British Columbia

Meng Wanzhou claims security detail placing her at risk of contracting COVID-19

Meng Wanzhou launched a bid to loosen her bail restrictions Monday in a B.C. Supreme Court hearing that provided a glimpse into the Huawei executive’s privileged pandemic lifestyle under 24-hour surveillance as she awaits extradition proceedings.

Head of security firm tasked with guarding Meng claims Huawei executive is breaking guidelines

Huawei chief financial officer Meng Wanzhou arrives at the B.C. Supreme Court with members of the security team, which she claims is placing her at risk of catching COVID-19. (Ben Nelms/CBC)

Meng Wanzhou launched a bid to loosen her bail restrictions on Monday in a B.C. Supreme Court hearing that provided a glimpse into the Huawei executive's privileged pandemic lifestyle under 24-hour surveillance as she awaits extradition proceedings.

The 48-year-old — who has survived thyroid cancer and has hypertension — claims the changing roster of security guards who accompany her everywhere during daylight hours is placing her at heightened risk of catching COVID-19.

The two-day hearing pits Meng, Huawei's chief financial officer, against the head of the company tasked by the court with preventing her from fleeing Canada pending a decision in her extradition case.

Lions Gate Risk Management president Doug Maynard said he believes Meng is still at risk of extraction by a foreign government and targeting by organized crime.

"We believe that the risk for some of those factors is actually rising," Maynard said.

"We're now two years on into this matter, and I would argue that because the opportunities are less frequent, the risk for that highest risk factor has actually risen somewhat."

Charged with fraud, conspiracy

Meng has lived under the same set of bail conditions since December 2018, when a judge released her from institutional custody pending extradition proceedings.

She's charged in New York with fraud and conspiracy in relation to allegations she lied to an HSBC executive about Huawei's control of a company accused of violating U.S. economic sanctions.

Meng and her husband, Liu Xiaozong, leave B.C. Supreme Court at an earlier court appearance. Liu recently testified on his wife's behalf in a bid to loosen the restrictions of her bail. (Darryl Dyck/The Canadian Press)

U.S. prosecutors claim Meng's alleged misrepresentations put the bank at risk of loss, because HSBC would be breaking the same set of sanctions in handling Huawei's financial transactions.

The daughter of Huawei's billionaire founder, Meng wears a GPS ankle monitoring bracelet and is confined to her home from 11 p.m. to 6 a.m. every day. But she is allowed to travel around the Lower Mainland alongside guards — who she pays for — during the day.

Quarantining together in apparent violation of guidelines

Her husband was the first witness at the recent hearing.

Liu Xiazong claimed the constant presence of guards is preventing his family from spending quality time together without attracting attention from strangers anxious to photograph the woman at the centre of the high-profile international court case.

Under cross-examination, Liu conceded that nothing in the bail conditions prevents Meng from going to malls, coffee shops and grocery stores with their two children.

He also admitted that, despite her confessed concerns about catching the coronavirus, Meng lived with him as he quarantined at their Vancouver mansion after arriving in Canada on a flight from Hong Kong last fall.

The same went for their kids when they flew to Canada before Christmas.

Canada's guidelines say you should avoid quarantining at home if you cannot separate yourself from those you live with.

'If she gets sick, we get sick'

Maynard, who was a Crown witness, said COVID-19 was as much a concern for him and his staff as it was for Meng and her family.

He said he has repeatedly expressed concern about the behaviour of Meng and her entourage during the pandemic.

WATCH | Meng Wanzhou arrives at B.C. Supreme Court on Jan. 12:

Meng Wanzhou arrives at B.C. Supreme Court on Jan. 12, 2021

2 years ago
Duration 0:50
The Huawei executive is applying to vary the strict release conditions in her bail agreement.

"If she gets sick, we get sick," Maynard said.

"I want to be careful not to be construed as the COVID police. We're there to ensure that our client is enforcing or adhering to the guidelines, because it's for their health and their safety protection, as well as our staff."

Maynard said Meng has intermingled her household bubble with the bubble of professional people who surround her, including Huawei employees and Chinese consular staff.

He said they have had gatherings in the past three months of around 10 people, where food and wine was shared in a restaurant closed for the occasion.

Meng has also had frequent trips downtown for "private shopping" sprees, Maynard said, where Vancouver's high-end retailers close their doors for her.

CBC photo entered into evidence

Much of the testimony concerned a picture taken by CBC photographer Ben Nelms of what was supposed to be a clandestine photo shoot with Meng's entourage on the courthouse steps last May in advance of the release of a court decision that could have ended the case.

The participants gave thumbs-up and flashed peace signs for a victory picture in the event of a win on the issue of double criminality — the concept that Meng's alleged offence would have to be a crime in both Canada and the U.S. for the extradition to go ahead.

None of them wore masks or physically distanced.

Meng along with friends and family flash peace signs as they stand on the steps of the B.C. Supreme Court in May in an image surreptitiously captured by a CBC photographer. Despite Meng's professed health concerns about COVID-19, none of those present were physically distancing. (Ben Nelms/CBC)

During the bail hearing, Crown attorney John Gibb-Carsley asked Meng's husband to count the 11 people in the photograph. 

"Does seeing this photo concern you that your wife, Ms. Meng, is not following protocols by being this close to others?" the Crown lawyer said.

"I don't exactly know what was the COVID-19 regulations in that time in British Columbia," Liu said.

Maynard said he disapproved of the photo shoot. The CBC learned of the event and Nelms and a reporter watched from across the street, hidden from view. The photograph was flashed around the world the following week.

Maynard said his staff spotted a number of passersby taking pictures during the brief shoot, and that they also noted people who appeared to be taking photographs from the sidewalk kitty-corner to the courthouse.

After the CBC broke the story, Maynard said his staff compared the angle of the spot where Meng's entourage took their photo to that of Nelms's image to confirm their suspicions about the possible presence of a photographer and reporter. 

Gibb-Carsley also revealed that a China Southern Boeing 777 was privately chartered to take Meng back to China immediately if she had won last May. 

He said members of the Chinese consulate were involved in making the arrangements to charter the plane, which can carry up to 368 people and has a large-enough fuel capacity to make the non-stop journey to China.

Rights violations

The extradition proceeding itself is expected to get underway at the beginning of March and to continue in various stages until the end of April.

The first part of the proceedings will involve a defence bid to have the case tossed because of alleged violations of Meng's rights. 

Her lawyers claim she is being used as a political pawn by U.S. President Donald Trump and they also say the Canada Border Services Agency and RCMP conspired with the U.S. Federal Bureau of Investigation at the time of her arrest to deny her access to a lawyer.

The defence also claims that the U.S. deliberately misled Canada about the strength of the case against Meng and is reaching beyond its jurisdiction to punish her.

The final part of the proceedings will be a test of the strength of the extradition request itself.


Jason Proctor


Jason Proctor is a reporter in British Columbia for CBC News and has covered the B.C. courts and the justice system extensively.

Add some “good” to your morning and evening.

A variety of newsletters you'll love, delivered straight to you.

Sign up now


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?