Calgary·Opinion

The argument for MSG: Taste test, scientific research show additive is yummy and safe

The additive, MSG, has gotten some bad press but regulators consider it safe, and food columnist Julie Van Rosendaal makes an argument for including it in your cooking.

Food columnist Julie Van Rosendaal finds incorporating the ingredient adds savoury sensation

Food columnist Julie Van Rosendaal makes an argument for using MSG, commonly sold as Ac'cent Flavour Enhancer in Canada, in at-home cooking. (Julie Van Rosendaal/CBC)

Although most of us recognize the acronym "MSG," not many could explain exactly what it is.

It's savoury flavour enhancer that's so common in Asian cooking, it's sold in shakers to add both in the kitchen and at the dinner table.

But MSG, or monosodium glutamate, has long been misunderstood, having suffered from unsubstantiated controversy in the western world.

The additive, in fact, makes food yummy and it's safe — Health Canada and scientists worldwide agree.

A little taste we did on the Calgary Eyeopener suggests a sprinkle in your cooking adds a savoury sensation.

The additive comes from a naturally occurring amino acid called glutamic acid. One of the most abundant naturally occurring amino acids, it makes up 10 to 25 per cent of all food protein, from both animal and vegetable sources.

Glutamate occurs naturally in the human body and in foods that we associate with umami: meat, tomatoes, mushrooms, soy sauce and Parmesan cheese. It also occurs in large quantities in breast milk.

The isolation of glutamate in 1908 was a culinary breakthrough, when University of Tokyo chemistry professor Kikunae Ikeda first extracted it from dried kombu (kelp).

The professor went on to identify it as umami, the fifth basic taste, joining salty, sweet, sour and bitter. It translates into "pleasant savoury taste."

A shake of MSG gave hoisin pork lettuce wraps a more meaty taste at a CBC taste test, writes food columnist Julie Van Rosendaal. (Julie Van Rosendaal/CBC)

In the western world, MSG still feels the effects of some bad press. In 1968, someone theorized that he was having an adverse reaction to it and wrote a letter to the New England Journal of Medicine, which published it, creating controversy around any food that contained MSG.

Of course, it could be that he was affected, as people can have allergies and intolerance to all types of food.

But the safety of MSG has been thoroughly studied by scientists and regulators worldwide, including the World Health Organization and Health Canada, and the general consensus is that it's not a health hazard.

MSG doesn't make the list of most common food allergens, and the Federation of American Societies of Experimental Biology determined there is no difference in the physiological response to synthesized and natural glutamates.

No hazard, Health Canada says

Health Canada agrees. In a post online, the national regulator notes leading international authorities have found that MSG does not present a health hazard to humans, nor can it be linked to obesity. 

In developing MSG, Ikeda added sodium, one of the elements of table salt, to stabilize the glutamate, allowing it to be easily added to, or sprinkled over, food. It looks like sparkly white sugar crystals but it's savoury.

The most popular brand worldwide is Aji-no-moto (which translates to "essence of taste"), headquartered in Tokyo. The brand Ac'cent, which was introduced in 1947, is more commonly found on Canadian grocery store shelves.

While it's far more common to see a shaker on the table in Japan and other Asian countries, where there has never been cause for concern, we don't give a second thought to its presence in packaged foods, such as Doritos, Pringles, canned soup, ramen noodles and other items designed to deliver a flavour punch.

MSG adds umami, or a pleasant savoury taste, to food. Umami is the fifth basic taste. (Julie Van Rosendaal/CBC)

Health Canada does advise some highly sensitive people can experience allergic-type reactions, such as temporary headache, nausea and chest pains. Those people may wish to avoid the ingredient.

MSG is not regulated as a food additive in Canada, and can appear in ingredient lists under different names. Manufacturers aren't required to list ingredients with naturally occurring MSG, either.

It's usually at the end of the list because ingredients are listed in order of quantity.

"Claims pertaining to the absence or non-addition of monosodium glutamate such as 'contains no MSG', 'no MSG added' and 'no added MSG' are considered misleading and deceptive," Health Canada says. 

Other sources of free glutamate may be present, such as hydrolyzed vegetable protein, hydrolyzed plant protein, hydrolyzed soy protein, soya sauce or autolyzed yeast extracts. Common food, such as tomatoes and tomato juice, grapes and grape juice, and mushrooms, all have high level of naturally occurring free glutamate.

Taste-testing MSG

Our in-studio taste test determined that a sprinkle of pure MSG made tomato soup with Parmesan and roasted garlic caesar salad dressing more palatable. It gave hoisin pork lettuce wraps a more "meaty" taste.

A shake made sliced cucumbers more intensely cucumbery, and a few of us noted that the flavour tended to linger longer than usual, a characteristic that would be well-suited to a bag of Doritos.

MSG is often included as an ingredients in dressings, such as for Caesar salad. The Calgary Eyeopener taste-tested one with it and one without it. (Julie Van Rosendaal/CBC)

You can find shakers of pure MSG among the salts, spices and other seasonings when you go grocery shopping. Think of it as a flavour booster that's slightly salty, with a umami edge.

It kind of does to food what the chrome filter on your iPhone camera does to photos: saturating and intensifying them, making the colours a more vibrant, stimulating version of themselves.


This column is an opinion. For more information about our commentary section, please read this editor's blog and our FAQ.

With files from the Calgary Eyeopener.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Julie Van Rosendaal

Calgary Eyeopener's food guide

Julie Van Rosendaal talks about food trends, recipes and cooking tips on the Calgary Eyeopener every Tuesday at 8:20 a.m. MT. The best-selling cookbook author is a contributing food editor for the Globe and Mail, and writes for other publications across Canada.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Account Holder

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?

now