Alberta luxury homes get less than half asking price at auction

The sale of two mansions in Priddis, Alta., for more than $1 million under asking price means there are deals to be found in Calgary's high-end real estate market, says real estate blogger Garth Turner.

2 southern Alberta mansions sold for more than $1M under asking price

This five-bedroom, five-bathroom luxury home in Priddis, Alta., was listed at nearly $4 million but sold for just over $1.7 million. (Concierge Auctions)

An Alberta home with Swarovski crystal-laced faucets and mother of pearl tiles in the master bathroom has sold for nearly half its asking price.

The 9,200-square-foot house located in Priddis, 40 minutes southwest of Calgary, was listed for $3.9 million but purchased at auction for just over $1.7 million.

Another luxury property down the street had a similar fate — the $2.9-million mansion was picked up at a 62 per cent discount.

"The buyer paid $1.1 million — the price of a dumpy 1970s Vancouver special," wrote investment adviser and former MP Garth Turner in a recent blog.

The Realtor representing the two Priddis homes says they were new builds, appraised just under their list price.

"The market tells us what the market tells us. That's what the market dictated at that time," said Mark Evernden, president of sales with Engel & Völkers in Calgary. 

Mark Evernden, who represented the two luxury homes outside Calgary says the high-end real estate market is 'on the slower side, no question.' (Kate Adach/CBC)

The price that the buyer paid was "a great savings," he said.

While there is "no question" the market has slowed down, Evernden said, there are often personal things going on behind the scenes that motivate people to move their properties quickly.

Deep discounts to come

Turner, who lives in Toronto but has clients in Calgary, said the Hawk's Nest Hollow properties are a sign of "deep discounts to come."

"Around Calgary in the nice suburbs ... where you've got houses in the $1-million to $2-million range, you go in with a sharp pencil and a cheque book — and you're going to walk out happy," Turner told the Calgary Eyeopener.

This property at Hawk's Nest Hollow in Priddis was listed for $2.9 million and sold at auction for just over $1.1 million. (Concierge Auctions)

He said the luxury-real estate market in Calgary and surrounding areas has been "taking it in the gut" for the last few months, but thinks it's worse than anyone is letting on.

On Monday, the Calgary Real Estate Board reported that the average price of a Calgary home dropped six per cent last month from October 2014.

CREB's statistics don't include sales outside the MLS system, like the two Priddis homes purchased at auction.

"Builders selling new homes to prospective buyers at deep discounts or private sales — none of these are included in the official numbers. And so when you factor those in, I really believe that the six per cent number is a pale shadow of what's actually happening in the market."

  • Listen to Garth Turner on the Calgary Eyeopener

Why are some high-end homes in the Calgary area selling for far below their asking price? Real estate blogger and investment advisor Garth Turner talks about the luxury home market in the Calgary area. 7:06

Turner said if Alberta's energy industry continues to suffer, more people will be forced to make tough choices.

"If you're sitting on a great big pile of bricks and dreams in Priddis, and you can get at least part of your money out instead of maybe taking a bigger loss down the road, you'd be wise to do it."


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?