British Columbia·Video

'It's the Wild West out here': Gulf Islanders raise alarm over too many whale-watching boats

Some residents of the southern Gulf Islands are worried too many whale-watching boats are chasing too few killer whales — stressing the already at-risk species.

Industry says it has voluntary guidelines but new federal regulations expected to be tougher

Some of the many boats which trailed a small pod of orcas recently near Saturna Island. (Facebook/Saturna Island Forum & Message Board)

Some residents of the southern Gulf Islands are worried too many whale-watching boats are chasing too few killer whales — stressing the already at-risk species.

"It's the Wild West out here on a Sunday and the orcas come by," says Susie Washington-Smyth, 75, of Saturna Island.

Fellow resident Mairead Boland, 65, agrees.

"Increasingly, they are pursued by a large number of boats," says Boland. "Once you've found them, you have them for a day. So it's an appalling situation for the whales."

Scientists fear vessel noise can interfere with killer whales' ability to hunt, navigate and communicate with each other, so researchers are studying into its impact. (Elaine Thompson/AP)

Residents report they've seen fleets of up to 25 vessels chasing orca pods during the busy summer months when whale watching is at its peak.

They say the problem is compounded because there are no regulations to govern the number of whale-watching boats permitted to track killer whales.

Commercial operators often share the location of pods, bringing in vessels from Vancouver, Steveston, Victoria and Friday Harbor on Washington's San Juan Island.

10 boats trailing one pod

A video shot on May 13 and supplied to CBC News shows at least 10 whale-watching vessels trailing a pod of six orcas.

Whale watching boats trail a pod of orcas near Saturna Island


3 years ago
The video, shot May 13, 2018, by a resident shows a large number of whale watching boats and commercial pleasure craft following the small pod. 0:42

The estimated 250 transient orcas in local waters are listed as threatened.

And 76 southern resident killer whales have been listed as endangered by both Canadian and U.S. authorities.

Resident killer whales subsist on dwindling Chinook salmon stocks, whereas transient orcas eat more plentiful marine mammals such as harbour seals.

In recent years, concerns have been raised by marine biologists about the effects of underwater sound on all orcas' ability to detect and locate prey, and communicate.

New regulations coming

Tough new marine mammal regulations are expected from the Canadian government in the fall.

In the meantime, the Pacific Whale Watching Association — representing the industry — has made changes to its voluntary guidelines.

A U.S. law enforcement patrol boat, right, is stopped near a recreational boat going past an orca whale in the Salish Sea in the San Juan Islands, where orca patrols ask vessels to give the sea mammals enough space. (Elaine Thompson/Associated Press)

"We are limiting a vessel to 60 minutes with any particular group of whales," says association president Jeff Friedman, who operates Maya's Legacy Whale Watching out of Friday Harbor. "And if there are 10 or more boats on scene, we suggest a limit of 30 minutes."

Friedman says his association is advising operators to keep 200 metres from southern resident killer whales and 100 metres from transients.

Jeff Friedman, president of the Pacific Whale Watching Association, says the industry has made changes to its voluntary guidelines to limit the amount of time boats follow a pod. (Jeff Friedman photo )

CBC provided Friedman with the video shot by concerned Saturna residents. He says the orcas were transients.

"[They're] very possibly some of the most successful whales on the planet right now. Their population is very robust and growing," says Friedman.

"All of the boats are obeying the distance regulations, and all of the boats looked like they were certainly doing less than seven knots," he says, referring to the maximum recommended speed near pods.

"I don't know that there are many studies, if any, that are showing the presence of boats having any impact," says Friedman.

DFO looking at acoustic impact

But the Canadian Department of Fisheries and Oceans (DFO) believes transient and resident killer whales should both be given the same 200-metre distance.

"One of the impacts that we're looking at [is] what may constitute too much noise over too long of a time frame," says Paul Cottrell, marine mammal response coordinator with the DFO.

While he says the industry has "very comprehensive" guidelines, he says the public should watch to make sure there are no infractions by commercial and recreational boaters.

Canada is coming up with new guidelines to keep boats further away from whales. (Elaine Thompson/AP)

"If there's something that's being seen that doesn't look right, we want to hear about it," says Cottrell. The DFO has a 24-hour marine mammal incident hotline.

Washington state forms task force 

Washington State is reviewing the plight of orcas in its waters.

In March, the governor created the Southern Resident Killer Whale task force to implement an "action plan for the recovery" of the orcas. And San Juan Island, home to Friedman's company, now has a voluntary no-go zone for whale-watching boats along its west coast.

Friedman insists his industry has only the best interests of the orcas at heart.

"This is our business — but our bottom line is the welfare of the whales," he says.

An orca whale breaches in view of Mount Baker in the San Juan Islands in 2015. (Elaine Thompson/Associated Press)

However, concerned Saturna Island residents believe the whale-watching industry itself needs to be closely watched.

"Step back, use smaller boats, less frequently" says Washington-Smyth. "They're not going to have a business in 10 years unless they do something like that."

Boland has her own warning.

"Whales are delightful, but they're going to be loved to death."


Eric Rankin

Investigative journalist

Eric Rankin is an award-winning CBC reporter. His honours include the 2018 Canadian Screen Award for Best Local Reportage, the 2017 and 2015 RTDNA awards for Best In-depth/Investigative Reporting, and the 2009 Jack Webster award for Best News Reporting.

With files from Manjula Dufresne


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversationCreate account

Already have an account?