British Columbia·Metro Matters

Port Coquitlam councillor taking city to court after being censured

After being censured by the rest of her colleagues on Port Coquitlam council, Laura Dupont is taking them to court.

Laura Dupont disclosed confidential information but is being defended by colleagues across the region

Port Coquiltam Coun. Laura Dupont was elected with the most votes of any of her colleagues in the 2018 election. (City of Port Coquitlam)

After being censured by the rest of her colleagues on Port Coquitlam council, Laura Dupont is taking them to court.

Dupont sent a notice though her lawyer to Mayor Brad West on Tuesday, serving notice of pending litigation for her censure and removal from external boards and committees last week. 

In a statement issued then, the other councillors said she was censured during a private meeting after a third-party investigator found she disclosed confidential information on three different occasions — but didn't say what that information was, beyond that it was serious and could have financial consequences. 

In his note to West, Dupont's lawyer, Sebastian Anderson, said Dupont would be seeking damages for defamation and a court order reversing the council's decision, along with a declaration that the information she disclosed was not confidential. 

Dupont, who alleged the decision to censure is related to her advocacy on climate change issues, said last week she apologized to council but felt she was being silenced by a "culture of intimidation."

West declined comment, but, in a statement, the City of Port Coquitlam said Dupont had made no complaints under the city's respectful workplace policy, and that council "would not have taken such actions over a minor error." 

"The action's are directly related to Coun. Dupont's conduct and breaches of confidentiality and not related to any council policy discussions or positions," the statement said. 

Support outside PoCo

It's not often that a councillor is formally censured by their colleagues or stripped of certain responsibilities. And it's not often that Metro Vancouver politicians comment on the affairs in another municipality. 

But both are happening in Dupont's case.

"I thought it was a very heavy-handed move," said Vancouver Coun. Adriane Carr, who chairs the Metro Vancouver Climate Action Committee that Dupont had sat on prior to her censure by Port Coquitlam. 

Carr said Dupont was an "incredibly valuable" member of the committee, and that while she didn't know the reason for the decision, couldn't imagine it required such a large punishment.

"There's an important balance," she said. "Giving people a second chance and not just stripping them of their responsibilities and their roles unilaterally over one thing .... I just can't even imagine."

New Westminster Coun. Mary Trenadue said the punishment doesn't seem to fit the crime.

"Divulging information from a closed meeting, quite honestly this happens often. I probably made the same mistake a number of times but never purposely," she said. 

"She admitted a mistake, and I completely believe her. So I think this censure isn't required in this situation. It's a way to shut someone down," she said.

Port Coquitlam Mayor Brad West says he can't comment on what information Dupont disclosed, but it was not a public policy issue. (Martin Diotte/CBC)

Codes of conduct

With few formal parties in local politics and no mechanism to recall mayors or councillors, a notice of censure is one of the few ways to resolve disputes when a majority of councillors believe one of their colleagues is in the wrong.   

In recent years, the Union of B.C. Municipalities has helped municipalities develop codes of conduct, which provide more formal and transparent processes to sanction councillors.

"They work best when there's buy-in at a local level and being in place before there's a problem," said UBCM president Maja Tait.

"I go back to when we played board games: let's all read the rules at the beginning, so we understand the game … in advance, so that we're not getting into the heat of it when there's a problem."

Dupont said she would support Port Coquitlam having a code of conduct going forward. However, Tait cautioned that it's not a magic bullet when it comes to resolving inter-council conflicts.

"While the vast majority [of councils] find a way … to express positions and come to a unified decision, that isn't always the case," she said. 

"And when it's not the case, the impact can be very significant and take its toll on any local government." 

Add some “good” to your morning and evening.

A variety of newsletters you'll love, delivered straight to you.

Sign up now

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?

now