British Columbia

U.S. law allowing cruise ships to skip B.C. ports would set risky precedent: harbour authority

The CEO of the Greater Victoria Harbour Authority says legislation temporarily allowing international cruise ships to bypass B.C. ports feels like a dangerous precedent.

'You always worry about a temporary measure becoming permanent,' Greater Victoria Harbour Authority CEO says

Victoria's Ogden Point cruise ship terminal. Proposed legislation passed in the United States on Thursday applies to cruise ships travelling between Washington state and Alaska, giving them the green light to sail past B.C. ports without stopping. (Greater Victoria Harbour Authority/Facebook)

When the U.S. House of Representatives swiftly passed legislation amending a historical law that some say could have severe consequences for British Columbia's port communities, it came as little surprise to Ian Robertson.

The CEO of the Greater Victoria Harbour Authority said he tried to alert Canadian and B.C. politicians to the ramifications of the change that would temporarily allow international cruise ships to bypass the province's ports.

"I must admit it's been frustrating, we've been sounding the alarm for the past few months,'' Robertson said.

The proposed legislation passed Thursday applies to cruise ships travelling between Washington state and Alaska and gives them the green light to sail past B.C. ports without stopping, a requirement introduced more than a century ago to protect U.S. shipbuilders and operators.

The amendment is a response to Canada's ban on cruise ships through February 2022 to prevent the spread of COVID-19 and the legislation would only last as long.

However, given the estimated $2.7-billion economic impact of the cruise industry on the B.C. coast, Robertson said it feels like a dangerous precedent to set before exploring other options.

"You always worry about a temporary measure becoming permanent,'' Robertson said.

Victoria has the most to lose, alongside fellow transit port communities like Nanaimo and Prince Rupert, which benefit from the flood of tourists who spend in their communities during the stops. Vancouver, a "home'' port from which passengers start and finish cruises, is more insulated, he said.

The harbour authority wants the federal government to allow "technical calls,'' which would see the ships maintain the routine stops without allowing passengers and crew to leave the ship.

At the very least, they should be pushing for reassurances that the U.S. change will remain temporary, he said.

Before the pandemic, the cruise ship industry contributed more than $2.5 billion to B.C.'s economy. (The Canadian Press)

Alaskan senators 'disappointed' with Canadian leaders

The amendment will become law with President Joseph Biden's sign-off.

Two Alaskan senators pursued the change. Sen. Dan Sullivan, one of the bill's sponsors, said he was pleased to see bipartisan, unanimous support in the Senate after running into roadblocks trying to work with Canada.

"We've put forward a number of very reasonable suggestions to try to accommodate what we are hoping will be a fighting chance for our tourism season, for our small businesses so decimated by this pandemic to our colleagues in Canada,'' he said before the Senate.

"This is not the co-operative spirit that has defined the Alaska-Canadian relationship for decades. Quite frankly, we've been disappointed by it.''

Alaska Republican U.S. Sen. Dan Sullivan, centre, speaks to a joint session of the Alaska Legislature in Juneau on May 3. (Becky Bohrer/The Associated Press)

In a statement Wednesday, Transport Minister Omar Alghabra's office stood by the cruise ship ban, which he said allows public health officials to focus on more pressing issues.

"With the number of provinces battling a third wave of COVID-19 and the current public health situation, Canada is not at a point to safely resume cruise operations in our waters,'' the statement said.

B.C. premier arranging meeting with U.S.

Canada supports U.S. actions requiring that 98 per cent of crew and 95 per cent of passengers be vaccinated. Transport Canada will also reassess measures as the pandemic evolves and review all requests, including technical stops, in consultation with provincial and local health authorities, the statement added.

"Minister Alghabra has spoken a number of times with Senator Sullivan on the importance of cruise ships both to Canada and the United States, and how we can work together to safely welcome cruise ships when both countries are ready to do so,'' it said.

After brushing off the legislation as a "blip'' that wasn't likely to pass quickly, B.C. Premier John Horgan said Tuesday he was lining up meetings with U.S. officials to talk about it.

B.C. Premier John Horgan arrives before the budget speech from the legislative assembly in Victoria on April 20. (Chad Hipolito/The Canadian Press)

However, the senators who put forward the legislation made clear in their correspondences that it would be a temporary measure until border restrictions are lifted, he added.

"I'm taking great comfort in that, the legislation is specific about that,'' Horgan said.

If it would help maintain the industry in B.C. in the long term, he said he is also happy to talk about technical port calls.

The cruise industry's direct and indirect impacts in Canada totalled more than $4.2 billion in 2019, according to a tally by industry group Cruise Lines International Association.

The pandemic sunk those figures to zero in 2020 and the same losses are expected this year.

Donna Spalding, who works in government affairs and community relations for the Cruise Lines International Association, North West and Canada, said she couldn't predict if the temporary legislation could become permanent.

Despite being a transit stop, Victoria is considered a "premier'' destination and cruise lines consistently hear positive feedback from guests, including that they planned to return, she said.

But it would be up to each cruise line to determine if they saw a benefit in bypassing transit stops, if that were an option beyond the pandemic, she added.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?

now