Edmonton·The Big Spend

Camrose-Drumheller region sees highest unemployment rate in Alberta

Officials say the weakened tourism industry and oil and gas sector are some reasons why the Camrose-Drumheller region has seen Alberta's largest increase in unemployment rates over the last four months.

Local officials say a weakened tourism sector, oil and gas industry part of the reason

The Camrose-Drumheller region has seen Alberta’s largest increase in unemployment rates over the last four months compared to 2019 numbers. (CBC News)

This story is part of The Big Spend, a CBC News investigation examining the unprecedented $240 billion the federal government handed out during the first eight months of the pandemic.


Until three weeks ago, Bob Willis was planning for the steam-powered train in Stettler to have customers aboard for the Christmas holidays.

But as the pandemic continued and provincial restrictions limited options, it became clear that the central Alberta tourist attraction wouldn't operate for most of 2020.

"We have not turned a wheel since March, which means quite a bit to us," said Willis, general manager of Alberta Prairie Steam Tours.

Bob Willis, general manager of Alberta Prairie Steam Tours in Stettler, says the steam train hasn't operated since March. (CBC News)

The tourism industry in central Alberta has been badly hurt by the pandemic, as have tourist centres across the province, with many companies relying on federal supports to get through the pandemic.

Officials say the weakened tourism industry is one reason why the Camrose-Drumheller region over the last four months has seen Alberta's largest increase in unemployment when compared to 2019 numbers.

The statistics are based on three-month moving averages.

Even now, with things opening up a little bit, it still hasn't come back.- Norman Mayer, mayor of Camrose

The regions' oil and gas industries are also part of the reason why the area is seeing higher-than-average unemployment rates compared to the rest of Alberta, officials say.

"Those are two areas that have been hit badly with the shutdown because of COVID-19," said Norman Mayer, mayor of Camrose. 

"Even now, with things opening up a little bit, it still hasn't come back."

Several communities within the region have residents who work in oil and gas and related industries.

In the east, hundreds of people in Hardisty, Alta., a central oil and gas hub, are employed in the industry.

There are also people working for oil and gas companies in the Drumheller area.

"In regards to our oil and gas industry that we do have here, it has been sluggish the last couple of years," said Heather Bitz, executive director of the Drumheller and district chamber of commerce. 

The federal economic region of Camrose-Drumheller covers a large portion of the eastern part of the province, extending east to the Saskatchewan border and going as far north as the area northeast of Edmonton. It extends to the south to the Vulcan area.

The area is seeing signs of improvement. The region's unemployment rate was at its highest in August and has dropped since, according to the provincial labour surveys. 

But the unemployment rate in November (based on three-month moving averages) remained the highest in the province.

Relying on government aid

Many businesses have relied heavily on the federal government business support programs, like the Canada emergency wage subsidy (CEWS), to keep staff employed during the pandemic. 

"We've heard from businesses that the wage subsidy program has been a huge help to a lot of businesses who have applied for it," said Bitz.

Uptake in the CEWS program in Alberta has been higher than other provinces like B.C. and Manitoba, with 27 per cent — or 46,360— of Alberta businesses with employees (as stated in June) accessing the wage subsidy program at least once, according to Nov. 22 federal government numbers.

Regional statistics aren't available for the wage subsidy program or the business loan program, the two largest supports for businesses.

CBC News obtained regional application data for the third largest program for businesses, the Canada emergency commercial rent assistance program (CECRA), which ended Sept. 30.

Despite the problematic program criteria, the first round of rent subsidies benefited some businesses across Alberta, and in the Camrose-Drumheller region.

There were 907 applications for rent subsidies from the Camrose-Drumheller region, with the amount received totalling around $4.7 million. 

That accounts for almost two per cent of the $281.73 million received from landlords across Alberta.

Since the first round of the program required commercial property owners to apply, it's not clear how many specific businesses received dollars under the program.

Federal Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland says the revamped rent relief subsidy should help businesses that have survived this far. (Sean Kilpatrick/The Canadian Press)

Federal Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland has said the government expects more businesses to apply for the revised rent subsidy program to get through what she called the second wave of COVID-19.

"As much of our country is fighting a second wave of the coronavirus, this support is especially important now for our businesses and our economy," Freeland said at a news conference last month. 

"This is the right thing for us to do and it is the economically smart thing for us to do."

Next few months

For some business owners in the region, rent subsidy isn't enough.

Pat McCarthy has been grounded since March and forced to pivot his business during the pandemic. 

The international business and marketing consultant and real estate developer, based in Camrose, is self-employed, and without an office space is ineligible for the wage and rent subsidies. 

"We've burned up a lot of our family jewels to stay alive through this so far," he said. "I really am not too interested to keep doing that any longer."

Pat McCarthy, an international consultant from Camrose, has not been able to apply for the federal wage subsidy and rent relief support. (CBC News)

What many small businesses need most is to return to normal sales, said Annie Dormuth, Alberta spokesperson for the Canadian Federation of Independent Business.

With that not expected to happen within the next few months, she and other experts have suggested provincial and federal governments look at injecting cash, not loan deferrals, into small businesses.

It would be a welcome financial boost for many businesses in the Camrose area, said Jason Heise, president of the Camrose and district chamber of commerce.

A business owner himself, Heise said many of the programs aren't sufficiently covering expenses and revenue losses.

"The federal government can do more for Western Canada," he said.

Until it does, he said, local businesses will try to hang on.

"They're doing what typical Albertans do: We survive."

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversationCreate account

Already have an account?

now