Calgary

Critics and industry clash over accuracy of Alberta well cleanup cost estimates

An Alberta coalition that says oil and gas producers are lowballing how much it will cost to clean up their well sites is being accused by the head of the Alberta Orphan Well Association of overstating those numbers.

One energy company alone faces $11.9B in costs to clean up well sites: Alberta Liabilities Disclosure Project

This oil well is being reclaimed by the Orphan Well Association, which is funded by industry to reclaim wells that have been abandoned by companies that simply don't have the cash or assets to pay for reclamation. (Orphan Well Association)

An Alberta coalition that says oil and gas producers are lowballing how much it will cost to clean up their well sites is being accused by the head of the Alberta Orphan Well Association of overstating those numbers.

The Alberta Liabilities Disclosure Project — a coalition of landowners, scientists, environmentalists and others — on Thursday published a list of producer companies with estimates of how much it would cost each to remediate Alberta oil and gas properties if the job had to be done immediately.

Those costs are much higher than the companies' estimates because they are assuming they will have decades of cleanup time, the coalition said, while calling on the province to release independently verified estimates of liabilities.

"When companies report their liabilities at discounted rates, without also reporting what it would cost to do the cleanup today, it makes them look — on paper — healthier than they are," said Regan Boychuk, the ALDP's lead researcher.

"But their numbers assume the companies have decades they may not actually have."

Estimates seem higher than actual cleanup costs: OAW

But the OWA — an organization funded by industry that steps in to clean up wells when their owners either can't or won't — says the cost estimates from the coalition seem much higher than actual costs his organization incurred to clean up 800 inactive oil and gas wells last year.

"With all the work we did last year, the average cost on the abandonment side, or decommissioning, as we call it, was $34,000 per well and $27,000 to reclaim a site," said Lars DePauw, executive director of the OWA.

"I don't know how they came up with their numbers."

Alberta has about 100,000 abandoned and inactive wells throughout the province. (CBC)

Boychuk said his group's assumed average cleanup cost per well is $229,000, a number based on an internal Alberta Energy Regulator study obtained through freedom of information laws.

The numbers given by DePauw may be accurate but they are for cleaning up "cheap, easy, quick wells," such as shallow gas wells with no associated hazardous gases, Boychuk said.

DePauw, in response, said OWA's job list last year included a mixture of both simple and complex wells, pointing out that the OWA did as many cleanups in one year as it has in the past 20 years.

Cleanup costs were far below targets set by the Alberta Energy Regulator, he said, thanks to growing expertise and the use of area-based programs that allow for greater efficiency.

CNR alone could face $11.9B cleanup, coalition estimates

Calgary-based Canadian Natural Resources Ltd. was singled out by the coalition as facing by far the largest bill at $11.9 billion to clean up 73,000 oil, gas and bitumen wells in Alberta.

In its news release, the coalition adds that is "more than double the $5.3 billion in worldwide asset retirement obligations reported in CNRL's audited financial statements."

However, in its Annual Information Form submitted to Canadian regulators in March, CNRL reports its undiscounted worldwide ARO is $12.3 billion.

When asked about that, Boychuk said the coalition worked with a U.S. specialist who consulted American regulatory filings, which didn't include the undiscounted amount. He said many companies reduce their apparent liability by spreading it out over decades.

He said CNRL should be "applauded" for reporting the undiscounted estimate as many companies do not, but noted the number for all of the company's assets in Africa, the North Sea and oilsands mining almost matches his group's estimate for its Alberta wells alone.

Top 10 companies by well cleanup costs

The following companies would have to pay the most to clean up their wells, according to the coalition's elist:

  1. Canadian Natural Resources Ltd.: $11.9 billion
  2. Husky Energy Inc. $2.17 billion
  3. IPC Alberta Ltd.: $2 billion.
  4. Imperial Oil Ltd.: $1.7 billion.
  5. Torxen Energy Ltd.: $1.7 billion.
  6. Obsidian Energy Ltd." $1.5 billion.
  7. Cenovus Energy Ltd.: $1.4 billion.
  8. Canlin Energy Corp.: $1.4 billion.
  9. Paramount Resources Ltd.: $1.2 billion.
  10. Taqa North Ltd.: $994 million.

Energy company says its estimates followed industry practices

Husky spokesman Mel Duvall says the company used accepted industry practices to estimate its worldwide abandonment liabilities as of the end of 2018 at $2.4 billion, with the majority of those costs related to properties in Alberta and Saskatchewan.

"We take our asset retirement obligations seriously and abandon and reclaim in excess of 1,000 wells a year," he said.

In April, the coalition estimated the total cost to clean up all of Alberta's oil and gas wells was $40 billion to $70 billion.

In an email, the AER said its official energy cleanup estimate of $58.65 billion is split into $28.35 billion for coal and oilsands mines and $30.2 billion for oil and gas wells, facilities and pipelines.

It says the total security held for mining as of June 2018 is approximately $1.46 billion and the total for oil and gas is about $224 million.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.