Calgary

Alberta MLA lends credence to COVID-19 'concentration camps' misinformation

Banff-Kananaskis MLA Miranda Rosin on Tuesday reassured a constituent that the provincial government would never create COVID-19 "concentration camps" — but added that if the "rumours" were true, it would be the federal government's doing.

Health expert says those with high profiles can rapidly escalate spread of conspiracy theories

Miranda Rosin, the MLA for Banff-Kananaskis, appeared to lend credence to a disinformation campaign circulating on social media in recent weeks. The UCP member wrote on Facebook that the provincial government would never create COVID-19 'concentration camps.' (Legislative Assembly of Alberta)

Banff-Kananaskis MLA Miranda Rosin on Tuesday reassured a constituent that the provincial government would never create COVID-19 "concentration camps" — but added that if the "rumours" were true, it would involve the federal government.

In doing so, Rosin helped to spread a misinformation campaign that has been been circulating on social media for weeks, says a health policy expert.

"It's a pretty hardcore conspiracy theory," said Timothy Caulfield, a Canada Research Chair in health law and policy at the University of Alberta. "It's extremely disappointing to have government officials, elected officials, helping spread this disinformation."

In a comment posted to Rosin's Facebook page, a constituent requested that government "STOP the COVID concentration camps."

In response, Rosin commented that, "If the rumours are true, those are being set up by the federal government, not us."

"Rest assured we would never create such a thing," she wrote.

While responding to a constituent on Tuesday, MLA Miranda Rosin said the provincial government would never create so-called COVID-19 concentration camps, referring to a disinformation campaign circulating on social media. (Facebook)

Earlier this week, health officials pushed back against the spread of the misinformation, the crux of which claims that the federal government is preparing to forcibly send Canadians to quarantine sites.

Funding has been announced for voluntary quarantine sites for homeless Canadians, and the federal government has plans to expand the number of sites available for international travellers who need to self-isolate but do not have space to do so. 

But a spokesperson for Health Minister Patty Hajdu told CBC News earlier this week that no one will be forced to leave their homes to go into a "COVID camp."

Speaking Tuesday, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau said he had to tell a young woman that the government would not remove Canadians from their homes to put them in facilities.

"There is a tremendous amount of noise and harmful misinformation about [the pandemic] on the internet.…  We need to hold together and resist people who would sow chaos within our communities and our democracy," he said.

MLA says she received hateful correspondence

In an update posted on Facebook , Rosin said Thursday that she should have denounced the constituent's use of the term "concentration camp."

"Yet in the moment, I quickly responded to him that the leak was but a rumour at this point, and that if such facilities were being set up, they were not being done so by our provincial government," Rosin wrote.

"We have worked hard to reopen Alberta's economy, and we aren't moving backwards."

Sharing an email purportedly received after the post, Rosin wrote that she had been insulted and called names typically used to denigrate women.

"As a society, we can and we should behave better. I believe in a world where we can all treat each other humanely no matter how much we may disagree on things. Politics don't need to divide us like this," she wrote.

Rosin was not immediately available to provide additional comment on Thursday.

Speaking to Alberta talk radio host Danielle Smith on Monday, Alberta Premier Jason Kenney said no government was engaging in the mandatory quarantine of Canadians, as purported by a recent disinformation campaign. (The Canadian Press)

In response to a request for comment, a spokesperson for Premier Jason Kenney's office referred CBC News to a recent interview with the premier by Alberta talk radio host Danielle Smith.

"I think a certain conspiracy theory has developed around this," Kenney said on the radio show. "My understanding was that it was basically for hotel rooms for arriving international travellers."

Kenney said Alberta has taken similar steps, such as when the province saw large outbreaks in meat-packing plants earlier this year.

"We offered to put a number of those people up in hotels during the quarantine period," Kenney said. "I think that some of this is turning into, unfortunately, a conspiracy theory. No government is going to engage in mandatory quarantine of people."

Expert says misinformation can erode trust in health policy

Caulfield said that when high-profile individuals in society like politicians, sports stars or celebrities spread misinformation, it can help conspiracy theories take flight.

"There's a good body of research emerging on exactly that," he said. "Even if you don't necessarily align yourself with that individual, just their ability to get that misinformation out there causes it to spread. There's been research that has backed up exactly that."

University of Alberta professor Timothy Caulfield says misinformation in a public health crisis can lead to hospitalization, financial loss and adverse impacts on health and science policy. (Sam Martin/CBC)

Caulfield said that those who align themselves with misinformation and conspiracy theories are less likely to adopt appropriate precautions, such as wearing masks or following physical distancing rules.

"So when we have politicians making irresponsible statements, you're really contributing to a public health crisis," he said. "The other thing that is fascinating about this story, is this is a pretty hardcore conspiracy theory. This is not something that is even rational.

"It demonstrates the incredible traction that misinformation can have."

Speaking Tuesday, Dr. Theresa Tam, Canada's chief public health officer, said it was up to every Canadian to fight the spread of fake news and fight back against false information.

"That is a dual challenge, for sure. Misinformation, disinformation, does not help public health officials," she said.

WATCH: Dr. Theresa Tam is asked about bogus COVID-19 claims:

Canada's chief public health officer says it's up to everyone to fight fake news

Politics

1 month agoVideo
3:12
Dr. Theresa Tam answered questions today about the rise of fake news online during the pandemic. 3:12

With files from John Paul Tasker

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

now