Canada

Federal government says Canada Post must deliver Epoch Times despite union objection

The federal government has declined a request from a postal workers union local in Toronto to issue an order stopping delivery of a special coronavirus edition of the Epoch Times, because it doesn’t meet the criminal threshold for hate speech.

Union rep asked minister to halt delivery of coronavirus issue over carrier concerns it could stoke hate

A copy of the Epoch Times was delivered to Lisa Armstrong in Kelowna, B.C., though she is not a subscriber. She says she found the content 'inflammatory.' (Submitted by Lisa Armstrong)

The federal government has declined a request from a postal workers union local in Toronto to issue an order stopping delivery of a special coronavirus edition of the Epoch Times, because it doesn't meet the criminal threshold for hate speech.

The special eight-page edition is headlined, "How the Chinese Communist Party Endangered the World." It includes an editorial arguing the coronavirus should be called the "CCP virus," a reference to the Chinese Communist Party, as well as an opinion piece that raises questions over whether the virus could have been created as a bioweapon by the Chinese military.

Derek Richmond, vice-president of the Scarborough local of the Canadian Union of Postal Workers in northeastern Toronto, said copies started showing up in some mail stations in the city last Friday. Several union members expressed concern the newspaper could fuel hatred toward the Chinese Canadian community, Richmond said.

The next day, Richmond wrote to Public Services Minister Anita Anand, the minister responsible for Canada Post, to ask for an interim order to stop delivery of the newspaper.

"We felt that Canada Post was very irresponsible in accepting this material, and it's putting not only the Asian community at risk of xenophobia, but our letter carriers as well," said Richmond.

A spokesperson for CUPW's national executive committee said the union is aware of the concerns and has brought them to the attention of Canada Post. 

"CUPW considers this item to be inflammatory, and we disagree with our members being put in a position to have to distribute this messaging. We will continue to monitor the situation," said Carl Girouard, the national grievance officer for CUPW, in an email to CBC News.

A special eight-page edition of the Epoch Times was delivered to some households across Canada. (Submitted by Carol Harman)

Anand notified Richmond on Monday that she wouldn't take steps to stop delivery, but assured him that her "officials will look into this further."

"Decisions made by Canada Post to deliver or refuse delivery of neighbourhood mail are subject to the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms," wrote Cecely Roy, a spokesperson for the public services minister, in an email to CBC News.

"An initial assessment of this material does not appear to meet the required criteria of the offence of wilful promotion of hatred, as established in the Criminal Code of Canada. However, further assessment is ongoing."

CBC News reached out to the Canadian publisher of Epoch Times, Cindy Gu, to ask about Richmond's request and Anand's response but did not receive a reply before publication.

Earlier in the week, in an email to CBC News, Gu said the Epoch Times has recently been distributing sample copies in select areas of "a special edition on Beijing's coverup that led to a global pandemic," because the newspaper considers the information to be important to Canadians.

"We regard this sampling as an act of good citizenship," she wrote.

The Epoch Times is a non-profit media organization founded by Chinese immigrants in the U.S. in 2000. It is closely associated with followers of Falun Gong, a religious practice that was declared a cult by the Chinese government in 1999. Falun Gong members have been persecuted by the Chinese government, including being jailed and tortured, according to human rights groups.

A stack of the special edition of the Epoch Times in a Toronto Canada Post station. (Submitted by a Canada Post carrier)
 

In a statement to CBC News, Canada Post said the agency is obligated to deliver any mail that is properly prepared and paid for, unless it is considered non-mailable matter.

"The Courts have told Canada Post that its role is not to act as the 'censor' of mail or to determine the extent of freedom of expression in Canada," the agency said in a statement.

"This is an important distinction between Canada Post and private sector delivery companies. Any views we may have about the content do not change our obligation to deliver."

'We simply asked questions'

In a statement Thursday, the U.S. Office of the Director of National Intelligence, the umbrella body for U.S. spy agencies, said it concurs with "the wide scientific consensus that the COVID-19 virus was not manmade or genetically modified."

The statement also says the U.S. will continue to rigorously examine intelligence to "determine whether the outbreak began through contact with infected animals or if it was the result of an accident at a laboratory in Wuhan, [China]."

Gu, the publisher of the Epoch Times, says the Wuhan lab is a small part of their reporting on the coronavirus.

"We simply asked questions like many others. In the past, CCP top military officials openly talked about the development of bioweapons. Whether the virus is engineered or not has neither been proven nor disproven at this point," she wrote in an email.

Scientists who have compared changes in the novel coronavirus genome against other coronaviruses say the virus almost certainly evolved naturally and recently made the leap from wild animals to humans just as both SARS and MERS coronaviruses did, probably as the result of close animal-human contact.

Letter carriers upset

After CBC News published a story about the newspaper on Wednesday, Canadians in Calgary, Whitehorse, Ottawa, several rural Ontario locations and Montreal reached out to report receiving a copy, though they are not subscribers to the weekly paper.

Two letter carriers in Toronto, both of Asian descent, wrote to their union to express concerns over the Epoch Times. CBC News is not naming them because they say they could face disciplinary action for speaking out.

"The title of this particular newspaper could cause a lot of hatred toward Asians," wrote one carrier in an email to the union.

"There is a difference between Chinese and Chinese Communist Party, but in reality, people would ignore the difference and blame everything on the Chinese."

WATCH Health Canada cracks down on false coronavirus claims:

Health Canada has sent 27 compliance letters warning about making unproven claims about COVID-19 to naturopaths, TV stations and major retailers including Canadian Tire and Amazon. 1:58

Another carrier echoed those thoughts in an email to the union.

"Not only are there a number of our own employees that are offended by this content, but this flyer will be sent all over the [Greater Toronto Area]," he wrote. "During this sensitive time with the COVID-19 pandemic, such content may provoke hatred and discrimination toward the Chinese-Canadian community."

But Gu, the publisher of the Epoch Times, says the newspaper clearly distinguishes between the Chinese government and the people.

"Some people may have erroneously conflated criticism of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) with criticism of the Chinese people. The Chinese Communist Party does not represent the Chinese people or China," she wrote.

"Understanding the difference is vital and will eliminate racial tension, as people come to understand that the criticism of the handling of the virus is of the CCP, not the Chinese people."

Add some “good” to your morning and evening.

A variety of newsletters you'll love, delivered straight to you.

Sign up now

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

now