British Columbia

Why a grocery store's decision to leave downtown could increase inequality in Prince George

The pending closure of Save-On-Food's downtown Prince George location has sparked concerns that some of the city's poorest residents may not have easy access to affordable food.

Save-On-Foods' pending move has raised concerns about a 'food desert' in the city's poorest neighbourhoods

Torie Beram is a nurse who works with vulnerable people in downtown Prince George, B.C. She says many of her clients will be unable to access affordable groceries once Save-On-Foods leaves the neighbourhood. (Andrew Kurjata/CBC)

The pending closure of a major grocery store in downtown Prince George, B.C., has sparked concerns that some of the city's poorest residents may not have easy access to affordable food.

Save-On-Foods, owned by the Jim Pattison Group, has confirmed it is moving its downtown location to Pine Centre Mall, roughly three kilometres away. 

Though the distance may not make much of a difference to people who drive, it could have a major impact on those who walk or take transit to get their food, advocates say.

"This is leaving a lot of people, I fear, with very little options," said Torie Beram, a nurse who works with vulnerable people in the city. "You are giving people no choice but to go hungry, utilize food banks or have to find a way to get to the grocery store."

The issue of food deserts — urban areas without accessible, affordable food  — is a growing concern across Canada. Research out of Winnipeg indicates areas without adequate grocery options tend to have higher rates of people with diabetes, with many surviving on convenience foods and canned goods. 

Beram worries Save-On's departure will create another such food desert in the heart of northern B.C.'s most populous city, particularly among residents of nearby neighbourhoods with higher concentrations of poverty.

Many of her clients don't have vehicles, and even the cost of taking a taxi or having groceries delivered can be prohibitive. As a result, she said, they may be forced to take an hour round trip by foot or bus just to get supplies — a difficult task for single parents or elderly people, particularly during winter months.

Seniors, students impacted

Although Save-On would not provide a reason for the move, its pending absence also deals a blow to the city's downtown revitalization plans, which include the construction of student housing just a few blocks away from the store's current location.

"Very often students come to Prince George, they may not have a vehicle, and having access to good healthy food is important to them," said Coun. Murry Krause, who chairs the city's poverty reduction committee. "It's very disappointing on so many fronts."

Krause said the city's economic development wing will be reaching out to other major grocers in an attempt to entice them to take Save-On's place.

City Councillor Murry Krause chairs Prince George's poverty reduction committee. He worries what the departure of Save-On will mean for the city's downtown revitalization efforts and how it will impact some of the community's most vulnerable people. (Andrew Kurjata/CBC)

Some private citizens are doing the same. Kathleen Hebb said she is personally reaching out to retailers including Safeway and Sobey's in an attempt to get them to open up downtown. She said she is motivated by her own background being raised by a single parent on social assistance.

"To say, 'Just get a taxi, get on a bus, go that extra distance' ... is really putting up more barriers and also taking away a bit of money every week."

Darrin Rigo said he has a similar background — and similar concerns. 

"I had a single mom who didn't have a car ... so we walked to the grocery store as a family, 20 minutes round trip each way," he said. Rigo mapped out what Save-On's move might mean for some of the people who live nearby and was concerned by what he found. 

"It's a 40-minute-plus walk that requires crossing a highway and following a lot of busy arteries," he said. "I think back to my mom who was working two jobs at the time and probably just barely fitting all of this together — if that walk suddenly doubled in length ... I don't think she would have had many options."

The move is also a concern to seniors and young families who live in the nearby Millar Addition and Crescents neighbourhoods. While they might be able to afford a car, many chose to live near downtown so they could access services by foot.

Save-On-Foods says it is closing its location in the downtown Parkwood Place mall and moving to another location in the city. The grocery giant did not provide a reason for the move. (Andrew Kurjata/CBC)

Jeremy Morris, 30, said he just bought his first house in the Crescents in part because he would be able to walk to get groceries, and is disappointed that will soon change.

Barbara Robin, 78, is a retired real estate agent who moved close to downtown so she would be able to "walk everywhere" without having to cross any highways. She said the neighbourhoods close to downtown are popular among older people looking to downsize and have easier access to medical services, but the lack of a grocery store could be a barrier. 

"We want to encourage growth downtown ... so I think it's only right we should have a grocery store in that area."

Brian Quarmby co-owns Birch and Boar, a downtown Prince George grocer specializing in locally-produced foods. (Andrew Kurjata/CBC)

In the meantime, some smaller retailers are adjusting to the pending departure of Save-On. Birch and Boar, a small grocer specializing in locally-produced food, is expanding its hours to better serve people who need to pick up some items after work or on weekends. Co-owner Brian Quarmby said the shop is also talking to local farmers about expanding their produce options.

But, he said, he recognizes a specialty shop can't replace the role of a large grocery store and he would welcome the arrival of another chain in the neighbourhood.

"Especially with the seniors and that [vulnerable] community, they need something downtown."

To hear more about the impact of Save-On leaving downtown Prince George, tap the audio below:

Save-On Foods' decision to leave downtown Prince George for the Pine Centre Mall is causing concerns. Some fear it could cause a 'food desert' in one of the city's poorest neighbourhoods. The CBC's Andrew Kurjata provides an in-depth look at the issue. 15:15

Subscribe to Daybreak North on CBC Listen or your favourite podcast app, and connect with CBC Northern British Columbia on FacebookTwitter and Instagram

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Andrew Kurjata

CBC Prince George | @akurjata

Andrew Kurjata is an award-winning journalist covering Northern British Columbia for CBC Radio and cbc.ca, situated in unceded Lheidli T'enneh territory in Prince George. You can email him at andrew.kurjata@cbc.ca.

now