British Columbia

B.C. woman who suffered stroke waited over an hour for an ambulance. Now she's partially paralyzed

The family of a woman who was left paralyzed after suffering a stroke is asking for answers as to why she waited more than an hour for an ambulance to take her to the hospital.

Family wants answers about ambulance delay, B.C. Emergency Health Services says it's reviewing the call

Lorrie Williams smiles at the camera. She is a white woman with blonde hair, and sunglasses atop her head.
Lorrie Williams, a former New Westminster city councillor, is paralyzed on the left side of her body after suffering a stroke on Aug. 6. (Submitted by Allan Greenwood)

This story is part of Situation Critical, a series from CBC British Columbia reporting on the barriers people in this province face in accessing timely and appropriate health care.

The family of a woman who was left paralyzed after suffering a stroke is asking for answers as to why she waited more than an hour for an ambulance to take her to the hospital.

Former New Westminster city councillor Lorrie Williams has been at Royal Columbian Hospital since Aug. 6.

Her brother, Allan Greenwood, is angry at the delay in transporting her to the hospital which he believes is responsible for her partial paralysis.

"Next to a heart attack stroke is the thing where you [have] to act quick and there's brain cells dying every second," he said.

"Now she's in a hospital bed and she's partially paralyzed and we don't know the outcome."

Allan Greenwood looks at the camera. He is a white man with greying hair and glasses.
Allan Greenwood wants answers from B.C. Emergency Health Services and the province about why it took over an hour for an ambulance to respond to his sister's stroke. (Nick Allan/CBC)

Williams was with a friend, who is a retired doctor, when she suffered the stroke.

CBC News spoke with the friend, who did not want to be interviewed on camera but provided details about how events unfolded.

The friend, who was staying with Williams, says the retired city councillor was sitting on the couch when the friend noticed her speech became slurred.

When she turned back, the friend saw that Williams' face was drooping and her body was swaying to the left so she grabbed her by the shoulders and said, "Lorrie, you're having a stroke." The friend called 911 immediately.

Over the next hour and a half, Williams lay on the floor as the friend and two neighbours tried to comfort her and manage her symptoms.

The friend says they called 911 repeatedly to get an ambulance and were told it was on its way.

In an emailed statement to CBC News, B.C. Emergency Health Services (EHS) confirmed they received a call at 8:09 p.m. to respond to a patient in New Westminster in the 400-block of Kelly Street, where Williams lives.

It said at the time, many paramedics were responding to other urgent medical emergencies in the area and the first ambulance that became available was dispatched.

It also said that during the response period, B.C. EHS was alerted that the patient's condition had changed and the call priority was upgraded. According to EHS, paramedics arrived within four minutes of that upgrade, and were on scene at 9:18 p.m.

EHS apologizes for delay

Greenwood says his sister's friend and neighbours thought about taking her to Royal Columbian Hospital themselves, which is a few blocks away from Williams' home, but kept hoping the ambulance would arrive soon.

He says paramedics finally arrived and transported his sister to Royal Columbian Hospital for surgery two hours after the initial 911 call.

"I don't blame the ambulance people here," said Greenwood. "There's something wrong with the system at this point ... How is it that when you really need an ambulance, it takes two hours to get one now?"

EHS says it's reviewing their response to the call. "We know it's stressful when someone who needs an ambulance is waiting for one and we apologize to the patient and their family for the delay," reads their statement.

Former councillor still in hospital

Before her stroke, Williams was an active 81-year-old. She lived independently and cared for her dogs and cats. When her house caught fire in the early hours of July 14, Greenwood says his sister jumped out of bed, ran out to the backyard and started fighting the fire herself with a garden hose.

A former city councillor in New Westminster for 16 years, Williams remains well-known and well-liked in the community. In 2019, she was named New Westminster's citizen of the year.

"She had it all going on and was travelling and had her pets and a wide range of friends and [she] was very active in the community," said her brother.

Lorrie Williams smiles as she sits at a table in a restaurant.
Lorrie Williams was a New Westminster city councillor for 16 years and was active in the community until her stroke in August. (Submitted by Allan Greenwood)

Williams is still in the hospital and while her condition has improved enough for her to sit up in bed, Greenwood says she may use a wheelchair for the rest of her life.

"It looks like she needs assisted care the rest of her life, and that's probably a direct result of the delay in getting her to the hospital," he said.

Union says delays due to staff shortages

Greenwood says it's common knowledge that rapid medical intervention is critical for stroke patients.

TV ads refer to the acronym F.A.S.T. to remind people of the symptoms that should trigger a 911 call.

"I'm angry at the people who get paid to look out for the system, who aren't doing their job, who allowed it to get to this condition," he said.

An ambulance with the word 'AMBULANCE' written in reverse font.
An ambulance is pictured in downtown Vancouver, B.C. on Monday, June 27. (Ben Nelms/CBC)

The union representing ambulance paramedics in B.C. has been sounding the alarm over staffing shortages for years.

"It's really disturbing to hear of these delays and we continue to hear of them and particularly in what could be a life-threatening emergency like that when somebody had to wait that time frame in their time of need, that's unacceptable," said Troy Clifford, president of the Ambulance Paramedics and Emergency Dispatchers of B.C.

He says staffing shortages are largely the result of wage disparities between paramedics and other public safety jobs like police, fire and health.

In 2016, B.C. Emergency Health Services set a target of responding to the most critical patients in Metro Vancouver within nine minutes at least 75 per cent of the time by 2020.

CBC News reached out to the Ministry of Health to ask why ambulance delays continue to exceed target response times. Despite having over 48 hours notice to respond, the ministry did not respond in time for publication, citing a media blackout due to the Queen's passing.

Meanwhile, Greenwood says his sister's experience has completely shaken his confidence in ambulance emergency services.

"This is evidently a new ball game where the ambulance isn't going to be there and you kind of have to take matters into your own hands and that's certainly what I would do if this situation came up again."

Join us for a virtual town hall about the health care crisis in B.C.

Emergency room closures. Family doctor shortages. Wait times with devastating consequences. Staffing issues and unhealthy work environments. British Columbia is in a health care crisis, and the province's rural communities are suffering the most. 

Join us for Situation Critical: a free, online public town hall on September 20 that will address the current state of health care, what's not working and what needs to change. 

You can listen to the town hall on CBC Radio One across the province, watch on CBC TV and live stream the town hall on CBC GemYouTubeFacebook and cbc.ca/bc.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Eva Uguen-Csenge is a multimedia reporter for CBC News in Vancouver with an interest in investigative and data-driven stories. Get in touch with her at eva.uguen-csenge@cbc.ca or on Twitter @evacsenge for story tips.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?

now