British Columbia

Discovery of ancient burial mounds traps landowners in bureaucratic 'bottomless pit of hell'

A dispute over land where ancient gravesites have been found in Chilliwack is an example of a complicated problem in B.C., where heritage conservation laws have repeatedly pitted unwitting landowners against First Nations that are trying to stop their burial sites from being bulldozed.

Private property owners, Ts'elxwéyeqw Tribe unite in call for B.C. to fix holes in heritage law

Beau and Dian Sutton’s dream to build a home on a property near B.C.'s Chilliwack River came to a halt when burial mounds were identified on the land in 2014. (Duncan McCue/CBC)

 When Beau and Dian Sutton bought a wooded half-acre near B.C.'s Chilliwack River in 2014, they intended to build their dream home.

That dream soon turned into a bureaucratic nightmare, one that has yet to end.

When they started clearing land on Winona Road, large hills were revealed throughout the lot, which an archaeologist neighbour advised them might be Indigenous gravesites.

"When first he told us, it was exciting … our original thought was, 'We're going to have burial mounds in our front yard for the rest of our lives,'" Dian Sutton says.

"We didn't really realize what that would mean, though."

The chief of the local First Nation — the Ts'elxwéyeqw Tribe — was called in. When David Jimmie first saw the mounds, he immediately felt his ancestors were buried there and that he had a responsibility to protect them.

Chief David Jimmie says the Ts'elxwéyeqw Tribe feels there should be no development at the Winona Road site near the Chilliwack River, and that the whole site needs the same protection as a modern cemetery. (Duncan McCue/CBC)

"You can't blame them [the Suttons] for wanting to build here," Jimmie says.

"That's a hard conversation to have, to go and tell them 'I'm sorry. This is our sacred site … we don't want to see any development here.'"

But it's an unfortunately common conversation in British Columbia, where heritage conservation laws have repeatedly pitted unwitting landowners against First Nations that are trying to stop their burial sites from being bulldozed.

Ancestor monuments

Prior to European contact, it was common for the Ts'elxwéyeqw and other Stó:lō tribes to bury their dead in earthen mounds, known as "ancestor monuments." Hundreds of burial mounds can be found throughout B.C.'s Fraser Valley, some mere bumps in the ground, others as tall as 2 metres.

Radiocarbon-dating of existing mounds suggests they range from between 1,000 to 1,500 years old. In more recent times, the Ts'elxwéyeqw shifted their funeral practices to using above-ground grave houses and wooden boxes in trees, eventually taking on the custom of church cemeteries.

As newcomers spread across the Chilliwack area, many of the ancient burial mounds disappeared under human settlements, which is why Jimmie felt so overwhelmed when the mounds were found at Winona Road.

"This is the history of our people in this territory," Jimmie says. "It's a feeling of connection, relating directly back to our ancestors here."

David Jimmie, chief of the Ts'elxwéyeqw Tribe, and CBC News reporter Duncan McCue visit burial mounds at the centre of a property dispute near the Chilliwack River in B.C. 0:21

Archaeologist Dave Schaepe of the Stó:lō Resource Management Centre in Chilliwack, an arm of the Stó:lō government that manages cultural and intellectual property, says everything points to it being a significant cultural site for the Ts'elxwéyeqw.

"We know features of that size contain an individual of very high status, people called 'siya:m.' They were mortuary markers for very senior leaders in the community," Schaepe says, adding that the mounds also contain rock alignments oriented toward the sun at summer solstice.

Development, Indigenous culture collide

When the mounds were identified at Winona Road, it meant B.C.'s Heritage Conservation Act kicked in.

The province keeps a registry of First Nations graves and spiritual sites. There are more than 54,000 archaeological sites in B.C., but that information isn't shown on land title documents, so a private landowner may not know they have an issue until they start to develop the property.

A survey conducted by the Stó:lō Resource Management Centre revealed 30 possible burial mounds at the Winona Road site, on the Suttons' empty lot and on two neighbouring properties as well.

As the Suttons' plan to build their dream home ground to a halt, neighbours Mike and Bev Prevost and Ed and Andra Tucker, retirees with existing houses on their lots, also got drawn into the conflict.

"We feel like we're caught between a rock and a hard place and we don't have a lifeline," Bev Prevost says.

Mike and Bev Prevost own land near B.C.'s Chilliwack River, and they've been drawn into a property dispute because of ancient burial mounds found in the area. 0:28

The Ts'elxwéyeqw insisted they did not want their ancestors disturbed. Months of wrangling over archaeology assessments turned into years. There were disputes over who should pay.

Finally, in 2017 an archaeologist was brought in to dig one of the mounds identified on the Tuckers' front lawn.

That report eventually confirmed the mound was a grave.

Last year the provincial government's Archaeology Branch, which decides whether permits can be issued for development in protected areas, declared all three properties contained designated archaeological sites that could not be disturbed. It imposed a one-to-three metre buffer zone around them.

The official designation means the Suttons, Tuckers and Prevosts can't alter the land without a permit, whether to build a home or fix a gas line. To get the permit, they must hire an archaeologist to do a survey. The government then consults the Ts'elxwéyeqw and can impose restrictions on development as it sees fit.

The landowners face large fines if any of the protected sites are disturbed, yet they continue to pay property taxes on the market value of the land.

With a burial mound in his front yard and artifacts in his backyard, 80-year-old Ed Tucker says realtors tell him his home, assessed at nearly $600,000, is now virtually impossible to sell.

An archaeologist investigated a mound on the Tuckers' front lawn in 2017 and confirmed it was a burial site. (Ed Tucker)

"The First Nations, it's their right to protect this. But the government should have done something way before now," Tucker says. "And the way they move, I figure we're up the creek without a paddle."

Mike and Bev Prevost, aged 79 and 66, say their home represents their life savings, assessed at $472,000 last year. They want the government to buy them out.

"Why do you penalize people so they're likely to never say anything if they find something? That's the sad part," Bev Prevost says. "We're not the only people that this is happening to."

Minister promises 'changes'

This month, the B.C. Ministry of Forests, Lands, Natural Resources Operations and Rural Development announced amendments to the Heritage Conservation Act, but there was no mention of a fund or process for landowners affected by heritage designations.

When contacted by CBC News, Forests Minister Doug Donaldson agreed the Act needs a "better system" of compensating landowners.

Donaldson says Archaeology Branch is consulting with First Nations, and he promises an "ancestral remains policy review" will result in changes to the law.

A 2015 survey revealed 30 possible burial mounds around the Winona Road site. (Stó:lō Resource Management Centre)

"Those changes will definitely involve much more rigorous outlines about compensation. Right now it [seeking compensation] is a one-off, it's ad-hoc, it involves having to go to Treasury Board," he says.

"That's just not the way to go into the future together with First Nations, and also recognize private property owner rights … we're focussing on it and going to be bringing in legislation within a year to address that larger picture."

Still, if John Glazema's experience with B.C.'s heritage laws is any indication, the Chilliwack landowners may be in for a long fight.

The B.C. developer has been embroiled in what he calls "endless process" after a 160-acre property his company planned to develop in Abbotsford, B.C., was identified as containing Indigenous mass graves.

Glazema and his partners say they had no knowledge of the cultural significance of the land to the Sumas First Nation when they bought it in 2011, as it wasn't listed on the property title.

"We trusted the investment in the 'fee simple' real estate. And we need to be protected," Glazema says.

John Glazema stands next to a mockup of a land development project design his company planned in Abbotsford, B.C. The development was stopped by the province when the 160-acre property was identified as containing Indigenous mass graves. (Duncan McCue/CBC)

In 2017, the province agreed to protect the gravesites, which Glazema says makes it impossible to sell the property. Yet his company is still paying the mortgage and property taxes.

Glazema and his partners are seeking to recover what they paid for the land — approximately $10 million — but says the government has only offered half that. He estimates he's spent nearly $1 million on lawyers, appraisers, archaeologists and consultants.

"We want to respect First Nations as far as contemplating digging up their gravesites. But at the end of the day, something has to be done," Glazema says.

"It's not the right way for B.C. taxpayers to be treated by the provincial government."

Multiple factors complicate compensation for Glazema's property, says Forests Minister Donaldson, "around zoning and the value of the land."

The B.C. Ministry of Indigenous Relations and Reconciliation is now handling negotiations.

'Bottomless pit of hell'

With most of their lot covered by burial mounds, the Suttons recently filed a notice of claim in B.C. Supreme Court seeking compensation for their property, assessed at $376,000, and for the anxiety they've suffered during five years of uncertainty.

"People that are purchasing property really need to know there is a potential bottomless pit of hell that you could be getting into," Beau Sutton says.

Beau and Dian Sutton recently filed a notice of claim in B.C. Supreme Court seeking compensation for their property, which has basically been rendered unmarketable since Indigenous burial mounds were discovered on the land. (Duncan McCue/CBC)

"The government doesn't have to do anything but wait us out. As private citizens, you only have so much money and ours is long gone," he adds.

The B.C. government has yet to file a response to the Suttons' lawsuit.

Minister Donaldson would only say, "Compensation discussions are underway, and those are confidential."

David Jimmie, chief of the Ts'elxwéyeqw Tribe, tells CBC News reporter Duncan McCue that ancient burial mounds must be protected, and that there needs to be a way to support property owners who are told they can't develop land they've bought. 0:20

Chief David Jimmie says the three landowners deserve fair treatment.

"Unfortunately, the homeowners there are out-of-pocket, trying to figure out their next steps. There needs to be an adequate process in supporting them through it."

And he insists the entire site needs the same protection as a modern cemetery.

"You do the right thing at the end of the day. It comes down to protection of remains."


Watch the story from The National about how B.C. legislation is pitting landowners and First Nations against each other when Indigenous artifacts and burial grounds are found on private property:

Thousands of sites in British Columbia are believed to be ancient First Nations burial grounds. Some are on private lands, and many Indigenous people believe these sites are sacred. But the government doesn't see the burial sites the same way as registered cemeteries, and that has left all parties frustrated and feeling vulnerable. 4:59


 

About the Author

Duncan McCue

CBC host and reporter

Duncan McCue is host of CBC Radio One's Cross Country Checkup and a correspondent for CBC's The National. He reported from Vancouver for over 15 years, and is now based in Toronto. During a Knight Fellowship at Stanford University in 2011, he created a guide for journalists called Reporting in Indigenous Communities. Duncan is Anishinaabe, a member of the Chippewas of Georgina Island First Nation.