Tom Moffatt 'karmic' Fort McMurray tweet shows employment law favours company reputation over free speech
U Calgary legal expert Emily Laidlaw says law needs to change
We've all heard it — be careful what you post on social media.
Just ask Tom Moffatt, the bureaucrat and former NDP candidate in Taber who was suspended from work after calling the Fort McMurray disaster "karmic."
A similar tweet, which has since been deleted, prompted a Vancouver company to suspend its employee Blake Siefken without pay.
"The money that would have gone to his salary will instead be donated to the Red Cross relief efforts in Fort McMurray," wrote The Electric Playground in a Facebook post.
According to a University of Calgary law professor who specializes in internet shaming, this is how these situations usually play out.
Emily Laidlaw said employers have the legal right to suspend, even fire, employees who blunder on social media — but thinks the law needs to be revisited.
"I feel uncomfortable defending these individuals in this case because what they said was just so terrible, but the problem is that people say stupid things all the time and people vent about work all the time," Laidlaw told the Calgary Eyeopener on Friday.
"That's part of how we interact and social media is now how people interact."
She said "it's concerning" that companies can now reach into "every aspect of your life" and that the law needs to offer more protection to individuals' freedom of speech.
Law favours employers
Employment law was written before Twitter and Facebook, said Laidlaw, which means it's not designed with social media in mind.
"In a lot of the cases that have gone to tribunal, individuals have said, 'I didn't think this had anything to do with work. This is how I interact and talk with my friends' ... But the fact is it's permanent, it's out there, so its impact is greater."
- Canada's first Twitter trial highlights need to curb online harassment
- MORE CALGARY NEWS | Low-cost fertility clinic in Calgary could be Canadian first
Aside from a handful of cases where controversial posts appeared in small, closed Facebook groups, Laidlaw said tribunals overwhelmingly rule in favour of employers — especially when businesses have their own social media policies.
"And if they're really well crafted… Any sort of social media used that reflects poorly on the company can lead to [the employee's] termination."
With files from the Calgary Eyeopener