British Columbia

Nestlé should not be charged more for B.C. water, urges former MLA Judi Tyabji

Some people are demanding the provincial government charge Nestlé more for bottling B.C.'s water. But a long time campaigner against bulk water exports and free trade agreements says a high price would be even riskier than giving it away for free.

Petition signed by thousands is urging the government to charge Nestlé more to access B.C water

An online petition urging the B.C. government to charge Nestlé more for access B.C. water has received over 200,000 signatures. (Getty Images/Science Photo Library RF)

Public dissent against Nestlé continues to grow over the multinational companies usage and bottling of B.C. groundwater.

An online petition asking the B.C. government to charge Nestlé "a fair price for our most precious resource" reached 218,884 signatures on Monday morning, just 1,116 names short of its goal.

But former Liberal MLA Judy Tyabji says members of public who have signed the petition have a misunderstanding of what is at stake.

"The minute the B.C. government...starts charging for water from aquifers for the use based on volume without providing infrastructure we can't turn it off," she told the Early Edition's Rick Cluff.

Former Liberal MLA Judi Tyabji has written a new biography about Premier Christy Clark. (Judi Tyabji/Facebook)

Tyabji, the president of the Pebble In the Pond Environmental Society — a community group dedicated to the reduction of plastic garbage waste — says her primary concern is that the public outcry to charge Nestlé a higher price for the use of B.C. water will lead to a restructuring of the current water regulations.

In a Facebook post sent on July 11, Tyabji called into question the demands made by the petition.

"Do NOT demand that the province charge Nestlé money, unless you want to open the door to massive water sales in BC," she wrote.

Her post, which has received over 4,000 likes and over 15,000 shares urges the public to question what the stipulation for such a request would have. "[Y]ou are lobbying our government to turn our water into a commodity for sale."

BC government content with regulations

Currently, companies such as Nestlé are able to access water from B.C. for free. Regulations set to be in place starting in 2016 will see Nestlé charged $2.25 to bottle a million litres of water.

B.C.'s Environment Minister Mary Polak says that charge is simply an access fee and not a cost of sale for the resource.

"We will never sell that right of ownership. We will allow access but it is tightly controlled."

Tyabji says it is that charge that has led to much misunderstanding from the public.

"A lot of people gets confused because they pay for metered water in a municipality. That's because it's costing local government to deliver the water… If we start charging a fair price, there's no questions Nestlé will say 'we're going to court to say they've sold it to us and lock them in.'"

She acknowledges that while it may not be the popular choice for many, the government is ultimately best left to decide how water usage by industries are dealt with in the province.

"We have to trust that this provincial government has protected our interest in water. The provincial administration has protected us under these trade deals for decades [so] they have to decide what's a fair price."

To hear more, click the audio labelled: Judi Tyabji warns against charging Nestlé more for water.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?