said Halima Hatimy, a member of the "Black, Brown, Red Lives Matter" group.

In a presentation, Fondevilla asked the service to do the following: 

  • End street checks/carding.
  • Do yearly studies on experience of community members interacting with police.
  • Issue carbon copy receipts including the badge number of the officer who stopped a person and a race category to facilitate tracking racial profiling.
  • Increase the racial diversity of sworn officers.
  • Implement lapel cameras.

The board asked for the chief to return to its next meeting with a report on what it would look like to keep race data, and to address the concerns raised Thursday.

De Caire said he'd give an overview of the training officers get, the laws that govern their interactions with people on the street, the "articulable cause" for street stops and what information is collected and recorded from interactions with citizens on the street.

'Multiple definitions based on who is doing the talking'

De Caire did not clear up semantic confusion about what the service's "street checks" are.

When you ask the chief, 'Do we card?' He says no.- Mayor FredEisenberger

He said there are "multiple definitions based on who is doing the talking" of the "street checks" term, even though Hamilton Police includes the category in its statistics and said it did between 3,500 and 5,500 "street checks" between 2010 and 2013.

A 2012 Toronto report drew a direct link between "street check" practices in other Ontario police departments and "carding" in Toronto.

Police Chief Glenn De Caire talks about street checks during the board meeting Thursday. (Samantha Craggs/CBC)
Outside the meeting, reporters asked again: are street checks the same as carding?

"This is where there are definitions that will come forward for the board to entertain at the next meeting as we have committed to," De Caire said. "And what we are going to do is we'll clarify at that point all of those issues for us."

Mayor Fred Eisenberger, who sits on the board, said he would take issue with information being recorded from street interactions "without just cause." But said he generally accepts the chief's description of what's going on.

"To be fair, when you ask the chief, 'Do we card?' He says no," Eisenberger said. "Is it incumbent on us to dig deeper and find out what the police do on a day-to-day basis? In a general sense, I think the chief has told us what they do on a day-to-day basis and it's a lot of interaction in the community, but not targeted at individuals for any specific reason unless there's a crime occurring. So, I take him at his word on that."

'If we're trying to build trust in this community'

If the police service formally included a race identifier in all of its records of street interactions, it could then analyze them to see if one race was impacted more than another across the city. By collecting the race identifiers, police can establish a baseline for how much or how little race seems to come into play in whom they stop.

Coun. Terry Whitehead, who sits on the board, said he thought it would help mend some of the "distrust" that he said can creep into the relationship between police and the community.

"The fact we're not collecting that, if we're trying to build trust in this community, a good start is to start collecting that kind of data," he said.

If we're trying to build trust in this community, a good start is to start collecting that kind of data.-Coun. Terry Whitehead

​Eisenberger said the collection of race data seemed "counter-intuitive" after hearing the community concerns about racial bias. De Caire said a "measured approach" would be required. 

He said that issue and others, like issuing receipts for street interactions, would be part of a conversation with the province about new regulations. 

Madeleine Levy, a civilian member of the board, said she is wholeheartedly opposed to carding. "I understand that Canadian law does not tolerate fishing expeditions and neither do I," she said. But, she said, the police must have power to do intelligence-based investigations.

Catching up on this discussion in Hamilton?

Here are some links to previous coverage: 

kelly.bennett@cbc.ca | @kellyrbennett


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?