Calgary

Rival all-Alberta Indigenous coalition sets sights on Trans Mountain pipeline

Indigenous competition for the right to buy an equity stake in the Trans Mountain pipeline system is heating up, with an Alberta group announcing Wednesday it intends to assemble a province-wide coalition of supporters.

Iron Coalition, an Alberta-based group, would compete with another Indigenous bidder on pipeline

Three members of the Iron Coalition after their meeting with federal Finance Minister Bill Morneau in Edmonton. From left: Legal counsel Will Willier, Chief Tony Alexis with Alexis Nakota First Nation and Chief Calvin Bruneau with the Papaschase First Nation. (Geneviève Normand/Radio-Canada)

Indigenous competition for the right to buy an equity stake in the Trans Mountain pipeline system is heating up, with an Alberta group announcing Wednesday it intends to assemble a province-wide coalition of supporters.

Iron Coalition said it has formally invited 47 First Nations and about 60 Métis organizations in the province to sign up for the effort, which was endorsed by the Alberta-based Assembly of Treaty Chiefs last fall.

The initiative puts it on a potential collision course with Project Reconciliation, a consortium inviting Indigenous participation from B.C., Alberta and Saskatchewan in a $6.8-billion bid for a 51 per cent stake in the energy pipeline linking Edmonton and the West Coast.

"The Alberta chiefs are mandated and speak within the territory of Alberta and so, initially, that's where we began," Iron Coalition co-chairman Tony Alexis, chief of the Alexis Nakota Sioux Nation located 85 kilometres northwest of Edmonton, said in an interview.

"Our hope is that the Indigenous communities in B.C. will follow our lead and build a similar coalition and then together we can approach the federal government to negotiate the best deal possible."

Distribution of proceeds

Iron Coalition said it will distribute 100 per cent of the proceeds to each member community based on ownership share and population if it succeeds in buying a stake.

That differs from Project Reconciliation's plan, announced last week, to direct 20 per cent of Trans Mountain's estimated $180 million in future annual cash flow to shareholder communities while the rest would be used to create a sovereign wealth fund.

The fund would be reinvested in projects like renewable energy, energy-efficient on-reserve housing and other greenhouse gas-reducing, climate friendly initiatives.

Iron Coalition can't provide any financial details of its plan because the Trans Mountain expansion project hasn't been approved, its costs are unknown and it's unclear how the federal government will structure a sale of the pipeline, Alexis said. He said the group could seek an equity stake of between 50 and 100 per cent.

Project Reconciliation welcomes competition

Delbert Wapass, executive chairman and founder of Project Reconciliation, applauded the Iron Coalition decision to bid and said he expects more bidders to emerge, adding that if Project Reconciliation's proposal is chosen, it would invite supporters of rival Indigenous bids to come aboard.

"I think it clearly demonstrates the excitement among First Nations that they are actually going to be included as players in the bid for the Trans Mountain pipeline," the former chief of Saskatchewan's Thunderchild First Nation said in an interview.

"When I started this whole campaign for our 51 per cent majority bid on Trans Mountain, it was about including everybody — I still believe that's the right decision because many of our communities are affected by poverty … we have been economically starved."

He said his group has been signing up supporters but wouldn't say how many or if any are in Alberta.

The Western Indigenous Pipeline group, a coalition of B.C. bands who live along the pipeline expansion route, has also indicated it wants to bid for an equity stake in Trans Mountain.

Federal decision on pipeline looms

Federal Finance Minister Bill Morneau has said Ottawa won't negotiate the sale of the pipeline it bought for $4.5 billion last summer until after construction of its proposed expansion is "de-risked," without specifying what that means.

The government is to make a final decision on whether the expansion can proceed by June 18.

It was forced to reconsider its previous approval in August 2018 when the Federal Court of Appeal found there was inadequate consultation with affected Indigenous peoples.

Iron Coalition met with Morneau earlier this year, but Wapass said he doesn't think that gives it any advantage over Project Reconciliation.

In May, the Union of B.C. Indian Chiefs warned First Nations in an open letter that they should reconsider investing in the pipeline because it faces many hurdles, including Indigenous land claims, and it is unlikely to be as profitable as the government says.

But Wapass said his group stands by its projections.

He said ownership will allow Indigenous groups to better protect the environment in which the pipeline operates.

Iron Coalition is co-chaired by Chief Calvin Bruneau of the Edmonton-area Papaschase First Nation and president Ron Quintal of the Fort McKay Métis in northern Alberta.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.