Omar Khadr war crime convictions questioned after U.S. court decision

An American court decision in the case of an alleged al-Qaeda recruiter Friday has cast further doubt on the war crimes convictions of Canada's Omar Khadr.

A split ruling from appeals court could affect rulings against Omar Khadr

Dennis Edney gives his opinion on how a U.S. court decision could affect Khadr 4:07

An American court decision in the case of an alleged al-Qaeda recruiter Friday has cast further doubt on the war crimes convictions of Canada's Omar Khadr.

In its split ruling, the appeals court set aside the military commission conviction of Ali Hamza al-Bahlul, a Guantanamo Bay detainee who did media relations for Osama bin Laden.

In essence, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit ruled that the conspiracy case against al-Bahlul was legally flawed because conspiracy is not a war crime — similar to arguments Khadr has made. The commission only had jurisdiction to try internationally recognized war crimes, the court said.

The same court had earlier set aside two of al-Bahlul's other convictions because the offences he was convicted of were not war crimes at the time of his alleged actions. 

Khadr's Pentagon-appointed lawyer was not immediately available to comment, but one of his Canadian lawyers said the recent decision undermines Khadr's conviction and his appeal should now be allowed.

"By implication, [the ruling] pretty much seals the deal with respect to Omar's appeal," Nate Whitling said from Edmonton.

"This case clearly confirms that all five of Khadr's convictions are invalid and must inevitably be overturned."

The Toronto-born Khadr was convicted of five war crimes in October 2010 after he pleaded guilty before a widely condemned military commission to offences he was accused of committing as a 15-year-old in Afghanistan in 2002.

He is appealing the conviction on the grounds that the commission had no jurisdiction to try him because the offences with which he was charged were not war crimes at the time. However, the commission appeals court has refused to hear the case pending the outcome of the al-Bahlul challenge.

Whitling said the Court of Military Commission Review should now get on with hearing Khadr's challenge given that the al-Bahul case has been decided.

"That abeyance has now expired," Whitling said. "They should make a decision on the merits."

Khadr released on bail

Khadr, 28, who returned to Canada in 2012 to serve out his eight-year sentence, was released on bail last month into the custody of Edmonton lawyer Dennis Edney pending the outcome of his American appeal.

The Canadian government, which brands him a dangerous terrorist, is still fighting to put him back behind bars and appealing the bail decision.

The U.S. government has conceded that Khadr's offences were not international war crimes, but has maintained he violated domestic common law dating to the Civil War.

While the al-Bahlul ruling does not speak directly to Khadr's other convictions such as murder and attempted murder, Whitling said the same legal logic applies — the military commission had no jurisdiction to try him.

U.S. courts had previously rejected another of the offences for which Khadr was convicted in a case against one of bin Laden's drivers: material support for terrorism.

The system of military commissions was created by the administration of former president George W. Bush after the Sept. 11 attacks on the U.S.

President Barack Obama's administration had argued Congress acted within its authority in making conspiracy a crime that could be tried by military commission.

The American government could still try to appeal the al-Bahlul decision to the Supreme Court.

With files from CBC News


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.