Panthers' Matthew Tkachuk returns to province where he was loved and loathed

Matthew Tkachuk wore the fiery Flames logo on his chest. On the eve of his return to Calgary, he kept the rhetoric cool while answering questions about what playing against his old club means.

Tuesday game will be popular forward's first in Calgary since blockbuster trade

After a two-point effort in Monday's 4-3 overtime loss at Edmonton, former Flames forward Matthew Tkachuk has 29 in 19 games for the Panthers. Jonathan Huberdeau, who was part of the July trade that sent Tkachuk to Florida, has just 10 in 18 contests with Calgary. (Marta Lavandier/The Associated Press)

For six seasons, Matthew Tkachuk wore the fiery Flames logo on his chest. But, on the eve of his return to Calgary, he kept the rhetoric cool.

"Obviously I've thought about it," Tkachuk said after his Florida Panthers skated in Edmonton late Monday morning ahead of a 4-3 overtime loss that night to the Oilers. "But, until we get to tomorrow, I probably won't be able to give you a good answer on it."

The NHL schedule-maker did its best to minimize the drama of a Tkachuk return, with games in Alberta on consecutive nights.

Tkachuk was Public Enemy No. 1 in Edmonton for six seasons and a hero to those in Calgary who made visits to the Saddledome.

There are no off-days to help build the hype, and very few opportunities for media to get the cameras and recorders in front of the American power forward.

"It's just kind of another road trip, right now," Tkachuk said when asked about what he expects in Calgary. "This one [against Edmonton] doesn't particularly feel that special, but [Tuesday] will be special for me, for sure."

Tkachuk, who had a 104-point season for the Flames in 2021-22 and amassed 382 points for Calgary over six campaigns, was dealt in July to Florida for forward Jonathan Huberdeau and defenceman MacKenzie Weegar.

It was the kind of blockbuster trade you rarely see in today's NHL with so many teams up against the salary cap. But it was part of Flames general manager Brad Treliving's plan to rebuild his team on the fly, after star forward Johnny Gaudreau made the decision to sign as a free agent with the Columbus Blue Jackets.

Fast forward to this season, and Tkachuk has 29 points in 19 games for the Panthers, while Huberdeau has just 10 in 18 games for the Flames.

'Incredible hand skills'

While Tkachuk was not going to say anything that could be used as bulletin-board material, his coach, Paul Maurice, had no issue raving about what Tkachuk brings to the Panthers.

"I don't know if surprised is the right word," said Maurice, who coached the Jets before taking the reins this season with the Panthers. "But in Winnipeg, we would have seen a fair amount of him, and I didn't fully understand his hand skills.

Tkachuk watches Oilers goalie Stuart Skinner make a save during a Nov. 12 game in Miami. Panthers head coach Paul Maurice said the team is looking forward to how fans in Calgary will react to the player's return on Tuesday night. (Lynne Sladky/The Associated Press)

"He has an incredible ability to tip pucks from all across his body, at different levels, and so many of the tight-area play. What's unusual for him is that he can do it goal line to the back of the net.

The way he treats people off the ice is incredible. The trainers, bus drivers, support staff, it's really impressive to watch.— Panthers head coach Paul Maurice on forward Matthew Tkachuk

"To see it in practice, to see the number of pucks he knocks down and no one understands how he did that."

Maurice said Tkachuk is a model team player, painting a different picture than the agitator who has earned three suspensions and was the central figure in a famous brawl between the Flames and Oilers in February 2021.

"The way he treats people off the ice is incredible," said Maurice. "The trainers, the bus drivers, all of the support staff, it's really impressive to watch. He's a very, very respectful young man who has had a whole bunch of success."

Maurice said the team is looking forward to how fans in Alberta, those who loathed and loved Tkachuk, will react.

"I think our guys might enjoy that a little bit," he said. "They'll have a bit of fun with it, and it won't be the first time Matthew's been booed in Alberta, so he'll be fine with it."

Asked if the boos will resonate when Oilers fans see Tkachuk in a Panthers jersey, he replied: "I've got no idea."

"It's not my decision," he said. "It's what everybody else here thinks, you might have to ask them."


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?