Calgary

AHS report shows need for better cardiac services outside of Calgary, Edmonton

The long-awaited report does not make any firm recommendation but says both Red Deer and Lethbridge have enough patients to support cardiac catheterization labs.

Report says higher heart attack mortality rates in rural Alberta need to be addressed

After calling on AHS to bring cardiac catheterization to Red Deer for years, Dr. Kym Jim, internal specialist at the Red Deer Regional Hospital, calls the report a 'positive step.' (Jennifer Lee/CBC News)

A long-awaited Alberta Health Services report concludes cardiac care in the province is not working for rural Albertans and it affirms what some doctors outside of the province's two major cities have been saying for years — that Red Deer and Lethbridge have enough demand to support a life-saving heart treatment.

Cardiac catheterization, which allows doctors to eliminate life-threatening heart blockages, is available only at hospitals in Calgary and Edmonton. That means heart attack patients around the province have to be treated with clot-busting drugs before being sent by ground or air ambulance for the treatment.

Doctors in Red Deer have been raising the alarm about this set-up for years, saying people in central Alberta are dying because they don't have timely access to the treatment.

"To be very clear this is a very positive step forward," said Dr. Kym Jim, one of the physicians leading the push for a cath lab in Red Deer.

"[The report] clearly indicates that cardiac catheterization and advanced services can be delivered to central Alberta and that is the part that matters … because it really paves the way for discussions with AHS and government as to how to deliver these services," he said.

The AHS report — put together with Alberta Health and input from doctors, patients and families — stays clear of making a formal recommendation but does state that "continuing the current provincial models of service was not considered viable" by the oversight committee.

It also concludes that the higher heart attack mortality rates in rural Alberta need to be addressed "to improve health equity of Albertans" and says a cath lab would give patients closer access to care, improve their experience and boost confidence.

The report lays out two different options for addressing the disparity in heart treatment available to rural Albertans. The first involves beefing up cardiac services such as prevention and rehabilitation supports at five regional hospitals, without the addition of cardiac catheterization labs, while the the second option would see extra cardiac supports as well as cardiac cath labs added in both Red Deer and Lethbridge.

Report's mortality findings:

  •  58 central Albertans die of heart attack on average per year.
  •  0-2 of those deaths would be avoided with a catheterization lab.
  • 19-21 deaths would be avoided with other improved cardiac supports such as prevention programs.
The AHS report says continuing with the current model for cardiac services in Alberta is 'not considered viable.' (Kim Kyung Hoon/Reuters)

Dr. Dan Edgcumbe, AHS central zone medical director, says central Albertans are almost twice as likely to have a heart attack as people living in Calgary and the reasons for that are complex, ranging from lifestyle factors such as exercise levels and smoking habits to varying levels of support.

"There isn't going to be one strategy that fixes all of these problems. Some of these problems are deep and entrenched," said Edgcumbe.

"One of the key messages of the report is although a cath lab would have some impact, that actually cardiac wellness and preventing heart disease is just as important if not more important than catheterization in terms of health outcomes," he said. 

A​ccording to Edgcumbe, the report helps define what basic services, such as cardiac rehabilitation and cardiac critical care units, need to be in place before catheterization labs can be set up.

The AHS report shows patient demand is high enough to support setting up a cardiac catherization lab at Red Deer Regional Hospital, pictured here, as well as in Lethbridge. (Red Deer Regional Health Foundation)

Early estimates, included in the report, reveal setting up cardiac catheterization in each city would initially cost $19-21.5 million, with annual operating costs pegged at $7-8.5 million, although Edgecumbe cautions those are very preliminary numbers.

Dr. Jim is now looking for a firm commitment on timelines.

"To be honest, that's what we as a group lack clarity on. We really don't know, to be quite honest, what the process is going forth," he said.

AHS is working on an overarching health service plan for central Alberta that it says will include setting up a catheterization lab in Red Deer. According to Edgcumbe, that plan will be submitted to the province early in 2019. 

About the Author

Jennifer Lee

Reporter

Jennifer Lee is a CBC News reporter based in Calgary. She worked at CBC Toronto, Saskatoon, and Regina, before landing in Calgary in 2002. If you have a health or human interest story to share, let her know. Jennifer.Lee@cbc.ca