Red Chris Mine gets green light from B.C. government

B.C. Minister of Energy and Mines Bill Bennett announced Friday that the Red Chris Mine, owned by Imperial Metals, will soon be in full production, despite environmental concerns.

Mine is owned by same company that operates Mount Polley

The Red Chris Mine site in northwestern B.C. has received a full operating permit from the provincial government. (Daniel Henshaw/B.C. government)

A gold and copper mine in northwestern B.C. that still faces angry opposition from its neighbours in Alaska has received approval for a full operating permit from the provincial government.

B.C. Minister of Energy and Mines Bill Bennett announced Friday that the Red Chris Mine, owned by Imperial Metals, will soon be in full production, despite environmental concerns from First Nations, environmental groups and Alaskans, who are downstream from the mine site.

Those worries were magnified last summer, when a tailings pond collapsed at the Mount Polley mine, another Imperial Metals-owned mine in interior B.C.

Bennett said he's confident the Red Chris Mine, located about 130 kilometres from the Alaska border, won't experience a similar breach because the tailings storage facility has undergone three independent reviews.

He noted the mine has operated successfully for months on a temporary permit while officials monitored the facility.

"I have no doubt ... that (waste) water is going to be managed carefully, and in such a way that people downstream, including our neighbours in Alaska, can have confidence that we're doing everything that any responsible jurisdiction should do," he said.

'We have no voice'

Heather Hardcastle, a commercial fisherman and spokeswoman for Alaska-based group Salmon Beyond Borders said she's still worried the mine could unleash heavy metals and acidic drainage into the waters, impacting Alaska's multi-billion dollar fishing and tourism industries.

A photo shows the excavation of the tailings impoundment area at Imperial Metals's Red Chris gold and copper property in northern B.C. A Tahltan spokesperson said the design of the pond is the same as that of the tailings pond that failed at Imperial's Mount Polley gold and copper mine. (Imperial Metals)

The problem is that the government of Alaska hasn't been involved in assessing or approving mining projects in northwestern B.C., where mine run-off flows into Alaskan waters, she said.

"We have no voice and B.C. has no accountability. And we're taking on all of the risks and receiving none of the benefits," Hardcastle said.

Alaskans aren't anti-mining, she added, but people are concerned about how many projects are currently underway in the pristine region.

"We're talking about a scale and scope of mining activity that's never been seen before in a place that's this valuable when it comes to salmon and clean water," Hardcastle said.

A representative for Alaska does have a seat at the table when it comes to many meetings on B.C. mining, said Bennett.

The minister noted that there is work to be done between Alaska and B.C., and said he would like to see a memorandum of understanding on mining between the two governments.

Government forging ahead

Another group which initially opposed the Red Chris Mine is now part of the project. Members of the Tahltan First Nation set up a blockade at the mine last summer following the Mount Polley tailings pond collapsed, spilling millions of cubic metres of water and mine slurry into local waterways.

The First Nation later instigated an environmental review of the Red Chris Mine, and in April signed on to co-manage it with Imperial Metals.

"From here on our environmental oversight role — an important part of our agreement — will also start to expand," Tahltan Central Council President Chad Day said in a news release.

B.C. Mining Minister Bill Bennet says getting permits should be difficult, but the province needs to be competitive when it comes to attracting mining companies. (Chad Hipolito/Canadian Press)

He added that expanding the mine to full capacity will create jobs and bring other benefits to the First Nation.

Bennett, too, said mining in B.C. helps bolster the province's economy.

Getting permits to build mines should be difficult, he said, but the province needs to be competitive when it comes to attracting mining companies.

"We had Mount Polley, it happened, it was terrible. It happened once in 150 years. We have to make sure it doesn't happen again," he said. 'But I think it would be a serious mistake to think that you can't mine safely in B.C. Because I'm convinced you can."

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.