Calgary

Petrochemical growth spurt expected despite rising desire for fewer plastics

Canada's slow-growing petrochemical industry is headed for its biggest surge of expansion spending in five years in 2019, thanks in large part to incentive programs by federal and provincial governments.

Government support has angered environmental groups

Inter Pipeline's Heartland Petrochemical Complex is shown under construction in Fort Saskatchewan, Alta., in January. Canada's slow-growing petrochemical industry is headed for its biggest surge of expansion spending in five years in 2019. (Jason Franson/The Canadian Press)

Canada's slow-growing petrochemical industry is headed for its biggest surge of expansion spending in five years in 2019, thanks in large part to incentive programs by federal and provincial governments.

The government support has angered environmental groups who point out that almost 90 per cent of plastics used in this country wind up as litter or in landfills.

But it's welcomed by the industry as a necessary factor if Canada is to keep up with its competitors in the United States.

Capital spending on industrial chemical industry projects in Canada this year is expected to jump by 65 per cent to $1.9 billion, the highest since $2.2 billion in 2014 and third-highest in a decade, according to a year-end members survey by the Chemistry Industry Association of Canada, which represents producers of 75 per cent of the country's chemical products by value.

More than 17,000 jobs

Employment is expected to rise by about four per cent, or by 640 jobs to 17,670.

The growth is coming despite rising concern over single-use plastics. Many jurisdictions are banning plastic straws and grocery bags in reaction to scenes, such as the great Pacific Ocean floating garbage island between Hawaii and California and dead and dying sea creatures.

"Yes, we need plastics. What we want is to stop wasting plastics," said Keith Brooks, programs director for Environmental Defence, who says voluntary initiatives by industry aren't good enough.

His organization is calling for a national strategy with performance standards and tougher enforcement to get Canada to zero plastic waste by 2025.

There are mountains of plastic waste in the industrial areas to the south of Malaysia's capital, Kuala Lumpur — and some of it originated in Canada. (Greenpeace)

Capital spending in Canada this year will come mainly from construction already underway on two projects to turn petrochemicals produced with natural gas into plastic pellets: Inter Pipeline Ltd.'s $3.5-billion polypropylene project in central Alberta and the $2-billion expansion of Nova Chemicals Corp.'s polyethylene plant at Sarnia, Ont.

The former is to receive $200 million in royalty credits under a 2016 Alberta NDP government program — the latter is backed by $100 million through Ontario's Jobs and Prosperity Fund and $35 million from Ottawa's Strategic Investment Fund.

"On a global basis, as all jurisdictions are trying to attract investment, the governments at various levels — federal, state and provincial — play a role," Nova CEO Todd Karran said in an interview.

He said it's always been so — the company's $1-billion polyethylene expansion at its central Alberta complex, opened in 2016, benefited from a multimillion-dollar provincial royalty credit program created by a Progressive Conservative government to spur new sources of ethane to remedy a shortage of feedstock.

$2.1B in royalty credits from Alberta

Last year Alberta announced two programs worth $2.1 billion in royalty credits, grants and loans to encourage investments in petrochemical feedstock and manufacturing facilities. Winning bids are expected to be announced soon.

Meanwhile, a final investment decision is expected soon on a $4-billion polypropylene project by a joint venture of Calgary-based Pembina Pipeline Corp. and a subsidiary of Kuwait Petroleum Corp., eligible for $300 million in royalty credits under the 2016 Alberta program.

"Our made-in-Alberta plan means new projects must do the right thing for the environment, and by upgrading more here at home instead of shipping our raw product south of the border, we reduce emissions and ensure Alberta is among the most responsible and lowest emissions petrochemical producers in the world," provincial Energy Minister Marg McCuaig-Boyd said in a statement.

'Crazy' not to apply for government funding

David Chappell, senior vice-president of petrochemical development for Inter Pipeline, wouldn't say if the company has applied for further government funding, but conceded it would be "crazy" not to consider it.

"Even in a low-carbon future, you're going to see huge demand for petrochemicals and that's good for the future of Alberta and the oil and gas industry," he said.

Canadian petrochemical expansions are dwarfed by the activity south of the border.

A total of 333 new U.S. chemical industry projects using shale gas had been announced as of September, according to the American Chemistry Council. Those projects account for $202 billion US in new capital investment and are expected to create 431,000 direct and indirect jobs by 2025.

In both Canada and the U.S., the main driver of growth is an ample and inexpensive supply of natural gas-based feedstocks like methane, ethane and propane that can be transformed into chemical building blocks such as methanol, ammonia, ethylene and propylene, said Stephen Zinger, senior vice-president, chemicals, at consultancy Wood Mackenzie.

Need to work together

Provincial and federal government supports, and Ottawa's recent decision to allow a 100 per cent accelerated capital cost allowance for new investments, are being noticed by investors, said Bob Masterson, CEO of the Chemistry Industry Association of Canada.

"Where for most of the last decade the global chemistry community has just bypassed Canada ... now we're back on the radar. We've got the resource, we've got the people and now we're starting to see the favourable investment conditions at the provincial and federal level," he said.

Industry says it wants to meet targets for reducing plastic waste but says the public needs to contribute, too. (Andy Clark/Reuters)

The Canadian industry is well aware of its environmental reputation.

The CIAC supports a target of 100 per cent of plastics packaging to be either reusable, recyclable or recovered by 2040 (and 100 per cent to be recyclable or recoverable by 2030), although it acknowledges it can't accomplish that without the co-operation of manufacturers, regulators and the general public.

On Wednesday, Nova Chemicals announced it was one of 30 founding members of the international Alliance to End Plastic Waste, which is making a combined initial commitment of $1 billion US to find ways over the next five years to eliminate plastic waste in the environment.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.