Crime law to target 'most heinous' offenders: Peter MacKay

Justice Minister Peter MacKay elaborated Friday on the government's throne speech promise to to lock up criminals convicted of the worst crimes — such as multiple murders or sex assaults on children — and throw away the key.

'It's all about catering to the fearful and the angry,' says criminologist Neil Boyd

Justice Minister Peter MacKay elaborated Friday on a throne speech promise to ensure crimes against the 'most vulnerable' carry the harshest punishments, and to close legal loopholes that the 'worst offenders' could exploit. (Andrew Vaughan/Canadian Press)

Criminals who are convicted of the worst crimes — such as multiple murders or sex assaults on children — could spend the rest of their lives behind bars, with no chance of parole, under planned federal legislation.

Justice Minister Peter MacKay elaborated Friday on the government's plan, promised in this week's throne speech, to lock some criminals up and throw away the key.

"We are talking about individuals who have committed the most heinous crimes serving an entire life in prison," MacKay said during a conference call to discuss the Conservative government's justice-related priorities.

It's all about catering to the fearful and the angry.- Neil Boyd, criminologist

MacKay said the forthcoming provisions would be applied very narrowly.

"When I say the worst of the worst, the most violent, repeat offenders, we're talking about multiple murders, multiple sexual assaults on the most vulnerable — our children," he said. "We want to ensure that certain individuals capable and convicted of those offences will never be let out of prison.

"The primary responsibility of any government, first and foremost, is to protect the public. And we intend to amplify and buttress our ability to do that."

Asked to cite the kind of offender the bill would cover, MacKay mentioned notorious sex killer Paul Bernardo as "an obvious example."

Bernardo is classified as a "dangerous offender," all but ensuring he is never set free.

'System works really well'

MacKay acknowledged there are already tools — such as the dangerous offender designation — to keep some criminals from being released. The Conservative government has also scrapped the so-called faint-hope clause that allowed some inmates with life sentences to seek early parole.

Still, the government wants to ensure "there are no loopholes" in the law that criminals can exploit, MacKay said.

"This would both provide surety and public confidence, and that is the intent in bringing about further changes. I can't really say more than that until we have the legislation before Parliament."

The planned law will not make society any safer, but is sure to appeal to voters who demand harsher punishment for criminals, said Neil Boyd, a criminologist at Simon Fraser University in British Columbia.

"It's all about catering to the fearful and the angry," Boyd said. "It's symbolic, it's not going to have any effect on the crime rate."

MacKay is quite right to say that some people should never be let out of jail, but there are already provisions in the law to ensure that, he added.

"Does anybody really think that Paul Bernardo will ever be let out of jail? The system works relatively well," Boyd said.

University of Toronto criminologist Anthony Doob echoed those thoughts, pointing to the case of now-dead serial killer Clifford Olson.

"What you have to remember is that the 'most heinous' people don't get out," Doob said.

"Was anyone really concerned that Clifford Olson might be released? He could have lived decades longer and still would never have been released."

Tougher penalties have consistently been a pillar of the Conservative approach to criminal justice since taking power in 2006, and the party has no time for those who question the rationale.

"That is in sharp contrast to the position that others have taken," MacKay said.

"It flies directly in the face of the faint-hope clause, which in many cases re-victimized victims of violent offenders, who were constantly reminded of their loss and dragged before a parole hearing."

The government has also promised a victims bill of rights, stricter sentences for sex offenders and specific penalties for harming police service animals.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?