British Columbia

'A child falling through the cracks': Teen failed by B.C. and Alberta child protection systems, report finds

Report into 2017 overdose death of troubled 17-year-old says the Ministry of Children and Families needs to act to protect vulnerable children from falling between the cracks in care as they're bounced between provinces.

'This boy and his family deserved much, much better,' says B.C.'s Representative for Children and Youth

B.C. Representative for Children and Youth Jennifer Charlesworth says more attention is needed for vulnerable children falling through the cracks of the system as they're shuttled between provinces. (InWithForward)

By the time "Romain" was 11 years old, he told social workers he already felt like he had been "passed around for 10 million years."

The troubled child had six more to go before he died of a fentanyl overdose in May 2017.

During that time, he was bounced between family members, care homes and youth custody facilities in both British Columbia and Alberta as relatives and social workers alike struggled to deal with his complex web of problems.

In a report released Tuesday, B.C. Representative for Children and Youth Jennifer Charlesworth described Romain as a "polite, kind and gentle soul" failed by child protection services whose inability to communicate left him without the services and attention he desperately needed.

And she called on B.C.'s Ministry of Children and Family Development (MCFD) to act to make sure more vulnerable "interprovincial children" don't fall through the cracks, as they're shuttled from province to province in search of a home.

"This boy and his family deserved much, much better," Charlesworth said, in a news release accompanying her report.

"The best interests of Romain were not fully considered and acted upon, and the result was as predictable as it was tragic."

'A predictably precarious situation'

Charlesworth's report — Caught in the Middle — makes six recommendations related to both the process through which children in care are moved from province to province and the way in which the MCFD handles questions about ethnicity and trauma as they relate to vulnerable young people.

Romain is a pseudonym for the teenager who died of a fentanyl overdose in May 2017 while placed in an emergency staffed residential home in B.C.

Children and Family Development Minister Katrine Conroy says work is already underway on most of the recommendations in Charlesworth's report. (CBC )

He was diagnosed and medicated for psychiatric disorders that saw him act out in violent and unpredictable ways that became too much for family members to handle alone.

He developed substance abuse problems and exhibited suicidal behaviour and ultimately came into conflict with the youth criminal justice system.

Romain was first moved to B.C. at the age of 13 when Children's Services in Alberta placed him with a female relative.

But Alberta didn't follow a protocol between the provinces that would have required it to give the MCFD notice.

"This was the first in a string of miscommunications and dropped handoffs between the two provinces that culminated when, despite Alberta's informal agreement to fund a highly specialized residential resource for Romain four years later, was never confirmed in the interprovincial agreement," the report says.

"No action was taken by B.C. to create that resource, leaving the teen in a predictably precarious situation and contributing to the events that led to his death."

'Confusion, miscommunication and discord'

Charlesworth's report says that interprovincial cases are rare for social workers but have resulted in previous tragedies, including a case in 2013 when Calgary paramedics found 15-year-old Alex Radita dead from complications related to untreated diabetes and starvation.

His parents were later convicted of first-degree murder in his death.

"A contributing factor to Alex's deteriorating health was the fact the family had relocated from B.C. to Alberta in an effort to avoid child welfare involvement," a report into his death said. 

"There was insufficient child welfare followup by B.C. or notification to Alberta following Alex's relocation."

Alex Radita, 15, weighed less than 40 pounds when he died. His parents, Emil and Rodica, were convicted of first-degree murder in his death. (Left:Court exhibit Right:CBC)

In another case investigated by Charlesworth's predecessor, a young Indigenous girl was confined to a windowless basement room in Saskatchewan after being placed with a maternal grandfather, despite his lengthy criminal history.

The B.C. representative can't make findings about Alberta's role in the events that led to Romain's death, but Charlesworth said she wants to see the MCFD take a leadership role in improving the protocol that governs the movement of children between provinces and territories.

She also called on the ministry to dedicate a co-ordinator tasked with supporting, tracing and monitoring interprovincial cases.

"This investigation pointed to a child falling through the cracks and his best interests getting lost in confusion, miscommunication and discord between provincial child welfare authorities," her report says.

A need for greater accountability

The report quotes B.C.'s deputy director of child welfare, who said: "We've taken our eyes off the ball ... Likely this report will put it on the front burner again."

In a statement, Children and Family Development Minister Katrine Conroy said work is already underway to address several of the key issues contained in the report, including the appointment of a co-ordinator to oversee interprovincial cases.

"It is clear to me that there must be greater accountability centrally and more hands-on support from this office to assist staff on the ground when it comes to managing interprovincial cases," the statement said.

"What is most disheartening for me as minister is to be making changes after the fact, in the wake of a young life that was filled with trauma and abuse."

About the Author

Jason Proctor

@proctor_jason

Jason Proctor is a reporter in British Columbia for CBC News and has covered the B.C. courts and mental health issues in the justice system extensively.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

now