British Columbia·Stories About Here

How the Vancouver Special, once described as bland, holds a key to solving B.C.'s housing crisis

Vancouver's popular residential architecture from the 1960s offers lessons on function over form when it comes to addressing the housing crisis, writes Uytae Lee.

The design exploited a loophole, allowing people to build bigger houses that helped meet their needs

By the 1980s the Vancouver Special was derided as too common in B.C.'s Lower Mainland, and eventually banned. But its design offers suggestions on how to address B.C.'s housing crisis today, writes Uytae Lee. (Stories About Here)

This story is part of Uytae Lee's Stories About Here, an original series with the CBC Creator Network. You can watch every episode of this series on CBC Gem.

In the 1960s, Vancouver was experiencing a boom in immigration. Housing in the city was running out and people needed homes, fast.

To meet that demand, a specific housing design became so popular that thousands of them were built over the following years.

And I think we can learn something from that design as we try to find solutions to the housing crisis in British Columbia — and cities across Canada — today. 

How to hide a first floor

Larry Cudney, a local draftsman, created a design for a house that would eventually be known as the Vancouver Special.

Its key feature is a low-pitched roof, which, compared to steeper roofs, required fewer materials — and was therefore cheaper to build. 

But the Vancouver Special wasn't just cheap: its first floor also exploited a loophole, allowing it to be larger than other homes.

In the 1960s, if you wanted to construct a house, there were limitations to how much square footage the first floor could occupy. 

But basements were not included in that calculation, and Cudney took advantage of this by building his first floor 18 inches below the ground — just enough for it to qualify as a 'basement.' 

At the height of its popularity, the housing design known as the Vancouver Special could be mass-produced in a matter of weeks, writes Uytae Lee. (Stories About Here)

This allowed people to build bigger houses, with the so-called basement becoming a whole new unit of housing and allowing two separate families to live under one roof.

Thus the Vancouver Special was perfect for many aspiring homeowners: immigrants could house extended family on the other floor, and working-class residents could rent out that floor and use the income to pay their mortgage.

As more and more Vancouver Specials were built, it became easier to build them. The materials became standard in the construction industry and city staff began to recognize the design and approve it for construction more quickly.

Around 10,000 Vancouver Specials were constructed between 1965 and 1985.

Today's special?

Today, many cities find themselves with a shortage of housing and zoning requirements that make it difficult to build new places to live.

Rezoning a neighbourhood to allow for multi-family housing, like apartments or townhouses, typically requires multiple applications, reports, consulting firms, council meetings, public hearings, an expertise of planning law, tons of money, and lots of time — and there's no guarantee you'll be successful.

By classifying its first floor as a basement, the creator of the Vancouver Special was able to build a much bigger home than was typical for the time. (Stories About Here)

When building new housing is this difficult, the usual result is that no new housing gets built.

But what if we had a new Vancouver Special — a type of building that is cheap to build, houses more people, and is quickly approved for construction?

There's at least one place where that's already happening: Kelowna.

The Kelowna Special

In 2018, the city of Kelowna held a competition for designs that could fit multiple units of housing on properties within single-family neighbourhoods. The winning designs for a quadplex were given fast-track approval process, from over a year to just two to three weeks.

In the past two years, over 200 of these quadplexes have been built, creating over 800 new units of housing. 

However, the Kelowna quadplex is now meeting the same challenges the Vancouver Special once did.

As the Vancouver Special grew in popularity, so did the backlash. People began to describe its architecture as bland, ugly and far too common.

By 1988, the city officially made it illegal to build them.

Over two years, more than 200 quadplexes were built in Kelowna, B.C., significantly contributing to new housing units in the growing city. (Stories About Here)

Unfortunately, Kelowna has done the same: as of 2021, the quadplex designs were no longer being approved for construction over concern too many were being built.

Function over form

Public opinion seems to be turning around, however, under the housing crunch and as nostalgia grows for Vancouver Specials among people who grew up in them. 

Today, these houses are viewed as a valuable part of the city's history — and culture. You can find it on T-shirts, posters, cross-stitch art, craft beers, and gingerbread.

What if we were less concerned about the look of new housing? The Vancouver Special wasn't about being the most beautiful house. It was about being as useful and affordable for the people who needed them.

Maybe it's time for a new Special. 

Learn more in Stories About Here: A 'Special' Solution to the Housing Crisis

About this series

Stories About Here is an original series with the CBC Creator Network that explores the urban planning challenges that communities across Canada face today. In each episode we dig into the often overlooked issues in our own backyards — whether it's the shortage of public bathrooms, sewage leaking into the water, or the bureaucratic roots of the housing crisis. Through it all, we hope to inspire people to become better informed and engaged members of their communities.

You can watch every episode of this series on CBC Gem.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Uytae Lee produces videos that educate people on the urban planning challenges cities face today. He is the creator of the CBC series “Stories About Here,” where he explores often overlooked issues in our own backyards. In addition to producing videos for CBC, he hosts a YouTube channel called “About Here." You can reach Lee at aboutherevideos@gmail.com.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?

now