Calgary

Report finds Chestermere golf course 'not economically viable,' backs up case to redevelop land

A recent feasibility report by MNP shows the Lakeside Greens golf course has lost hundreds of thousands of dollars in recent years, and that because the club is not likely to see membership numbers bounce back, the company is not a viable business in the long term.

Area residents fight redevelopment with 2,800-signature petition

A new feasibility report shows the Lakeside Greens Golf Course in Chestermere is not economically viable in the long term. (Lakeside Greens Golf Course Preservation Society )

A new feasibility report by national accounting firm MNP finds the Lakeside Greens Golf Course in Chestermere is "not economically viable as a long-term business" due to the company's shrinking revenues, the need for a costly overhaul to the grounds and clubhouse, and a dwindling interest in golf.

MNP was hired by the owners of the golf course to assess the company's financial status between 2014 and 2019 to determine the future viability of the course.

The owners have proposed closing the course and redeveloping the land to build a residential community — but are facing pushback from nearby homeowners.

MNP found Lakeside has not been profitable since 2015, mostly due to declining membership and corporate tournaments.

MNP said it had not audited or otherwise verified the unaudited financial statements provided by management in compiling the report. But the firm says, based on its review of the information, it has no reason to believe it is not accurate.

One of the club's owners said the external analysis reinforces the owners' case to redevelop the property.

"It's very clear, it's very obvious, and we don't want to hide anything. We want to look forward and basically explain to the City of Chestermere, to the community, that there is better use for that land and it will improve the life of all Chestermerians," said Peter Paauw, president of Slokker Homes.

Losing money

MNP says Lakeside's revenues dropped from roughly $2.4 million in 2016 to $2.2 million in 2019, a rate of 9.1 per cent, due to declining memberships, green fees and tournaments.

The club currently has 154 members, down from 194 in 2016.

When factoring in costs and operating expenses, MNP noted Lakeside was losing tens of thousands of dollars every year over that same time period.

For example, it said Lakeside ran with a $104,515 deficit in 2019.

The owners say on top of that they need to update the aging clubhouse and repair its retaining walls and pathway system, among other things — renovations which are estimated to cost nearly $600,000 per year for five years.

MNP says taking that into account, Lakeside would need to find a way to bring in an additional $700,000 per year, just to break even.

"The long and short of it is that the club operates at a cash loss and needs probably an injection of about $2.5 million just to fix deferred maintenance," said Paauw.

The report concludes that Lakeside will not turn the financial situation around.

"We do not believe that Lakeside Golf will be able to generate these additional revenues," it says, given low oil prices, the current fiscal situation and current research that shows golf participation worldwide is dropping.

And Paauw says for those who are interested in playing golf, they are choosing better-designed courses.

"(Lakeside) was built in the mid-'90s, truly as almost a farmer field golf course. It's not the nicest golf course to play, it's not the nicest golf course to live alongside. There's a lot of golf balls that go over fences and [are] hitting houses," said Paauw. 

Community pushback

Since the Lakeside club ownership announced it had signed a deal to partner with international developer and builder Slokker Homes to redevelop the property contingent upon approval by Chestermere city council, there has been a lot of pushback in the community. Some residents banded together to form the Lakeside Greens Golf Course Preservation Society and launched a petition.

"It's very, very clear by the 2,800-plus [petition] signatures and the people that we have emailing us and reaching out to us that the City of Chestermere and the residents, the homeowners, are not, not on board with this," said Darby King-Maillot, executive director, Lakeside Greens Golf Course Preservation Society.

King-Maillot lives beside the course. She says her whole family golfs there and they chose their home because of its location.

She believes the course should be sold off as a golf course, rather than redeveloped, because she says Chestermere needs a course.

"I just feel that if their business plan hasn't been working for them, that should not make a case for pulling out the bulldozers and putting condos in my backyard," said King-Maillot.

Paauw says he understands the concern but that he hopes to work with the community to come up with a design that everyone will be happy with. 

"We are engaging with the neighbourhood to make sure that we communicate our intent to make everything a win-win, including increasing property values for everyone involved," said Paauw.

Slokker Homes has not submitted any applications to the city yet.

It plans on holding two online information sessions regarding the future of Lakeside. The first is set for March 9. 

The City of Chestermere declined to do any interviews. Instead, it referred to a statement it released last month that's posted on the city website.

Paauw says MNP didn't include the financials from 2020 in its report because they weren't complete at the time of the review.

Clarifications

  • This story was updated on March 2, 2021, to add that MNP said it had not audited or otherwise verified the unaudited financial statements provided by management in compiling the report. But the firm says, based on its review of the information, it has no reason to believe it is not accurate.
    Mar 02, 2021 12:08 PM MT

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Colleen Underwood has been a reporter/editor with CBC news for more than 10 years filing stories from across southern Alberta for radio, television and online. Follow her on Twitter @cbccolleen.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?

now