Calgary

Does weed make you a better driver? No, probably not, University of Calgary researcher says

The answer is complicated and more research is needed, according to Sarah Simmons, but currently she says the best evidence seems to say, no, probably not.

Crash risk doubles among drivers who consumed cannabis, but it's 'not necessarily a causal relationship'

Research continues on the effects of consuming cannabis and driving. (The Associated Press, CBC)

If you smoke a joint or eat a cannabis-infused cookie, are you a better driver because you drive more slowly and carefully?

The answer is complicated and more research is needed, according to a University of Calgary doctoral student who has put this question in her crosshairs, but currently she says the best evidence seems to say, no, probably not.

"The idea is people who are high are aware that they are high and attempt to compensate for it by slowing down and increasing their following distance," researcher Sarah Simmons told the Calgary Eyeopener on Wednesday.

"But those are only two components of driving. There is still the detection and response to on-road hazards, the ability to keep the vehicle in the lane laterally, longitudinally, just the control of the vehicle in general."

Simmons is doing her PhD in psychology on this exact issue.

But where is the question coming from?

'Controversy in the science'

CBC News reported Tuesday there had been only one marijuana-impaired driving charge laid in Calgary since recreational use of the drug was legalized last October.

Defence lawyer Tim Foster chatted with the Calgary Eyeopener that morning and said cannabis and alcohol aren't the same when it comes to impaired driving.

"It definitely is different than alcohol," Foster said. "There is a lot of controversy in the science about whether cannabis actually makes you a better driver or worse driver, depending on the amounts."

Meanwhile, if you ask Google, "Does weed make you a better driver?" you'll find lots of people suggesting that, yes, it does.

But Simmons says the best research out there right now doesn't fully agree.

"What we know for certain from several meta-analyses, the best-quality evidence you can get, is that the crash risk associated with having cannabis in your system increases up to about double. If you have it in your system, you are up to twice as likely to crash versus if you don't have it in your system," she said.

"That is not necessarily a causal relationship, it is an association," she cautioned. "We are still trying to parse apart the relative contributions, the underlying characteristics of people who smoke cannabis and then drive and then crash, versus the acute state of being high."

But, she added, the field still hasn't reached consensus on some basic things, such as how to determine cannabis impairment.

"What do we call impairment?" she said. "We have to agree on that first, which is actually quite challenging. There are lots of different ways that we measure impairment in the traffic safety field."

She also says that, academically speaking, legalization has its advantages.

"Now that cannabis has been legalized, this opens up the door for more research in Canada, particularly."

Does weed make you a better driver 6:56

With files from Meghan Grant and the Calgary Eyeopener

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.