Crisis a day keeps focus away: Did Albertans give UCP a mandate for all this?
Even staunch defenders are treading lightly
Did the UCP campaign in Alberta's spring election on replacing the RCMP with a provincial police force, pulling out of the Canada Pension Plan, significant cuts to education and health care, a private member's bill that could affect access to abortion and firing the election commissioner after more than $200,000 in fines were issued related to their own leadership race?
Were these actions what Albertans voted for when they handed Jason Kenney and the United Conservative Party a majority government, ousting Rachel Notley's incumbent NDP?
That depends on who you ask, as CBC Calgary's Alberta@Noon heard on Tuesday..
However, even staunch defenders were treading lightly.
"It's very controversial and it's going to get a lot of tongues wagging," Monte Solberg, a former MP for the Reform Party, Canadian Alliance and then Conservative parties, told Alberta@Noon.
"This is in alignment with where the government said it would go, but the optics are absolutely … they are pretty bad."
Solberg represented Medicine Hat, Alta., as an MP from 1993 until he retired from the role in 2008. He was a federal cabinet minister and has long been a supporter of now-premier Jason Kenney. As a political strategist and principal with New West Public Affairs in Calgary, Solberg urged Albertans to vote for UCP.
- Irregular votes, panicked moves, kiosks: Insiders detail the last days of Jason Kenney's campaign
- Fraudulent emails used to cast votes in UCP leadership race, CBC finds
Zain Velji, a campaign strategist and political analyst, went a bit further.
"I think it's a brazen move," said Velji, a partner at Northweather.
"It's about a crisis a day. This doesn't allow citizens or the media to get a full dissection on what's going on because we have to cover the next thing. It's called changing the channel. You do something that people don't like, you don't want them to talk about it, you throw something else at them."
- Alberta NDP Leader Rachel Notley thrown out of house in Bill 22 stand-off
- UCP denies political interference over plan to fire election commissioner
The United Conservative Party won 63 of the Alberta's 87 ridings in the April election, with 55 per cent of the popular vote.
Kenney campaigned on jobs, the economy and pipelines, and regularly criticized NDP Leader Rachel Notley for not mentioning a carbon tax in her platform before winning the 2015 election but then introducing one.
Kenney also said he would not "bring forward legislative measures on abortion" if elected.
- CBC Investigates | 'Left with fines, charges and shame': Calgary political insider alleges voter fraud in UCP leadership campaign
- Investigation into Jason Kenney's UCP leadership campaign spreads
Yet, earlier this month, a UCP MLA, Dan Williams, introduced private member's bill 207, which would not only let Alberta doctors refuse to advise or assist on things they object to due to for personal or religious beliefs like abortions, contraception or medically assisted death — something they already have the right to do under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms — but also drops the current obligation that they steer patients elsewhere for help.
All the UCP MLAs in attendance for the first reading of the Conscience Rights (Health Care Providers) Protection Act voted to pass it while all NDP MLAs voted against it.
Critics say it would reduce abortion access, especially in rural communities with few doctors.
On Monday, the UCP announced omnibus Bill 22 — which would allow the firing of the election commissioner, who is investigating fraud in the party's 2017 leadership race that elected Kenney. Lorne Gibson has dished out fines totalling more than $200,000 so far.
- Jason Kenney says office investigating his leadership campaign isn't safe from cuts
- 5 Alberta cabinet ministers have now been interviewed by RCMP in voter fraud probe
Finance Minister Travis Toews says it's not about undermining current investigations, it's about the $1 million in savings over five years. Gibson would see his office merged with that of the province's chief electoral officer.
But the move drew criticism from the opposition and questions about interference in the work of an independent officer of the legislative assembly.
"It reeks of corruption. This is farther than I have ever seen any other political leader in Canada go," Notley said Monday.
- Lack of public input stalls physician conscience bill at legislature committee
- 'This is redundant': 2 UCP members announce opposition to conscience rights bill
A political scientist says it doesn't look good.
"The optics of firing the guy or removing his position, who is investigating the party, looks really bad. And it is bad," said Duane Bratt, a professor at Mount Royal University.
Toews wasn't available Tuesday to defend the bill on Alberta@Noon.
"It does save money," Solberg said. "It puts Alberta on the same footing as every other province in the country."
- Advocates concerned Alberta conscience rights bill could put trans people at risk
- OPINION | The first cut is the deepest: UCP's debut budget aims for public sector
But, he concedes, it's a tough sell.
"This is a no-win situation for the UCP, so they felt now is the best time to make this move."
Velji says, however, this goes beyond what the party promised.
"The electorate has given Jason Kenney the mandate to cut expenditures, but not at any cost," he said.
- University of Calgary to slash 250 jobs after provincial funding cuts
- 'Risky ventures': Alberta unions worry about plan to put pensions under government control
"No way has this government been given the mandate to do stuff like this."
And caller Tyler Lambert of Edmonton told Alberta@Noon he agrees.
"It is incredibly corrupt, what they are doing," Lambert said.
- Public education advocate questions why religious universities were spared cuts
- Colleges and universities learn the extent of cuts to government grants
"They advocated jobs and pipelines and they are cutting all of these social services. There is no job creation there. He is not standing up for Albertans, not in my eyes."
A Calgary caller was on the same page.
"It doesn't look bad. It is bad," Doug Wilson said, defending the work of the elections commissioner.
"I can't believe for a moment that [Lorne Gibson] would do so without any form of substantiation. To remove him could change the entire investigation and make it a whitewash. It speaks to a certain level of ethical bankruptcy, in my mind."
- Alberta finance minister on defensive after 'job creation' tax cut spurs spending elsewhere
- Husky Energy announces layoffs
Velji says for some voters, it's a matter of sticking with your team.
"If you like Jason Kenney, you will rationalize, justify and find every excuse to continue liking Jason Kenney. If you don't, you won't," Velji said.
"As long as you get me jobs, economy and pipelines, then I am fine. Right now, let's be totally candid, very little movement on the economy, jobs and pipelines. At some point, people are going to ask for the receipts."
- Alberta premier says proposal to pull out of CPP due to 'hostility' from others
- Inquiry commissioner Steve Allan campaigned for Alberta Justice Minister Doug Schweitzer
Solberg says many conservatives will see it differently.
"People are still overwhelmingly with the government. It is you versus the other parties. When people look around, they don't want to go back to the NDP. That's not an option for them."
Another Edmonton caller wasn't so sure, saying trust is paramount.
"I have never been mad enough to phone in before, but I am now," Brian Kaliel said.
- Alberta government won't investigate controversial $905K sole-source contract
- Jason Kenney touts $30M 'war room' but provides few details
"I am not a partisan party member by any stretch. I am the kind of guy Jason Kenney should be paying attention to. Once you have lost a voter's trust, you are not going to get it back. I think most Albertans are concerned about good governance, somebody who will be honest and manage our affairs in a careful, prudent way. The urban voters in Edmonton already don't trust him, and I would be concerned about voters in Calgary, if I were him."
Matt Bergin of Edmonton tweeted what's on the minds of some.
"Firing the elections commissioner in the midst of an investigation is troubling and very bad optics," Bergin wrote.
"Moving teachers pension to government control is OK only if they get the same or better returns."
Firing the elections commissioner in the midst of an investigation is troubling and very bad optics. Moving teachers pension to government control is ok only if they get the same or better returns.—@InsuranceByMatt
- Alberta energy war room not subject to freedom of information rules
- Energy giant Encana to move HQ from Calgary to the U.S.
Tamara Lee of Calgary said this government has not been as advertised.
"I expected an ideological budget, not a cruel and vindictive one," Lee tweeted.
"I expected downplaying the leadership campaign investigation, not firing the investigator and dissolving his office mid-investigation. I expected an effort to increase jobs, not corporate tax gifts and layoffs."
No. I expected an ideological budget, not a cruel and vindictive one. I expected downplaying the leadership campaign investigation, not firing the investigator and dissolving his office mid-investigation. I expected an effort to increase jobs, not corporate tax gifts and layoffs.—@micropainter
- Thousands of students protest UCP's GSA plan with Alberta-wide walkout
- 2018 | Jason Kenney's UCP inner circle made up of former Ottawa staffers
Caller Don Smith who has a farming background near Edmonton had some predictions.
"Trump won't get impeached, he will probably get re-elected. Kenney will get re-elected. We will forget all about this and life will go on," Smith said.
"Under the NDP, I could not have survived another four years. We are in trouble now. I am hoping Kenney is going to bring the jobs back and I am willing to overlook the rest of it."
Solberg says, meanwhile, the speed and content of some of these bills may not go over well with even some of Kenney's supporters.
"It absolutely will impact their support, and the government is going to have to answer a lot of tough questions," Solberg said.
Velji says none of this came out of left field.
"Jason Kenney knows what he is doing: a crisis a day that gets everyone's attention. None of this is a mistake. This is all deliberate."
Two points of view on <a href="https://twitter.com/Alberta_UCP?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">@Alberta_UCP</a>'s recent string of controversial bills <a href="https://twitter.com/montesolberg?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">@MonteSolberg</a> <a href="https://twitter.com/zainvelji?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">@ZainVelji</a> <a href="https://t.co/6pewnqfa5D">https://t.co/6pewnqfa5D</a> <a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/ableg?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#ableg</a> <a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/abpoli?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#abpoli</a> <a href="https://twitter.com/AlbertaatNoon?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">@AlbertaatNoon</a> <a href="https://t.co/zO0QOV0XLj">pic.twitter.com/zO0QOV0XLj</a>—@DavidBellCBC
With files from Alberta@Noon
To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.
By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.
Become a CBC Account Holder
Join the conversation Create account
Already have an account?