Edmonton

'Trying to make drivers happy': Cyclists slam proposed south side bike network

A plan for expanding the downtown bike network south of the North Saskatchewan River is drawing criticism from cyclists who regularly ride through the Garneau and Strathcona neighbourhoods.

Plan would add a protected bike lane on 110th Street, not the 109th Street corridor

A cyclist turns left through traffic on 109th Street. (Rod Maldaner/CBC)

A plan for expanding Edmonton's downtown bike network south of the river is drawing criticism from cyclists who regularly ride through the Garneau and Strathcona neighbourhoods. 

In a report going to council's urban planning committee Tuesday, city staff propose protected bike lanes for 110th Street, and not 109th Street — the popular option in a 2016 survey of area residents — to connect cyclists with the High Level Bridge. 

"Roadways that would experience significant operational traffic impacts with the addition of bike routes were removed from consideration," the report states.

"The 109 Street corridor was considered as a candidate bike route, but was removed due to its importance for transit and motor vehicles."

Mike Cotfas, the owner of Mike's Bikes and Beans on Whyte Avenue, is frustrated that the city seems to be prioritizing drivers over cyclists in the design of a bike network. 

"I think they're really trying to make drivers happy first and foremost, and then cyclists second, offering a concession of 110th instead of 109th," Cotfas said. 

The report says the expansion to the south side of the river takes into consideration learnings from the downtown bike network, city standards for street design and national guidelines. 

$5.8-million project

The $5.8-million south side bike network would build on the downtown bike network completed in 2017.

The south-side network would have protected bike lanes in Garneau and Strathcona. 

There are already some protected bike lanes in the area. Cotfas and other cyclists have positive reviews of the lane along 83rd Avenue between 99th and 106th streets and is currently being extended to 111th Street. There's another on 106th Street and another on 76th Avenue.

The south side bike grid recommended by city staff. (City of Edmonton)

The south side bike network would add a lane on 110th Street, with a link along 88th Avenue to the High Level Bridge, as well as another lane on 100th Street between Whyte Avenue and Saskatchewan Drive to connect to the Low Level Bridge.

There would be an east/west route along 87th and 86th avenues between 97th and 106th streets.  

'Prioritize moving people'

Holyrood resident Dave Sutherland, who has been cycling in the area for years, wrote a letter to the city with concerns about the proposed south side bike network.

"It's kind of squandering an opportunity here to improve transportation access to an area that's planned to be intensified and made more walkable and accessible," Sutherland told CBC News, referring to Envision 109, a long-term improvement project for the 109th Street corridor.

In 2016, the city designated 109th Street as a Main Street.

According to a presentation document from an Envision 109 open house that year, with main streets, the city will aim to "prioritize moving people, not just motor vehicles" and "enhance and rebalance the environment for pedestrians, cyclists and transit users."

In a survey of 2,500 people that was part of Envision 109, 57 per cent of respondents said they want space for cycling on 109th Street. Seventy per cent said they would cycle more on 109th Street if it were improved.

A cyclist swerves to avoid a pot hole on 110th Street. (Rod Maldaner/CBC)

Cotfas said the current condition of 110th Street is discouraging.

"I challenge anybody to take a picture of a 10-foot stretch that doesn't have a pothole or a major crack in the road," Cotfas said. "It's virtually unusable in its current state."

A dangerous ride

Cotfas and Sutherland said they don't feel safe riding on 109th Street right now, either.

Cotfas said while riding over the High Level Bridge and down the corridor recently, he worried he could get into a traffic accident.

"Something magical happened the second I got on to the bike lane on 83rd [Avenue]," Cotfas said. "That risk of something terrible happening to me dropped to zero per cent."

Sutherland said while the wide lanes on 109th Street create more room on the road, there is also more speeding and more distracted driving.

"Right now, it's not a good experience," Sutherland said of cycling on 109th Street. "At the same time, it's a corridor that has so much potential."

Should council endorse the south side bike network, city administration recommend implementing it over the next four years, in concert with the Garneau and Strathcona neighbourhood renewal projects.

With files from Madeleine Cummings

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.