Human rights commission wants Supreme Court to hear dispute over Muslim prayer at Calgary school
Alberta's top court overturned $26K fine against Webber Academy for discriminating against religious students
The Alberta Human Rights Commission is hoping the Supreme Court will hear its appeal in the case of two Calgary Muslim students who were not allowed to pray at a non-denominational private school.
Sarmad Amir and Naman Siddiqui, who were in Grade 9 and 10 at Webber Academy in 2011, told the human rights commission that praying is mandatory in their Sunni religion.
They said the school told them their praying, which requires bowing and kneeling, was too obvious and went against the academy's non-denominational nature.
The human rights tribunal ruled the school's policy was too rigid and it could have accommodated the students without violating its secular status.
That decision was upheld by the Alberta Court of Queen's Bench. The school then took the matter to the Alberta Court of Appeal.
It overturned the commission's original decision ordering the school to pay a $26,000 fine for discriminatory behaviour and said another hearing was required because Webber Academy raised new issues under the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
Webber Academy president Neil Webber said Monday the human rights commission is seeking leave to appeal the decision.
"We should know I think by Christmas whether or not they have been successful. It took them quite a while to make the decision," said Webber.
Webber confident leave will be denied
"We doubt that they will be successful. My information from our lawyer and also from a former member of the Supreme Court is that roughly 90 per cent of applications for leave ... are turned down."
No one at the Alberta Human Rights Commission immediately responded to a request for comment.
Webber said he hopes to preserve the secular nature of the school, which has about 1,000 students. He said the school has always made it clear to incoming students and their parents there is no space in the school for praying. It has received only two requests for prayer space in its 22 years of operations and both were denied.
He said even if the Supreme Court refuses to hear an appeal, the matter is far from over.
"Then the human rights commission has a choice — they can have another hearing or they could just drop the whole thing. I don't know what the probability of dropping the whole thing could be."
- MORE CALGARY NEWS | Former Homeless Foundation board member accused of sexually assaulting teen faces 4th set of charges
- MORE CALGARY NEWS | Calgary remand looks to beef up security with body scanner
- Read more articles by CBC Calgary, like us on Facebook for updates and subscribe to our CBC Calgary newsletter for the day's news at a glance