Edmonton

Never built: New exhibit explores Edmonton's unrealized architecture

The Muttart Conservatory, the art gallery, the legislature - iconic architectural landmarks of Edmonton, but what about the buildings envisioned for the city skyline that died on the drafting table? 

'Some of them are really cool and some of them could have been really, really bad'

The Unrealized exhibit offers Edmontonians a glimpse of ambiguous city projects that were never built. (Wallis Snowdon/CBC)

The glass pyramids of the Muttart Conservatory. The swooping metal of the downtown art gallery. The imposing classically inspired dome of the legislature.

These are the iconic architectural landmarks Edmonton is known for, but what about the buildings that were envisioned for the capital city skyline but died on the drafting table? 

Unrealized, a new exhibit by Media, Architecture, and Design Edmonton (MADE), has put these defeated designs on display.  

The architectural efforts run the gamut from impressive to absurd, said Max Amerongen, a board member with MADE. 

The designs included in the exhibit span more than a century of city planning. There was a plan for a downtown arena complete with football field and hidden hockey rink, a freeway traversing the river valley and a glass-walled restaurant on the old Walterdale Bridge.

"Some of them are really cool and some of them could have been really, really bad," Amerongen said in an interview with CBC Radio's Edmonton AM.

"All cities have a similar situation. Lots of projects don't end up going ahead but we seem to have more projects, and more interesting projects, than other cities I've seen." 

It's really interesting to see what the boom-and-bust economy does to the urban form​​​​​​.- Max Amerongen

Among the most notable projects Edmonton could have had is the Centennial Pylon. The 100-metre tower was included in the original designs for the old Royal Alberta Museum.

The tower, intended to celebrate Canada's 1967 centennial, would have included a rotating restaurant and observation deck overlooking the river valley, Amerongen said. 

But nearby homeowners weren't feeling so celebratory and, when the tower was scrapped, the designs came to fruition in a different form, as the Calgary Tower. 

"This is one we heard rumours about for a while. People were saying, 'Did you know that the Calgary Tower was supposed to be in Edmonton?'

"Glenora residents were disturbed by the project and its potential traffic impact ... In a really '60s way, it would have been this really, really cool structure." 
Centennial Pylon had plans for a breathtaking observation deck and rotating restaurant. (Wallis Snowdon/CBC)

'This spectacular building that never happened' 

Amerongen's personal favourite is a design by famous Canadian architect Douglas Cardinal for an Indigenous arts centre on stilts.

"It was this really cool five-lobed elevated building up on pillars," he said.  

"I think anyone who looks at this project could say that this would have been one of the most beautiful buildings on our skyline.

"It's this spectacular building that never happened." 

Even the best designs can die on the drafting table due to "government waffling," public backlash, or lack of money, Amerongen said. 

In Edmonton, big design proposals have been won or last at the whim of Alberta's oil-driven economy. 

"It's really interesting to see what the boom-and-bust economy does to the urban form and what having a single resource roller coaster does to the projects that get proposed," Amerongen said. 

"When that economic trend changes direction, a lot of those projects just lose funding and quietly disappear." 

Unrealized runs until Oct. 25 on the second floor of Edmonton City Centre west. It is open during mall hours, except for on Sundays.

The exhibit spans more than a century of city planning, drawing on blueprints that died on the drafting table. Above is an early take on the subway pitched for Edmonton in the 1960s. (Wallis Snowdon/CBC)

About the Author

Wallis Snowdon

Journalist

Wallis Snowdon is a digital journalist with CBC Edmonton. She has nearly a decade of experience reporting behind her. Originally from New Brunswick, her journalism career has taken her from Nova Scotia to Fort McMurray. Share your stories with Wallis at wallis.snowdon@cbc.ca

With files from Ariel Fournier

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.