Alberta premier says federal throne speech stomps into provincial jurisdiction

Alberta Premier Jason Kenney sees grounds for more constitutional challenges, should the federal Liberal government follow through with promises contained in Wednesday's throne speech.

Jason Kenney says Liberal policies may see Alberta, federal government square off again in court

Alberta Premier Jason Kenney says he is disappointed with the federal government's throne speech. He says there is nothing in the Trudeau government's plan for the ailing energy industry. (CBC)

Alberta Premier Jason Kenney sees grounds for more constitutional challenges, should the federal Liberal government follow through with promises contained in Wednesday's throne speech.

Kenney told reporters Thursday morning that federal government plans jeopardize global investments in Alberta's forestry and fertilizer sectors — moves the premier believes are an infringement on Alberta's right to develop its own natural resources.

He called the speech a "full-frontal attack" on federalism.

"There were more policies that would invade provincial jurisdiction than I could count," Kenney said.

He accused the Trudeau government of pursuing policies that require constitutional amendments.

"I regret the federal government so spectacularly failed the mark yesterday."

WATCH | Alberta Premier Jason Kenney slams throne speech, cautious optimism in oil sector:

Kenney slams throne speech, cautious optimism in oil industry

3 years ago
Duration 1:49
Alberta Premier Jason Kenney railed against Wednesday’s throne speech saying it didn't reflect the crisis in the energy sector, but some in the oil industry say they're cautiously optimistic.

The Alberta government is already challenging the federal government's consumer carbon tax in court, as well as the federal Impact Assessment Act, which changed the environmental approval process for major infrastructure projects.

Kenney said other premiers may share his concerns, and he plans to speak with his colleagues across the country later Thursday.

The premier also reiterated comments from a written statement he issued Wednesday, saying the federal speech from the throne failed to acknowledge the Canadian oil and gas sector and included policies destined to damage an already-battered industry.

While corporations move toward renewable energy projects and away from oil and gas and as California's governor moves toward banning the sale of new gas-powered cars by 2035, Kenney stood by his position that the world will demand more oil and gas products from Alberta.

"If you really think the billion people in India who are all desperately moving toward a higher standard of living are going to be driving Teslas 15 years from now, then you're disconnected from reality," he said. 

"There are billions of people living around the world living in extreme energy poverty. They don't have the luxury of repeating all these California-style pieties. They want to stop burning cow dung."

'Kooky academic theories'

Federal tax incentives promised for Canadian companies developing net-zero technologies unfairly exclude the oil and gas sector, Kenney said.

"There was space for every bright shiny object, every possible political distraction," he said. "Kooky academic theories like intersectionality found their way into yesterday's throne speech, but not one word about health transfers for the provinces that are carrying 80 per cent of the costs as our population ages and we cope with a pandemic."

Kenney also said Alberta would attempt to opt out of a promised federal pharmacare program, saying the province already has its own program. He would expect an equivalent cash transfer from Ottawa, who he said should stay out of "micromanaging" Alberta's health spending priorities.

In the House of Commons Thursday, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau responded to similar critiques from Opposition Conservative MPs, saying the federal government has supported Albertans and the oil and gas industry during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Thousands of Albertans collected the Canada emergency response benefit (CERB) and businesses stayed afloat with the emergency wage subsidy, Trudeau said.

"We made investments in cleaning up orphaned wells, which is something that was a provincial area of jurisdiction that we are happy to support because we needed to keep giving people opportunities to do the right thing and to have work through this difficult time," Trudeau said.

The federal government allocated $1 billion of the $1.7-billion well cleanup program to Alberta projects.

Alberta also received $1.3 billion from the federal government's "safe restart" funding to provinces, which will help pay for more COVID-19 testing, health-care staffing and protective equipment, among other things.

Alberta Opposition NDP leader Rachel Notley said she was alarmed by Kenney's throne speech comments.

"This premier is so focused from distracting from his own inability to create jobs and restart economic growth that he is continuing his fake fights with Ottawa at the expense of the best interests of the people has been asked to represent," Notley said at a news conference in Lethbridge.

She said a federal pharmacare plan would improve the quality and affordability of health care for millions of Albertans by allowing all patients to afford the medications their doctors prescribe.

    One of the pillars of the throne speech was a promise by the Liberal minority government to create over one million jobs through direct investment, wage subsidies and other skills and incentives programs.

    The government also promised to exceed its goal of reducing greenhouse gas emissions by 30 per cent below 2005 levels and legislate Canada's goal of net-zero emissions by 2050.

    Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers president and CEO Tim McMillan said he was happy to see natural resources receive a mention in the throne speech, but pointed to policies such as the incoming clean fuel standards as problematic for the oil industry.

    The new federal regulations, which are set to take effect in 2022, are intended to reduce the carbon intensity of gasoline and diesel by 10 to 12 per cent below 2016 levels by 2030.

    McMillan said those standards will cost the industry jobs for little improvement in greenhouse gas emissions.

    "If the country is going to meet its climate goals, the oil and gas sectors know how technology development and clean tech will play a key role in that, not just for our sector, but the economy as a whole," McMillan said.

    WATCH | The federal government outlines its environmental policy goals: 

    The throne speech: government outlines its environmental policy goals

    3 years ago
    Duration 2:26
    Gov. Gen. Julie Payette delivered the 150th speech from the throne in the Senate chamber on Wednesday.

    -- With files from Terry Reith and Charlotte Dumoulin


      To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

      By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

      Become a CBC Account Holder

      Join the conversation  Create account

      Already have an account?