British Columbia

After 2 toddlers' deaths, B.C. doctor wants action to prevent children falling from windows

A pediatric neurosurgeon in British Columbia is urging caregivers to take steps to prevent children from falling from windows and balconies after two kids have died from their injuries so far this year.

8 children have required emergency care at B.C. Children's Hospital so far this year, neurosurgeon says

A low-rise apartment building in B.C. Doctors and health-care providers are urging parents to keep children away from open windows and balconies to prevent falls as the weather warms. (Shutterstock/Roman Makedonsky)

A pediatric neurosurgeon in British Columbia is urging caregivers to take steps to prevent children from falling from windows and balconies following the deaths of two toddlers so far this year.

Dr. Ash Singhal of B.C. Children's Hospital said it's also the provincial government's responsibility to change the building code so windows in homes can't be opened enough for young children to tumble out.

A total of eight children have required emergency medical care at the hospital this year, he said, adding the two who died were under the age of four.

Across the country, an estimated 420 children are treated in emergency departments every year for injuries related to falls from a second storey or higher, according to the Canada Safety Council.

"This is an enormous tragedy for kids and families and its effects often can cause very severe brain injuries, spinal cord injuries, smashed faces and the like,'' Singhal said.

"And in many of the kids who survive, it's a life-altering event and it alters the life of the entire family, who now has a child with a lot of medical needs.''

Some children fall through window screens that may seem like a barrier, or when their natural curiosity has them climbing onto furniture and leaning out a window or tumbling over a balcony railing, he said.

"Because of the way kids are, with their heads being much larger than the rest of their bodies, relatively speaking, they often end up being top heavy and they hit their heads or their necks, or the top part of their bodies, when they hit the ground.''

Children can climb before they can crawl

Caregivers should keep in mind that children can climb before they can crawl so it's important to take early measures to prevent falls by keeping furniture including side tables away from windows and putting away stools that kids could move in front of windows, Singhal said.

"It's natural to have nice furniture on your balcony. That's the whole point of having a balcony, to enjoy the nice weather. But you've got to be able to put it away or set it up in such a way that a kid cannot drag the furniture to the railing of a balcony," he said

Dr. Ash Singhal, a pediatric neurosurgeon at B.C. Children's Hospital, said some children fall after climbing onto furniture and leaning out a window, or tumbling over a balcony railing. (CBC)

He also advised parents to place latches on windows so they can't be opened past about 10 centimetres.

However, Singhal said he's counting on the province to require the construction industry to restrict the opening of windows in single-family homes to a few centimetres so kids can't fall through them.

"There's no such regulation that demands that a window be equipped with an inexpensive safety device prior to getting a certificate of completion,'' he said.

Push for changes to national building code

Ulrik Seward, chief building official with the City of Calgary, said the municipality took the lead across the country in 2016 to try to get the national building code changed to make windows in single-family homes safer for children.

The city worked with an emergency room doctor who had seen far too many injured children ending up in hospital, he said, adding 15 per cent of major trauma patients at Alberta Children's Hospital that year had fallen out of windows.

The National Research Council accepted Calgary's proposal last year but publication of the latest requirements has been stalled due to the pandemic, Seward said.

"It's up to each individual province to decide how they're going to handle the building codes,'' he said, adding the Alberta government will adopt the national code within a year of it being published.

The entrance to B.C. Children's Hospital, with a smiley face.
An estimated 420 children are treated in emergency departments every year for injuries related to falls from a second storey or higher, according to the Canada Safety Council. (Maggie MacPherson/CBC)

"The problem with the code as it is today is that for windows that are on second or higher floors of a single-family home, there are no real requirements for how high that window has to be off the ground or whether that window has to be restricted from opening a certain distance,'' he said.

The new national building code would require that either the sill is no less than 0.9 metres above a finished floor or that the opening of the window is permanently restricted to no more than 10 centimetres for new homes or when new windows are installed, Seward said.

B.C.'s Ministry of the Attorney General, which is responsible for the building code, did not immediately respond to questions about whether the construction industry would be required to adopt the new national building code.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?

now