Taxpayers billed $173K for Redford suite, documents show

New documents tabled in the Alberta legislature reveal taxpayers were billed $150,000 just for design concepts on a planned penthouse for former premier Alison Redford.

Redford has refused to talk about the planned penthouse

Former premier Alison Redford returned to the Alberta Legislature Monday after a six-week absence. (City TV)

Alberta taxpayers were billed $150,000 just for design concepts on a planned penthouse for former premier Alison Redford, show documents tabled this week in the legislature. 

The total bill for all consulting work on the suite, dubbed the "sky palace" by the opposition and media, was just over $173,000. 

The documents were tabled Tuesday by former infrastructure minister Ric McIver

They show that $150,000 was spent on conceptual design, related contract documents, and fittings. 

There was $11,850 for advice on how to change the plumbing and air systems. There was $7,400 on suggestions on lighting and power changes. Architect fees to co-ordinate the engineering subconsultants were pegged at $3,850. 

The penthouse was to be on the 11th floor of the Federal Building  an historic structure under renovation that will eventually house offices for all members of the legislature along with other government officials. 

It is a block north of the legislature, and the top offers stunning views of the sandstone-domed structure. 

Suite under negotiations since 2012

The project was run by the Infrastructure Department, but email correspondence released in March revealed that starting in late 2012, Redford's office became involved and ordered changes to the 10th and 11th floors. 

The changes called for a "premier's suite" built to the style of the ultra-posh Hay Adams Hotel in Washington D.C. 

There would be bedrooms for Redford and her pre-teen daughter, Sarah, a shared bathroom, a powder room, a walk-in closet, a butler's pantry and areas for dining, studying and lounging. 

There would be grooming and changing areas, a fireplace and room-by-room temperature controls. 

There were multiple emails on the composition of room-divider panels. One memo urgently demanded "colour boards." Another spoke of 3D floor plans. 

Ultimately, the suite was never finished. 

McIver has said he learned of it in January, just weeks after taking over the infrastructure portfolio. He said some of the framing for the suite had already been done. He ordered the existing framing redone to turn the floor into meeting rooms and cancelled the premier's penthouse. 

McIver said it wasn't something taxpayers should pay for. 

Documents show city planners balked at plans

The new expense totals follow up on a raft of memos, emails and reports released by the province in late March, less than a week after Redford resigned ahead of a reported caucus and party revolt over her spending and plummeting poll numbers. 

The documents showed that at one point, city planners balked at Redford's apartment. They said if she planned to stay overnight, the development permit had to be changed and made public. 

Redford's office replied that nothing would be made public for security reasons. 

Confusion over project timing

There has been confusion over who killed the penthouse project. 

Wayne Drysdale, the current transportation minister but infrastructure minister at the time, has said he thought he cancelled the project in late 2012. 

It should all come back to the ministry.- Premier Dave Hancock

Drysdale, ironically, is now infrastructure minister again. McIver resigned from cabinet Tuesday to announce Wednesday he will run in the PC party leadership race to replace Redford. 

Opponents have held up the suite as the symbol of the excess and entitlement of the governing party. Since the project was reportedly killed twice, the Wildrose party refers to it as the "zombie sky palace." 

Premier Dave Hancock admitted Wednesday the project went off the rails. 

"It wasn't appropriate," said Hancock. "Infrastructure should have been in charge of that process right along, and I think that's what we need to make sure (that happens in the future). 

"It should all come back to the ministry." 

However, he said, "at the end of the day (the Federal Building) will be a good project for Albertans." 

Redford has refused to comment on the planned penthouse, saying she has moved on with her new life as a backbencher for the riding of Calgary-Elbow. 

All members of Redford's inner circle have left the government, sharing $1.3 million in severance.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.