British Columbia

Human error or mechanical failure? Mystery remains around Vancouver freighter collision

The M.V. Pan Acacia was left with a hole in its bow after it was struck by a vessel heading to get fuel.

M.V. Pan Acacia was left with a hole in its bow after it was struck by a vessel heading to fuel station

The M.V. Pan Acacia sustained a 20 centimetre hole in its bow after it was hit by the M.V. Caravos Harmony in Vancouver Harbour, according to the Transportation Safety Board. (Don Marce/CBC)

Since this story was first published, the Transport Safety Board of Canada has updated its information on the collision. Read the new story here: TSB finds 'significant' damage on freighter struck in Vancouver Harbour collision 

The Transportation Safety Board says it's still investigating whether a collision between two freighters in Vancouver Harbour early Sunday morning was the result of human error or a mechanical problem.

TSB marine investigation manager Mohan Raman told CBC that the M.V. Pan Acacia had a 20 centimetre hole torn in its bow when it was struck by the M.V. Caravos Harmony.

At the time of the collision, the Caravos Harmony was heading to a bunker station to fuel up. it was under its own power and was being operated by a pilot.

The Pan Acacia was at anchor.

"There's a big hole on the side of the Pan Acacia that needs to be repaired, though it is above the waterline," said Raman.

The M.V. Caravos Harmony was heading to a bunker fuel station when it struck the M.V. Pan Acacia early Sunday morning. (Don Marce/CBC)

No one was hurt in the collision and there was no reported pollution.

Raman said the Pan Acacia is a double hulled freighter and was empty of cargo when it was hit.

The Caravos Harmony was not damaged. Raman said he didn't know if it had cargo aboard. 

According to, the Caravos Harmony has left Vancouver for Incheon, South Korea.

The Pan Acacia remains anchored in Vancouver Harbour. Raman said both vessels would need approval from Transport Canada to leave. 

"If they allow [the Pan Acacia] to go elsewhere for repairs, they would have to give clearance first," he said.

The collision has raised questions about Vancouver Harbour safety, especially with oil tanker traffic through the waters set to increase by approximately 10-fold upon completion of the Trans Mountain pipeline expansion project.  

But Raman said he doesn't believe this incident means there's cause for concern. 

"I don't think it's unsafe. Ships come in and out all the time and there are separate channels for them to travel in," he said. "So it's not a free-for-all inside Vancouver Harbour. It could just be one of those things."

It's not known how long the TSB report will take to complete.

The M.V. Caravos Harmony is registered in the Marshall Islands and is listed as a 2013 bulk carrier. The M.V. Pan Acacia is a 2010-built cargo ship with Panamanian registration.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.