Bottle diggers unearth stash of Hotel Vancouver silverware believed to be over 80 years old
121 intact pieces stamped with hotel's insignia found in Vancouver forest
On a cold, wet day in late December, Christian Laub and Julien Hicks slogged their way through a Vancouver forest in pursuit of a hot tip.
Hicks, an actor by trade and newcomer to the hobby of bottle digging, had learned of an old abandoned car in the area.
Hicks had enlisted Laub, a film location scout with years of bottle digging experience, who knew that where there was an old car, there were often antique bottles to be found.
Once at the secret site, however, the two stumbled upon something completely surprising: a treasure trove of historic silverware from the Hotel Vancouver, possibly dating back over 80 years, buried near a rotting tree stump.
Video posted on social media captures the moment when Hicks hits the mother lode and starts pulling handful after handful of the utensils out of the dirt.
"We've just hit a hot pocket," narrates Laub. "This never happens. It's a whole stash of Hotel Vancouver silverware!"
The pair extracted 121 fully intact pieces and a few broken ones — soup spoons, teaspoons, pickle forks, regular forks, knives and ladles — all with an old Hotel Vancouver insignia clearly stamped in the silver plating.
"The experience of reaching your hand in a hole and pulling out a bunch of close to 100-year-old forks and knives, it's once in a lifetime," said Hicks.
"I thought we were gonna have to fight over who got the first piece of cutlery, and then I kept finding more and more and more."
At first, Laub estimated the silverware dated back to the 1920s.
But a little research revealed a provenance of 1939 or later, when construction of the Hotel Vancouver that still exists today at the corner of Burrard and Georgia streets was finally completed after a five-year delay during the Great Depression.
"The logo, which says Hotel Vancouver, is a mimic of the Canadian National logo of the time," said Laub. "Canadian Pacific ... joined forces with Canadian National and the two [companies] completed the hotel in time for the King and Queen's visit to Canada in 1939."
The Hotel Vancouver has confirmed the approximate age of the silverware. Laub and Hicks won't reveal exactly where they found the stash, only saying it was from land near the University of British Columbia.
How it ended up there is a mystery of history.
"It wasn't just recklessly discarded, it was carefully put there," said Laub. "But the question is why?
"We've come to two conclusions: it was either put there purposely for somebody to find in the future, as we did, or somebody stole it and stashed it for a rainy day and then something happened to that person, or they forgot about it."
After an initial cleaning, a few of the pieces looked to be in good condition. Many, however, have some damage, although not nearly what would be expected for being buried in a rainforest for untold decades.
Hicks chalks it up to the fact that the stash was found underneath a car section that had kept it dry all these years.
Collectors of Vancouver history have already started inquiring about buying the find. Laub estimates a single piece in good condition has a market value of around $30 to $40. But not all of the silverware is for sale.
"We've already decided we're both going to keep one set for ourselves and we're offering one set to the hotel for their archives," said Laub.
To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.
By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.
Become a CBC Account Holder
Join the conversation Create account
Already have an account?