After accidentally paying $10k on $100 bill, shop owner chases Yellow Pages to pay her back

Pat Ridler claims a reimbursement cheque that should've arrived in February is nowhere to be found, leaving her out thousands as she tries to keep her small business afloat and plan for the upcoming tax season.

Yellow Pages sent reimbursement cheque after being contacted by CBC

Patricia Ridler, pictured inside Pages Book Emporium, after being honoured with the Influential Women in Business Award by Kootenay Magazine in 2016. (Pages Book Emporium/Facebook)

UPDATE — March 15, 2019, 12:50 p.m. PT: Christy Haarstad, co-owner of Pages Book Emporium, says the bookstore received and deposited a reimbursement cheque from Yellow Pages on Friday.

EARLIER STORY:

Pat Ridler says a tiny, misplaced black dot on her computer has cost her more than $10,000.

She logged on to pay her monthly Yellow Pages bill online in November, owing $104.50 for regular advertisements promoting her bookstore in Cranbrook, B.C.

Somehow, Ridler punched in $10,450 instead — a misplaced comma — and hit send on the payment.

She said Yellow Pages has been aware of the mistake for months and promised to pay her back weeks ago. She claims a reimbursement cheque that should've arrived in mid-February is nowhere to be found, leaving her out thousands as she tries to keep her small business afloat and plan for the upcoming tax season.

"I had been looking to get things cleared up by the year end," Ridler told CBC News over the phone, her voice tight.

"I was thinking, 'It's gonna make a mess in my accounting.' Now we're past that — and we're still $10,000 behind."

An invoice from Yellow Pages to Pages Book Emporium showing a credit for $10,405 after a previous balance of $104.05 on Dec. 24, 2018. A subsequent bill sent to CBC News shows the $10,405 credit disappeared and replaced with an amount due of $334.55. (Pages Book Emporium)

After being first contacted by CBC News last week, a spokesperson for Yellow Pages said in a phone call Monday that an "administrative error" led to Ridler's case falling through the cracks for the past few months. 

Accidental overpayment

Ridler has co-owned Pages Book Emporium in Cranbrook for years. It's a much-loved bookstore that's longer than it is wide, with secondhand volumes stacked and crammed into any available space along slim, carpeted aisles. There's a space for magazines and a corner for hoards of puzzles.

Ridler was preparing for the rush of the Christmas season when the payment mistake happened. She said she realized what was going on when her bank phoned her to say her cheques were bouncing.

"I had a panic. I went to the bank immediately," said Ridler.

Inside Pages Book Emporium on Baker Street in Cranbrook, B.C. (Alana Krushen/Cranbrook Tourism via Pages Book Emporium)

She said she instantly dipped into reserve funds to cover suppliers' checks and employee wages.

"From there, we just kept depositing every night and tried to keep ahead of things," Ridler said.

She called Yellow Pages the same day she went to the bank. She said a phone operator gave her a case number and told her her file had been marked as a priority.

In January, when she phoned the company again to follow up after nothing changed, she said another representative told her a repayment cheque had been mailed and would arrive by Feb. 16.

Ridler said she hasn't seen that money, nearly a month past that date. She said she's also been receiving calls about a balance owing on the same account, and invoices show the $10,000 credit appearing and then disappearing again.

Pages Book Emporium on Baker Street in Cranbrook, B.C., just off Highway 95. (Pages Book Emporium)

On Monday, Yellow Pages spokesperson Treena Cooper said the problem is being "rectified" and a cheque "will be sent by priority post" to make up the difference.

"We're doing a bit of an internal investigation to understand why this could've happened, especially considering the delay in time," Cooper said over the phone, declining to comment on further specifics about Ridler's file.

"Our deepest apologies [to Ridler] for this."

Ridler said she simply wants her money back, knowing the incident could've put her business under.

"If it hadn't been Christmas time, or close to Christmas when the sales increase — and we had a relatively good summer — yes, it would have paralyzed us. The cash flow would have just been done."

About the Author

Rhianna Schmunk

@rhiannaschmunk

Rhianna Schmunk is a reporter for CBC News based in Vancouver. Reach her at rhianna.schmunk@cbc.ca or on Twitter. @rhiannaschmunk

With files from Rafferty Baker and Bob Keating

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.