Chocolate milk has become an udderly divisive issue

Chocolate milk has become politicized in recent months with the discussion around chocolate milk restrictions in schools. And one expert argues the polarized debate might be harming public health advocacy.

Chocolate milk has become a pawn in a left vs. right political battle

A health expert argues that replacing milk with chocolate milk is like replacing apples with apple pie (Shutterstock)

Chocolate milk has become politicized in recent months with the discussion around chocolate milk restrictions in schools. And one health expert argues the polarized debate might be harming public health advocacy.

Some say the beverage contains too much sugar (about 26 grams of sugar in 240 millilitres of 1% partly skimmed chocolate milk, compared to 12 grams of sugar in 240 millilitres of 1% partly skimmed milk). Others argue kids won't drink milk if it's not sweetened and flavoured.

Dominic Cardy, the Minister of Education and Early Childhood Development for the New Brunswick provincial government, argued that kids need calories.

"Would you rather have kids have some calories in their stomach or none? You need the calories to start with," he said in a CBC Radio interview.

New Brunswick became the epicentre of the chocolate milk debate this year when the previous Liberal government restricted the sale of the beverage in schools.

It was such a contentious issue that the Progressive Conservative Party of New Brunswick campaigned on bringing it back in the September 2018 provincial election.

They won the election with a minority and chocolate milk has since returned to schools throughout the province.

A similar debate played out in the United States when Obama-era restrictions on chocolate milk in school lunch programs were overturned this fall by U.S. President Donald Trump.

Chocolate milk has become a political pawn

It's all a little much for Dr. Yoni Freedhoff, a bariatric doctor who specializes in medical weight management and a passionate advocate for better obesity and nutrition policy.

He says chocolate milk has become a pawn in a left vs. right political battle.

Left-leaning politicians aim to restrict access in schools, while right-leaning politicians treat any restrictions as an infringement on rights and freedoms.

Dr. Yoni Freedhoff says people believe putting sugar in milk is necessary to make children drink it. (Pierre Fournier/CBC News)

"Politics is not about the best interest of the public. It's about getting elected. That's cynical, but I think it's truthful," said Freedhoff. "If the public can be stirred up to oppose a policy, that in itself is smart, thoughtful policy … If the public isn't behind that, the politicians won't be behind that. Because if you're not behind what the public wants, you might not get elected."

For a guy who has spent a career advocating for public health policy changes based on evidence, the current political divide on chocolate milk is a bit frustrating.

'A nonsensical argument' not supported by health or science

As milk has become an indicator of people's position on the political spectrum, Freedhoff says public health advocacy becomes an uphill battle.

"It's a bit sad-making really," said Freedhoff. "I think, in some cases, people are being manipulated to believe that milk is a magical beverage and that putting sugar in milk is important if your child doesn't drink regular milk, which is akin to suggesting that if your child doesn't like apples, you should serve them apple pie. It's a nonsensical argument. It's certainly not one that's supported in the context of health or science."

Despite what most public health advocates say about chocolate milk, it's back on some menus — for now.

While the current version of Canada's Food Guide suggests chocolate milk as a reasonable option, the latest version, which is currently in the works, is expected to remove it.

Early drafts of the new guide promote water as the best option for healthful hydration.

About the Author

Khalil Akhtar

Food Columnist

Khalil Akhtar is a syndicated food columnist for CBC Radio. He takes a weekly look at some of the surprising aspects of your daily diet. Khalil is based in Victoria, B.C.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.