Alexander First Nation election to proceed, despite court application

The upcoming election at Alexander First Nation will proceed after a judge rejected an application for a last-minute injunction that would have given off-reserve members the right to cast a ballot.

The challenge called for a 40-day delay to change rules and allow off-reserve band members to vote

A federal court challenge has cast doubt on whether Monday's election at Alexander First Nation will take place. (Alexander First Nation website)

The upcoming election at Alexander First Nation will proceed after a judge rejected an application for a last-minute injunction that would have given off-reserve members the right to cast a ballot.

The decision came on Saturday in response to a motion by band member Sandra Relling to delay the election for 40 days and to change election rules so off-reserve members could vote.

Now, on-reserve members will head to the polls on Monday. The election is happening after results of a July 13 election were overturned.

"I hope this will encourage current Alexander electors to cast their ballots wisely for those candidates who will properly address Alexander's governance and financial management issues, and guide our community forward in a positive way," Relling said in a statement. Relling lives off-reserve.

In a notice to band members Friday, Relling said she'd applied for the delay to have "Alexander Tribal Government Customary Election Regulations changed so that where you live does not affect elector eligibility."

About half of Alexander's 2,223 members live off-reserve.

In July, Alexander members voted to return chief Kurt Burnstick to power along with three of the six councillors.

The following month, an appeal board ruled that a regulation requiring the unanimous consent of chief and council for an early election call had been violated.

'Setting people up for failure'

But that wasn't the only challenge. Band member Rodney Yellowdirt and others argued off-reserve members should be eligible to vote. The appeal board didn't rule on their challenge.

"What kind of decision is the appeal board making?," asked Yellowdirt, criticizing officials for going ahead with a new election based on the same rules. "They're setting people up for failure."

Yellowdirt, who first challenged voter eligibility rules in 2011, characterized the rules as discriminatory.

He pointed out that many members are forced to leave the reserve due to lack of housing. They also leave the reserve to pursue careers or education, he said.

The election squabbling is just the latest challenge on the reserve, 40 kilometres northwest of Edmonton.

Last year, police charged Burnstick with sexual assault, prompting a protest in the community calling for his resignation.

A financial review conducted for Indigenous and Northern Affairs Canada identified more than $5.3 million in payments lacking sufficient supporting documentation between April 2010 and March 2016.

Shane Arcand tried to vote in July. But a video shows election officials prevented him from casting a ballot because he currently lives in Edmonton.

"It's one of my rights that I've always been able to vote, that I've always had a say in what was happening in the community and that's been taken away from me," said Arcand, adding he has voted in every election since he was 21.

Arcand said he tried to clarify whether he was eligible to vote prior to his trip to the ballot box, but couldn't reach election officials.

andrea.huncar@cbc.ca                  @andreahuncar


Andrea Huncar


Andrea Huncar reports on human rights and justice. Contact her in confidence at andrea.huncar@cbc.ca