British Columbia

Pipeline protesters predict number of arrests over Trans Mountain will eclipse War in the Woods

Protest organizers against the Trans Mountain Pipeline expansion project say they believe the number of people arrested for civil disobedience will rise or even surpass the number arrested fighting to stop logging in Clayoquot Sound on the west coast of Vancouver Island more than two decades ago.

'There's enough people that are strongly committed to this movement,' says professor

Cedar George-Parker addresses the crowd as protesters against the Kinder Morgan Trans Mountain pipeline extension defy a court order and block an entrance to the company's property in Burnaby on April 7. (Darryl Dyck/Canadian Press)

Protest organizers against the Trans Mountain Pipeline expansion project say they believe the number of people arrested for civil disobedience will rise or even surpass the number arrested fighting to stop logging in Clayoquot Sound on the west coast of Vancouver Island more than two decades ago.

Those logging demonstrations, known as the War in the Woods, marked the largest civil disobedience protest in Canadian history.

The promise of more arrests from Trans Mountain protesters comes despite the threat of spending seven to 14 days in jail for blocking work at Kinder Morgan's Burnaby Terminal and the Westridge Marine Terminal.

'The idea that you're standing on a road and doing civil disobedience and doing a political protest ... and then you're being put in jail for seven days is completely absurd and and overblown,' says activist Tzeporah Berman. (CBC)

Tzeporah Berman, a director for, is helping organize blockades on Burnaby Mountain with the Indigenous-led group Coast Protectors.

Berman says there are moments in history when governments fail the public interest due to influence from industry and it's at those moments when people must stand up.

"And I feel that this is one of those moments," she said about the Trans Mountain expansion project.

The project was purchased by the federal goverment in May to ensure it gets built, so the focus of the protest is now directed at Ottawa.

One of the signs at the protest targeted Prime Minister Trudeau for his recent decision to purchase the Trans Mountain Pipeline Expansion Project from Kinder Morgan. (Mike Laanela/CBC)

There are striking differences between the two protests. The Clayoquot protests were directed against the province and took aim at one of B.C.'s prized resource industries: logging.

The Trans Mountain protests were first directed at an American company and opponents say the project poses many threats, namely it infringes on Indigenous rights, increases the risk of oil spills and contributes to climate change.

Academics who study civil disobedience say that despite the differences between Clayoquot and Trans Mountain, there is potential for more people to get arrested over the pipeline expansion.

'Moral duty'

"There's enough people that are strongly committed to this movement," said David Tindall a professor of sociology at the University of British Columbia, who has has studied civil disobedience for the past 30 years.

"Some people think that they don't have any choice if they want to be moral beings, that this is their moral duty to engage in these types of activities," Tindall said.

A anti-pipeline protester at a Kinder Morgan terminal in Burnaby speaks with a RCMP officer on Saturday, March 24, 2018. (CBC)

In 1993, Berman was charged with 857 criminal counts of aiding and abetting in the organization of blockades around Tofino and Ucluelet during the Clayoquot protests.

That protest focused international attention on the ancient forests of Clayoquot Sound on the west coast of Vancouver Island. At its peak in 1993, around 800 people were arrested for civil disobedience.

The number of people arrested protesting the Trans Mountain pipeline expansion is smaller.

From mid-March of 2018 to the beginning of July, 211 people were arrested for breaking a court-ordered injunction at Kinder Morgan's work sites.

But after a flurry of arrests in April — around 170 in one week — there have only been a handful here and there on weekends.

The trickle could be due to increased penalties, which could include a $5,000 fine and seven to 14 days in jail.

Those first arrested for civil or criminal contempt were either fined $500 or ordered to do community service if they were unable to pay.

In Clayoquot, initial sentences were $500 fines, which escalated to $1,000. The Court of Appeal ultimately imposed house arrest on some for up to 45 days but lifted the fines because the trial court had failed to inquire about people's ability to pay.

For her Clayoquot protests, Berman spent a few weeks in jail. But she fought charges and emerged with no criminal record.

More than two decades later, she says 20,000 people have pledged to stop the pipeline and have vowed, on the Coast Protectors web site, to stand with Indigenous leaders.

Long game

Protesters say having accessible camps such as Trans Mountain's Camp Cloud help draw numbers to the cause because people from diverse backgrounds have a gathering place to be arrested. (Maryse Zeidler/CBC)

As for the arrests themselves, Berman says they help garner media attention and keep the issue in the public eye. They also create doubt for investors and can delay construction.

Because work is planned for years to come at the Burnaby sites, Berman and others believe the arrests too will continue.

"There is no one moment that stops a project, rarely is there just one moment," said Berman. "It took us 10 years to stop [Enbridge's Northern Gateway pipelines.] It took us five years to stop [The Energy East pipeline]. We'll stop this one too."


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?