Vancouver police call for centralized body to co-ordinate services on the Downtown Eastside
Methodology of VPD commissioned report has been called into question
The message from Vancouver Police Chief Adam Palmer that Vancouver's Downtown Eastside (DTES) requires a centralized body to oversee, prioritize and coordinate services likely has merit.
However, attaching the conclusion to a report commissioned by his own police force that uses questionable inputs to seemingly overstate costs has many questioning the VPD's motivation.
Entitled Igniting Transformational Systems Change Through Policing, the report by Alberta-based HelpSeeker Technologies estimates that Vancouver's "social safety net" costs $5 billion per year, the equivalent of $7,200 per year for each resident of the city.
Included in the financial arithmetic are budgets for things that do not meet the traditional definition of a social safety net, like firefighting and policing, among others.
Nevertheless, Palmer says the report provides a jumping-off point to make the argument that those in Vancouver's most challenged neighbourhood are worse off than ever and not well served by the many "siloed" entities operating in the DTES.
"I don't want to lose sight of the big picture here with the lack of coordination and the piecemeal approach we've taken to social services in this city," he said. "You've got half a dozen government ministries, a bunch of different departments up at the city, all these non-profits, everybody running around doing different things... and it's clearly not working."
"Somebody, probably from government, probably at the provincial level, needs to coordinate all these silos," said Palmer.
'Marketing and communication exercise'
DTES resident Karen Ward says the disputed $5 billion figure is meant to provoke public shock and outrage, while supporting the VPD's argument for funding as it approaches its annual budget request deadline of Nov. 30.
"It's specifically designed to give people these huge numbers to make us forget about other huge numbers and to say that doesn't seem so bad. It's not factual at all. It's marketing and a communications exercise."
City of Vancouver Coun. Christine Boyle also pointed to the questionable conclusions in the report.
"The numbers are incredibly misleading and that's the wrong way to start a really important conversation. I think there are valid concerns about the way the report seems to seek to villainize those serving on the front lines."
The VPD paid HelpSeeker $149,000 for the report. Company co-founder Alina Turner did acknowledge a number of limitations, caveats and gaps when it comes to the data used for its so-called "social service audit."
"This report doesn't make the argument that there's a need for more or less police," said Turner. "It talks about the overall system," she said.
Palmer said police are uniquely positioned to understand what's going on in the DTES because of how frequently they are called there.
A second report from the VPD entitled Vancouver's Social Safety Net: Rebuilding the Broken was released in draft form because it had already leaked to the media, according to Palmer.
He said police are still seeking input from stakeholder groups and are recommending the establishment of a steering committee made up of community partners and various levels of government.
The City of Vancouver confirmed on Tuesday that neither city council nor city administration requested the report be commissioned or directed the VPD to commission it.
"Given the City was not offered an opportunity to provide inputs toward the report's drafting or to review its findings, it would not be appropriate to comment on the report at this time until City staff have had an opportunity to review and validate its findings," said a spokesperson with the city.
with files from Joel Ballard
To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.
By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.
Become a CBC Account Holder
Join the conversation Create account
Already have an account?