British Columbia

Why B.C. won't consider a high school rugby ban anytime soon

As of this year, all high school coaches have been mandated to take a World Rugby-accredited concussion management course, according to B.C. School Sports.

Coaches mandated to take World Rugby-accredited concussion management course

A plan to ban rugby from high schools in Nova Scotia has drawn criticism from members of B.C.'s rugby community. (Shutterstock)

David Speirs know how much effort it takes to win the big game.

He represented Team Canada in the Rugby World Cup in 1991. Last year, he coached the Collingwood School senior boy's rugby team from West Vancouver to a provincial championship.

So when he heard the Nova Scotia School Athletic Federation had planned to cancel public school rugby amid safety concerns, one of the first things he thought about was his own team.

"It was a complete shock that they could suddenly out of the blue just cancel an entire sport — it seemed a pretty big overreaction," he told CBC News. "It would be absolutely heartbreaking to the boys that I coach, because they put in so much work."

The attempt to ban rugby in Nova Scotia was ordered to be reversed by the province's education minister, but safety concerns — particularly for head trauma — still loom.

But B.C. has no plans to move toward a ban of any sort. Instead, plans are in motion to expand public school program offerings, while also strengthening concussion management and education.

Collingwood School has one of B.C.'s elite high school rugby teams. Coaches say it takes concussion management and prevention seriously. (Collingwood School/Facebook)

Expanded programs

According to B.C. School Sports (BCSS) —  the governing body for high school sports across the province  — there are 4,535 high school students that play rugby across more than 100 schools in B.C.

Executive director Jordan Abney says rugby 15s has been a part of the public school system in B.C. for the bulk of BCSS's history.

Last month, the board voted in favour of adding rugby sevens to the school sports program on a trial basis beginning next season

"We feel comfortable in doing so because of the pieces we've put in place to address some of the concerns and risks that inherently come with a sport like rugby," Abney told CBC News.

Rugby teams in Nova Scotia were abruptly informed their season was coming to an end when the province's athletic federation moved to ban the sport at the high school level. The education minister reversed the decision. (Jenna Smaggus photo)

Improved training

Among the precautions Abney says are now in place is a mandatory concussion management course for each high school coach. The program is the standard used by World Rugby — the sport's world governing body.

"This really sort of standardizes the expectation. It's pretty clear that if there's any thought a student athlete has sustained a brain injury of any type, then they are to be removed from the field of play permanently until they are cleared by a medical professional to return," said Abney, emphasizing that coaches are urged to err on the side caution.

Abney says concerns have been raised by parents in the past in regards to injury, but there hasn't been a substantial amount of complaints.

Unlike smaller provinces, including Nova Scotia, B.C. does not track the number of injuries that occur on the field.

BCSS has formed a sport medicine and athlete safety committee tasked with ensuring standards are consistent with the latest research surrounding concussions.

Coach David Speirs says officiating is also evolving to curb injuries.

"No one that I know in the rugby community is going to risk someone's future over a high school rugby game," said Speirs.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.