British Columbia

Restaurant owner targeted by coronavirus rumour bewildered by lies spread online

Lily Yung, owner of of Grand Crystal Seafood Restaurant in Burnaby's Crystal Mall, said a rumour involving an employee circulating on WeChat tanked her family's business in less than 24 hours.

WeChat message claimed an employee had the virus

Restaurant owner Lily Yung said she has lost 80 per cent of her business since a rumour about the virus COVID-19 started spreading on social media last weekend. (CBC News)

Lily Yung, owner of of the Grand Crystal Seafood Restaurant in Burnaby, B.C.'s Crystal Mall, says a 36-character WeChat message tanked her family's business in less than a day. 

The message claimed that one of the restaurant's employees was hit by the coronavirus known as COVID-19 and officials shut down the restaurant for 14 days. Neither of the claims were true.

"Vancouverites are already scared. Then you send out useless rumours and lies like this?" Yung told CBC News in Cantonese.

In the latest count from the World Health Organization, more than 73,000 people around the world have been diagnosed with COVID-19. Of those cases, 72,528 of them are in China. More than 1,800 people have died, three of them outside of China.

A friend sent Lily Yung of Grand Crystal Seafood Restaurant this screenshot of a WeChat message that had gone viral. In the second note, it says her restaurant located inside Crystal Mall in Burnaby had an employee that had contracted COVID-19. (Submitted by Lily Yung)

But in Canada, no one has died and only eight people have tested positive for the virus: five in B.C. and three in Ontario.

Health officials have repeatedly said the risk of contracting it in B.C. is very low.

80 per cent decline

Yung said nothing in the rumour was true, but by the time a friend alerted her to the message on Saturday afternoon, it had gone viral.

Business was already down in general because of coronavirus fears, but on Sunday she noticed a sudden drop of  about 80 per cent as customers called to cancel pricey banquet reservations.

It got so bad, she asked for special permission to post articles around the mall hoping to fight the lie.

"Very sad, so sad, because staff just lose the jobs," said Yung. 

She says only 10 of her 20 kitchen staff are now working and servers have also had their hours slashed.

Yung doesn't know why someone may have targeted her business, but it's a question she hopes to have answered.

Yung asked for permission to post articles around the mall saying her restaurant is still open. (CBC News)

Fear possibly driving profit

On Monday, health officials pleaded with the Chinese community to trust official sources.

"Sometimes there are alternative agendas for misinformation," said federal Health Minister Patty Hajdu at a press conference in Vancouver's Chinese Cultural Centre.

"People sometimes drive fear because ... they can drive a profit."

Hajdu and her provincial counterpart Adrian Dix, as well as Vancouver Mayor Kennedy Stewart held a roundtable after many in the community said they had lost anywhere from 50 to 70 per cent of their business during the outbreak.

All three levels of government asked the public to look to credible media sources and not to restrict social activities. 

Why rumours are rampant

But one University of British Columbia professor who has studied Chinese politics and culture for decades says the message isn't getting through. Part of it, he says, could be due to a mistrust in government.

"For people who immigrated from mainland China, this could be inherited behaviour because after the Cultural Revolution there have been issues with mistrust with each other, within the community and with the government," said political science professor Yves Tiberghien.

That mistrust can make social media rumours appear more believable, particularly, he says, when they're reinforced by family in China surrounded by dire news about COVID-19.

 "The stories are very real," says Tiberghien. "You talk to your mom, mom is stuck in quarantine [in China], you talk to dad and he is stuck and very grumpy ... whereas for other Canadians they may not have that connection."

He says that can make it appear as though Canadian officials are downplaying the situation.

No matter the level of fear, Yung is hoping her story will encourage everyone to think twice before sharing any rumours online.

"It might have been easy to send out, but it ruined a lot of lives," she said.

Earlier this week, federal health officials pleaded with the Chinese community to trust official sources rather than online discussions that have fueled fears of going out in public even though risks of COVID-19 are very low in Canada. (CBC News)

About the Author

Lien Yeung

@LienYeung

Lien Yeung hosts CBC Vancouver News Weekends. As a multimedia reporter, she has covered stories locally and nationally from coast to coast on television, radio and social media. You can reach her on Instagram or Twitter @LienYeung or via email at lien.yeung@cbc.ca.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.